Heterogeneous Impacts of Financial Incentives on Math Test Performance by Ethnicity : Jewish Secular, Arab and Jewish Ultra - Orthodox

How to cite

Zamshman, Nelly; Kaplan, Todd R.; Ofek-Shanny, Yuval. 2025. "Heterogeneous Impacts of Financial Incentives on Math Test Performance by Ethnicity : Jewish Secular, Arab and Jewish Ultra - Orthodox." AEA RCT Registry. AEARCTR-0015841. https://doi.org/10.1257/rct.15841-1.0

Download: BibTeX · RIS — for reference managers without a browser translator. Zotero and most others pick up this page's citation metadata directly.

Nelly Zamshman* , Todd R. Kaplan , Yuval Ofek-Shanny

* Primary investigator

Registry ID
AEARCTR-0015841
DOI
https://doi.org/10.1257/rct.15841-1.0
First registered
Last updated
Status
On going
Trial dates
2025-04-06 – 2025-06-30
Countries
Private
Registry record
http://www.socialscienceregistry.org/trials/15841

Abstract

Behavioral economics recognizes that decision-making is influenced by various cognitive biases, social factors, emotions, etc. Incentives are a field whose development owes much to the contribution of economists, psychologists and researchers from different disciplines. This inter-disciplinary input reflects a broader understanding of human behavior and explains the influence of incentives on motivation, which is not solely driven by the desire to maximize profit. In behavioral economics, incentives are seen as tools that shape behavior, of both adults and children. Incentives have also been studied in the field of education. Research has investigated the impact of different types of incentives on the learning performance of students of varying ages. Previous studies found that the effect of incentives can be either positive or negative, depending on variables such as the type of the incentive, the timing of the incentive, the age of the recipient, religious affiliation, and more. This research will examine the extent to which financial incentives affect performance in mathematics tests among secondary-school students from Jewish Secular, Arab and Jewish Ultra - Orthodox ethnicities in Israel. Approximately 270 students will participate, with around 90 students from each ethnicity, equally distributed between genders. The research assumption is that differences will be found in how financial incentives affect different populations due to varying perceptions of the concept of “money”. Additionally, there is evidence of differences in the perception of incentives resulting from the Big Five personality traits. Therefore, this research will also explore the influence of these traits on the effectiveness of incentives. Quantitative data collection tools will be utilized for this research.

Experimental design

The research will be conducted in Israel, across four secondary schools, during regular school hours.
Approximately 270 students will participate in the study, with equal representation from three sectors (Jewish, Arab, and Haredi) and balanced gender distribution.
Each student will complete three mathematics tests in a multiple-choice format. The tests will be similar in structure and difficulty but will differ in terms of the incentive condition:
Test 1 – conducted without any financial incentive.
Test 2 – includes an individual financial incentive, in the form of a voucher for purchasing educational items. The value of the incentive will also be influenced by the class’s overall performance.
Test 3 – includes a group financial incentive designated for a shared class activity. The incentive amount will be determined based on the class’s collective performance.
The tests will be conducted in the students’ native language (Hebrew or Arabic) using tablets provided in advance. Before each test, students will receive instructions in their native language and will be informed that the tests are for research purposes only and will not affect their school grades.
Before beginning the series of tests, students will complete a questionnaire assessing their attitudes toward money and their personality traits based on the Big Five model. The questionnaires will be available in both Hebrew and Arabic.

Design details

Randomization method
In each sector, four classes will participate. The first test will be administered uniformly to all classes without any incentive. The assignment of the second and third test conditions (individual incentive vs. group incentive) will be determined by a coin flip for each class.
Randomization unit
The unit of randomization is the class. Each class is randomly assigned to one of the two incentive conditions (individual or group) using a coin flip. All students within a class receive the same condition.Randomization Unit: Class.
Clusters
The randomization is done at the class level, with each class being treated as a separate unit. A total of 12 classes (4 from each of the 3 sectors) are randomly assigned to different treatment conditions.
Observations
Each student will participate in 3 tests, resulting in 810 observations in total (270 students × 3 tests).
Arms
This study employs a within-subjects experimental design in which each student will participate in all three test conditions. A total of 270 students will be included in the study, with approximately 90 students from each ethnicity . Since each student completes all three tests, the total number of test observations will be 810 (270 students × 3 tests).
Primary outcomes
The key outcome variable is mathematics test performance among secondary -school students. This performance will be measured after implementing two types of financial incentives: individual-based and group-based. The study aims to explore how this outcome is influenced by: Ethnic background, based on the assumption that different groups may have varying cultural perceptions of money. Big Five personality traits, which are expected to moderate the effectiveness of incentives. Additionally, the research will consider how students’ perceptions of the concept of money relate to their motivation and performance, serving as a possible explanatory factor for differences in responsiveness to incentives.

Cited by

No citation data available for this registration yet.

Keywords