Palatability of Interventions for Good Self-Nudging Complementarities in Food Environments Using an Experimental Online Supermarket

How to cite

Ferris, Adam; Lohmann, Paul; Clark, Michael. 2025. "Palatability of Interventions for Good Self-Nudging Complementarities in Food Environments Using an Experimental Online Supermarket." AEA RCT Registry. AEARCTR-0015869. https://doi.org/10.1257/rct.15869-1.2

Download: BibTeX · RIS — for reference managers without a browser translator. Zotero and most others pick up this page's citation metadata directly.

Adam Ferris* , Paul Lohmann , Michael Clark

* Primary investigator

Registry ID
AEARCTR-0015869
DOI
https://doi.org/10.1257/rct.15869-1.2
First registered
Last updated
Status
Completed
Trial dates
2025-04-24 – 2025-05-01
Countries
United Kingdom of Great Britain and Northern Ireland ()
Registry record
http://www.socialscienceregistry.org/trials/15869

Abstract

We consider whether a salient action-identity cue can be used to increase self-nudging into different choice environments. Specifically, we test whether a consumers can be convinced to change their online supermarket ‘Sort by’ ranking from standard to an eco-ranking (from most to least environmentally-friendly). We also study the follow-through and effect of the changed product ‘Sorting’ order on grocery shopping baskets’ environmental scores. This study is designed as a framed field experiment and will utilise a difference-in-differences approach to estimate the causal effect of the interventions. We will also explore theoretical mechanisms underlying the effects and conduct heterogeneity analysis of individual specifics such as demographic and preference elicitation factors, as well as consumer preferences. For example, we explore a distinction between consumers with high and low search efforts (in week 1) and the relative effect of ‘sort by’ interventions. We also consider whether the identity-action cue also affects green-identity self-belief, and based on propositions by Benabou and Tirole (2011), how the shift is moderated by each participants baseline belief of green identity.

Intervention

Prior to week 2, participants will be randomly assigned to one of three treatment arms:
The three treatment arms, applied in week 2, are (and described in chronological order):
1. Effect of MPL (Control): MPL (no action identity cue) – Control.
2. Effect of Cue on MPL and behaviour: Action-Identity Cue + MPL
3. Effect of Cue on behaviour: MPL + Action-Identity Cue.

Two treatment arms of our experiment design will include an “action-identity link” informational cue (Tonke, 2025). The other will not include any identity cue. In all three treatment arms, participants are asked to go give their (incentive-compatible) willingness to pay between two online grocery shop formats. One is the standard layout of searched grocery items, the other format has all goods searched for sorted by their eco scores (Clark, 2022), from most eco to least. Participants then will undertake a typical weekly shop on an experimental online grocery shopping platform, Woods (https://woodssupermarket.co.uk). For each participant the Woods ‘sort by’ layout will be allocated based on the willingness to pay choices they previously declared in the Multiple Price List (same way as Epperson and Gerster, 2024).

Experimental design

Similar to (Panzone et al., 2021a, 2021b; Zizzo, 2010), we will employ a between and within-subject experimental design, where participants are recruited to shop twice on our simulated grocery store. Week 1 serves as a baseline, where all participants are asked to do a weekly shop on the platform. Participants will then be randomised into one of 3 conditions using a stratified randomisation procedure and will be invited to complete a second survey and shopping task in the following week. Importantly, our experimental design will be incentive-compatible and can be classified as a framed field experiment (List, 2011).
A UK adult (18+) representative (as defined by Prolific) population sample, and pre-screened by Prolific for diet (to avoid participants with strict dietary requirements, such as veganism, Halal or Kosher requirements), online shopper (to select those that interact with online grocery shopping at least a few times a year) and primary household shopper (to get the main grocery shoppers) is initially recruited through the Prolific recruitment platform. We will also track whether individuals have other dietaries (vegetarianism, food allergies and intolerances, whom we might exclude from our main analysis at a later date.

Design details

Randomization method
To allocate the participants to one of the 3 treatment arms in week 2, we use a stratified randomisation technique, based on gender and eco score of participants’ week 1 shopping task baskets (as terciles of the basket eco scores).
Randomization unit
The unit of randomisation is at the individual level.
Clusters
N/A
Observations
We collect 2-week data (from 2 pre- and post-shop surveys and two shopping tasks) from c.900 participants (not recruitment number) for the whole experiment (spread over 3 treatments). This sample size is based on previous papers of a similar nature and power calculation simulations for linear and log-linear difference-in-difference (detail below) and for unbalanced cross-sectional regression analysis (where the treated arm needs 300 people). This does not covers likely non-completion of the survey and experiments, attrition across the two-week study, comprehension and attention check failures, and budgetary constraints.
Arms
The recruitment sample size collected for week 1 is 345 participants per treatment arm. This sample size is based on previous papers of a similar nature and power calculations. This accounts for non-completion and attrition in the range of c.15% across the two-week study.
Primary outcomes
Primary Outcomes (end points): This study has two main outcome variables. First primary variable: The willingness to pay from each participant to have the grocery item menu ‘sorted by’ the standard format (based on order of appearance in the background grocery dataset) or from most to least eco-friendly on an incentivised online platform supermarket (https://woodssupermarket.co.uk). The willingness to pay is elicited through a Multiple Price List following Epperson and Gerster (2024). Second primary variable: Eco-score of the final shopping baskets from Week 1 (pre-intervention baseline) and Week 2 (post-intervention treatment) based on the final product choices made by all participants in both weeks (in a shopping budget of £25-50). Eco-scores are based on calculations by Clark et al. (2022). The final basket eco scores will be re-balanced per 100g of produce bought and per GBP spent.
Secondary outcomes
Our experiment includes two secondary variables. We capture Green Consumer Identity through a series of statements to which participants indicate their degree of agreement (following Guiidetti et al, 2023). The identity measures are given after the shopping tasks in week 1 and 2. Our other secondary variable measured in both week 1 and 2, is search effort in the shopping task (based on time spent going through the shopping platform). Through the experimental online supermarket platform and the survey platform, we will get these two separate measures for each participant each week. In addition to these two key secondary variables, we collect data on socio-demographics (age, income, weekly grocery expenditure, children education, etc). We also collect preference elicitation data for the cognitive reflection test, locus of control, self-control.

Cited by

No citation data available for this registration yet.

Keywords