Referrals, Cooperation, and Competition
How to cite
Munoz, Manuel. 2025. "Referrals, Cooperation, and Competition." AEA RCT Registry. AEARCTR-0015842. https://doi.org/10.1257/rct.15842-1.0
Download: BibTeX · RIS — for reference managers without a browser translator. Zotero and most others pick up this page's citation metadata directly.
* Primary investigator
Abstract
This study investigates how referral sources (vertical referrals, horizontal referral, or direct invitation) influence students' choices regarding cooperation and competition in an application process for a university excellence award. Using an online real-effort task (counting ones in 4x4 matrices), students complete the task individually, then in a cooperative and competitive format. Participants probabilistically select their preferred referral source to be matched with, allowing the measurement of revealed preferences and belief-driven behavior. The order of cooperation and competition tasks is randomized across participants.
Intervention
Participants are invited to apply for the Academic Excellence Award through one of three channels:
- Faculty Referral: Recommended by university faculty.
- Peer Referral: Recommended by another student applicant.
- Direct Invitation: Invited directly by the university without referral.
The third stage of the application process consists of:
1. Belief Elicitation: Participants estimate participation and average performance by referral group.
2. Real-Effort Tasks:
- Part B: Individual task (1 min), earns 1 point per correct answer.
- Part C: Competition task (1 min); participants probabilistically assign chances to be paired with a competitor from each referral group.
Winner earns 2 points per correct answer; loser earns 0.5.
- Part D: Cooperation task (1 min); participants assign chances to be paired with a teammate from each referral group. Team score is
average number of correct answers × 1.5.
- The order of competition and cooperation is randomized across participants.
Experimental design
The expected number of participants to reach this stage of the application process and thus participate in the experiment is about 1020. The number from each group is expected to be:
- Faculty referred: ~127
- Peer referred: ~ 173
- Directly invited: ~ 720
Participants are randomly assigned (stratified by referral source) to one of two task sequences:
- Sequence 1: Cooperation → Competition
- Sequence 2: Competition → Cooperation
This design controls for order effects and enables estimation of how referral identity affects preference in collaborative versus competitive settings.
The primary outcomes focus on partner/competitor selection and belief accuracy. I will test the following hypotheses:
Hypothesis 1 (Competition): Participants are more likely to allocate probabilities to compete against applicants directly invited or referred by peers rather than those referred by faculty.
H1 reflects expectations about lower ability of peer/direct-invite groups compared to faculty referrals.
Hypothesis 2 (Cooperation): Participants are more likely to allocate probabilities to cooperate with applicants referred by faculty rather than peers or direct invites.
H2 reflects expectations about higher ability or greater trustworthiness among faculty referrals.
Hypothesis 3 (Referral homophily): Participants are more likely to assign higher probabilities to partners/competitors who share the same referral source as themselves (faculty referred select faculty, peer referred select peer, etc.).
H3 tests if homophiily is a heuristic driving selection and whether it is stronger than following the reported beliefs.
Hypothesis 4 (Belief-driven choice): Participants’ selections (probability allocations) will be positively correlated with their stated beliefs about the performance of each group.
Hypothesis 5 (Null order effects): The order in which competition and cooperation tasks are completed will not significantly affect partner/competitor selection patterns.
Design details
Cited by
No citation data available for this registration yet.