The effect of perceived prosocial impact on the relationship between monetary incentives and prosocial work

How to cite

Gafni, Hadar; Jeppesen, Lars Bo. 2025. "The effect of perceived prosocial impact on the relationship between monetary incentives and prosocial work." AEA RCT Registry. AEARCTR-0015825. https://doi.org/10.1257/rct.15825-1.0

Download: BibTeX · RIS — for reference managers without a browser translator. Zotero and most others pick up this page's citation metadata directly.

Hadar Gafni* , Lars Bo Jeppesen

* Primary investigator

Registry ID
AEARCTR-0015825
DOI
https://doi.org/10.1257/rct.15825-1.0
First registered
Last updated
Status
In development
Trial dates
2025-05-26 – 2025-06-09
Countries
Private
JEL codes
D9
Registry record
http://www.socialscienceregistry.org/trials/15825

Abstract

This study examines how monetary incentives influence people’s willingness to help others, and how that effect changes depending on who is being helped. Organizations often want to encourage prosocial behavior—actions people take to help others—but relying only on people’s goodwill is often not enough. One common approach is to offer money as a reward. However, previous research has shown that in some cases, offering money can actually reduce people’s motivation to help, rather than increase it. This study explores when money helps and when it backfires.
We use an online survey-experiment with a sample of individuals living in the United Kingdom, aged 18-70. In the first step, participants read a short scenario where someone is asked to help load a sofa into a van. Across different versions of the scenario, we change two things: whether the helper is offered no money, a small amount ($0.50), or a larger amount ($5), and who the beneficiary is—ranging from a wealthy person to someone who is elderly and in a wheelchair. Participants are then asked how likely the “average person” would be to help in that situation.
We also include additional questions to better understand why people think others would help or not, based on existing psychological theories of motivation. This will help us learn more about what types of motivation matter most—and when money helps or hurts. In a second step, participants are shown a new scenario where the incentive is changed, allowing us to examine how people believe motivation shifts when financial rewards are introduced or removed. We anticipate writing at least one paper based on this study. If the second step yields informative and novel results, a second paper may be developed. All outcomes and analyses are included here regardless of final publication format.

Experimental design

This is a survey-experiment examining how monetary incentives and perceived prosocial context jointly shape judgments about others’ willingness to help. Participants are randomly assigned to one of 12 conditions in a 4×3 between-subject design. The first dimension manipulates monetary incentives for helping (no incentive, $0.50, or $5). The second dimension manipulates the perceived prosocial need of the person receiving help: (1) a neutral, unspecified beneficiary (replicating Heyman & Ariely, 2004), (2) a wealthy individual, (3) an elderly person from a poor neighborhood, or (4) an elderly person in a wheelchair.
Participants read a brief description of a scenario in which someone is asked to help load a sofa into a van. Based on the version they receive, they are asked how likely they think the average person would be to help, rated on a scale from 1 to 11 (11 being extremely likely to help). Asking about of the likelihood of others to help rather than the likelihood of the participants themselves is essential to potential reduce social desirability biases (Epley & Dunning, 2000; Fisher, 1993; Fisher & Katz, 2000).
In a second step, participants are presented with a revised version of the scenario in which the monetary incentive changes (to one of the two conditions they did not initially receive), allowing us to examine how people believe willingness to help changes when financial rewards are added or removed. This step makes the experiment a within-subject experiment.
Between the two steps, all the participants answer a questionnaire about the motivations of the “average person” to help (or not) by adapting questions from the Multidimensional Work Motivation Scale (MWMS), Ryan and Connell (1989), Millette & Gagné (2008), Gagné (2015), Fenigstein, Scheier, and Buss (1975), Grant (2008), Duffy & Kornienko (2010), Hartmann et al (2017), Leuker (2021), Bandura (2006), Cuddy, Fiske, Glick (2007), Erlandsson et al (2015), Jie (2020), and others. The answers will be used to understand the mechanisms that explain the answers in the first stage, and are not part of the experiment itself.

Design details

Randomization method
Random allocation by Qualtrics
Randomization unit
Individuals.
Clusters
720 individuals
Observations
720 individuals living in the United Kingdom, aged 18-70.
Arms
60 individuals for each of our 12 cells, overall 720 individuals. In the second step, each cell is divided in two, resulting 24 cells, 30 in each one.
Primary outcomes
Participants’ ratings (on a scale from 1 = Extremely unlikely to 11 = Extremely likely) of how likely the average person would be to help in the described scenario – willingness to help.

Cited by

No citation data available for this registration yet.

Keywords