Food Swaps: Defaults vs Active Choice Using an experimental online supermarket

How to cite

Ferris, Adam; Clark, Michael. 2025. "Food Swaps: Defaults vs Active Choice Using an experimental online supermarket." AEA RCT Registry. AEARCTR-0015805. https://doi.org/10.1257/rct.15805-1.1

Download: BibTeX · RIS — for reference managers without a browser translator. Zotero and most others pick up this page's citation metadata directly.

Adam Ferris* , Michael Clark

* Primary investigator

Registry ID
AEARCTR-0015805
DOI
https://doi.org/10.1257/rct.15805-1.1
First registered
Last updated
Status
Completed
Trial dates
2025-04-14 – 2025-04-24
Countries
United Kingdom of Great Britain and Northern Ireland ()
Registry record
http://www.socialscienceregistry.org/trials/15805

Abstract

We examine whether the design of a shopping “swap” -a pop-up window suggesting an environmentally-friendlier alternative to the consumers first choice- can influence both the environmental impact on final grocery baskets and consumer identity. Building on policy and behavioural research on defaults in contexts of heterogeneous preferences and shaping identity (Sunstein, 2017), we explore the effects of different swap designs in cognitively demanding environments, e.g. online grocery shopping. Participants, in the intervention week (week 2), are presented with either default opt-in, default opt-out or active choice designs.
Using an incentive compatible framed field experiment and a difference-in-differences approach, we estimate the causal effect of swap design on the eco-score of grocery baskets. Additionally, we assess changes in consumers’ environmental identity and their willingness to pay for such interventions. The willingness-to-pay is measured for the swaps with and without the eco and nutritional labels to disentangle the effect of the swap mechanism itself from the influence of visible product-level sustainability information.

Intervention

Following a baseline shopping task in week 1, the same for all participants and prior to week 2, participants will be (stratified and) randomly assigned to one of four experimental arms:
The four experimental arms, applied in week 2, are:
1. Control: No swap mechanism.
2. Default opt-in: Swap with original grocery preselected.
3. Default opt-out: Swap with alternative grocery preselected.
4. Active choice: Swap with neither original or alternative pre-selected.

Experimental design

Similar to (Panzone et al., 2021a, 2021b; Zizzo, 2010), we will employ a between and within-subject experimental design, where participants are recruited to shop twice on our simulated grocery store. Week 1 serves as a baseline, where all participants are asked to do a weekly shop on the platform. Participants will then be randomised into one of 4 conditions using a stratified randomisation procedure and will be invited to complete a second survey and shopping task in the following week. Importantly, our experimental design will be incentive-compatible and can be classified as a framed field experiment (List, 2011).

Design details

Randomization method
To allocate the participants to one of the 4 experimental arms in week 2, we use a stratified randomisation technique, based on gender, eco score of participants’ week 1 shopping task baskets (as eco terciles).
Randomization unit
The unit of randomisation is at the individual level.
Clusters
N/A
Observations
We collect 2-week data (from 2 pre- and post-shop surveys and two shopping tasks) from c.960 participants for the whole experiment (spread over 4 treatments, 240 per treatment). This sample size is based on previous papers of a similar nature and power calculation simulations for linear and log-linear difference-in-difference (detail below) and for a multilevel logistic and linear regression analysis. This does not cover likely non-completion of the survey and experiments, attrition across the two-week study, comprehension and attention check failures, and budgetary constraints.
Arms
The recruitment sample size collected for week 1 is 280 participants per treatment arm. This sample size is based on previous papers of a similar nature and power calculations. This accounts for non-completion and attrition in the range of c.20% across the two-week study.
Primary outcomes
Primary Outcomes (end points): This study has two main outcome variables. First primary variable: Eco-score of the final shopping baskets from Week 1 (pre-intervention baseline) and Week 2 (post-intervention treatment) based on the final product choices made by all participants in both weeks (in a shopping budget of £25-50). Eco-scores are based on calculations by Clark et al. (2022). The final basket eco scores will be re-balanced per 100g of produce bought and per GBP spent. Second primary variable: Consumer green identity changes from Week 1 (pre-intervention baseline) and Week 2 (post-intervention treatment) based on survey questions from (van der Werff et al., 2014; Guidetti et al., 2023).
Secondary outcomes
Our experiment includes secondary variables. Our other secondary variable measured in both week 1 and 2, is search effort in the shopping task (based on time spent going through the shopping platform). Through the experimental online supermarket platform and the survey platform, we will get these two separate measures for each participant each week. We also collect the data on whether proposed swaps were accepted or not. In addition to these two key secondary variables, we collect data on socio-demographics (age, income, weekly grocery expenditure, children education, etc). We also collect preference elicitation data for the cognitive reflection test, locus of control, self-control.

Cited by

No citation data available for this registration yet.

Keywords