Trading Off Openness: Information, Incentives, and Preferences for Immigration Policy

How to cite

Cattaneo, Cristina. 2025. "Trading Off Openness: Information, Incentives, and Preferences for Immigration Policy." AEA RCT Registry. AEARCTR-0015811. https://doi.org/10.1257/rct.15811-1.0

Download: BibTeX · RIS — for reference managers without a browser translator. Zotero and most others pick up this page's citation metadata directly.

Cristina Cattaneo*

* Primary investigator

Registry ID
AEARCTR-0015811
DOI
https://doi.org/10.1257/rct.15811-1.0
First registered
Last updated
Status
In development
Trial dates
2025-04-27 – 2025-07-31
Countries
Private
Registry record
http://www.socialscienceregistry.org/trials/15811

Abstract

We conduct a survey experiment with Italian, German and Hungarian residents and present the trade-offs associated with (open) migration policies and the economic and demographic consequences of an aging native population. We analyse preferences for more open immigration policies and attitudes towards migrants using both self-reported measures and a real-stakes decision to donate money in support of the integration of immigrants in the labour market of hosting countries. In our experiment, we manipulated the amount of information provided to the respondents. The control group only visualizes information on three future policy scenarios characterised by different levels of stringency and openness of immigration. The treatment groups are also informed on the demographic and economic consequences of the three alternative immigration policies. We also vary the way the economic consequences are expressed, either in aggregated form, namely as per-capita GDP or personalised, in terms of own income level.

Intervention

We present three future policy scenarios characterised by different levels of stringency and openness of immigration to individuals in three countries: Italy, Germany, Hungary. For each of the three scenarios, we ask respondents to indicate whether they would support the proposed migration policy or prefer to keep the current one, which we label as the status quo. In our experiment, we manipulated the amount of information provided to the respondents. The control group only visualizes information on the immigration policies. The treatment groups are also informed on the demographic and economic consequences of the status quo and the alternative immigration policies. In Treatment 1, we present the implications in terms of working-age population and GDP per capita in 2050; in Treatment 2 in terms of
personal income.
After respondents are exposed to three sets of binary choices between maintaining the status quo and opting for the alternative scenarios and express their preference, we also collect incentivized decisions to gauge revealed preferences for supporting immigration. We identified an organization that is involved in both international cooperation programs in countries of the global South and in migrants' integration programs in destination countries.

Experimental design

The experimental design includes individual-level randomization. We randomly assign individuals to three groups. The control group only visualizes information on the immigration policies. The other two groups are also informed on the demographic and economic consequences of the status quo and the alternative immigration policies. One of these two groups visualzed the economic consequences in aggregated form,
namely as per-capita GDP. The other group visualize them in a personalised way, in terms of own income level. We retrieve own income to all respondents through a pre-treatment question.

Design details

Randomization method
Randomization done by Qualtrics.
Randomization unit
We will have three samples: one in Italy, one in Germany and one in Hungary. Within the sample, the randomizations are conducted at the individual level.
Clusters
3000 participants in Italy; 3000 in Germany; 3000 in Hungary
Observations
9000 adult participants
Arms
3000 participants by treatment arm
Primary outcomes
The primary outcome variables include stated policy preferences in three different migration scenarios caraterised by different levels of stringency/openess to migration and an real-stake decisions in support to immigration.
Secondary outcomes
The secondary outcome variables include post-treatment beliefs on the impacts of immigration, to understand if respondents trust our treatments and update their beliefs accordingly; general and self-reported questions on attitudes towards migrants; responses to the open question on possible solutions for the ageing of the population in their own country; beliefs about the share of migrants in their own country. This outcome helps us determine whether our treatments—by highlighting the impending decline of the native population—backfire by exacerbating concerns about the shrinking ratio of natives to foreigners.

Cited by

No citation data available for this registration yet.

Keywords