Measuring the Credibility of Nonpolitical Institutions

How to cite

Nannicini, Tommaso. 2025. "Measuring the Credibility of Nonpolitical Institutions." AEA RCT Registry. AEARCTR-0015789. https://doi.org/10.1257/rct.15789-1.0

Download: BibTeX · RIS — for reference managers without a browser translator. Zotero and most others pick up this page's citation metadata directly.

Tommaso Nannicini*

* Primary investigator

Registry ID
AEARCTR-0015789
DOI
https://doi.org/10.1257/rct.15789-1.0
First registered
Last updated
Status
In development
Trial dates
2025-04-14 – 2025-05-05
Countries
Private
JEL codes
O33, J24, D83, P10
Registry record
http://www.socialscienceregistry.org/trials/15789

Abstract

This survey experiment examines how the credibility of nonpolitical institutions shapes individual beliefs and preferences. Fielded in Italy, it delivers identical information about labor automation while randomizing the sender—trade unions, business organizations, newspapers, or an unspecified source. By isolating the sender effect, the design identifies how source attribution drives belief updating and behavioral responses. A pre-post structure captures prior beliefs and tracks changes over time in both beliefs and policy preferences. The experiment aims to provide new evidence on the persuasive power of nonpolitical institutions and their influence on public opinion.

Intervention

I will build on previous studies on labor automation (Arntz et al., 2022) to align with existing literature and provide out-of-sample benchmarks. The information will be designed to operate through the updating of beliefs and perceptions, rather than priming. The experimental design will follow a “pre-post” structure with the elicitation of first-stage beliefs and updated posteriors (Stantcheva, 2023). This approach will allow me to examine the credibility and influence of different nonpolitical institutions—such as trade unions, business organizations, and newspapers—on individual decision-making. By systematically varying the sender of the information, I will assess the credibility of these institutions and measure their impact on both beliefs and behavior.

Experimental design

The survey will be conducted by the professional polling company SWG through fieldwork for CAWI. The goal is to randomize information m, which will be the same for all treatment groups except the control group, but the source of this information will differ across the groups receiving the treatment. The sample will be divided into five groups of 650 individuals each. The information will be provided in a graphic format resembling a newspaper headline to increase its impact.
• Group A (650 individuals): Receives the information from "major trade unions."
• Group B (650 individuals): Receives the information from "major business associations."
• Group C (650 individuals): Receives the information from "major newspapers."
• Group D (650 individuals): Receives the information without a specified source.
• Group E (650 individuals): Does not receive no information (control group).

Versions of information treatment.
• (Trade Unions): "Major trade unions warn: 66% of jobs at risk due to artificial intelligence. Cgil and Cisl discuss a recent study."
• (Business): "Major business associations warn: 66% of jobs at risk due to artificial intelligence. Confindustria and CNA discuss a recent study."
• (Newspapers): "Major newspapers warn: 66% of jobs at risk due to artificial intelligence. Corriere e Repubblica discuss a recent study."
• (No Source): "66% of jobs are at risk due to artificial intelligence. A recent study discusses this issue."

Note that there is no deception involved, as the information treatments simply state that the specific nonpolitical institutions “discussed” the study in question. In fact, as shown by a press review conducted in preparation for this survey, when a study estimated that 66% of jobs in developed countries could be at risk due to generative AI, major newspapers, trade unions, and business organizations all discussed its findings. Therefore, the statements in the information treatments are accurate.

Design details

Randomization method
Randomization automatically performed by the polling company SWG in the CAWI fieldwork.
Randomization unit
Survey respondents.
Clusters
Not applicable – treatment is not clustered. Randomization occurs at the individual level (CAWI respondents).
Observations
Approximately 3,250 individuals (CAWI respondents) in Italy.
Arms
650 individuals – Trade unions as sender 650 individuals – Business associations as sender 650 individuals – Newspapers as sender 650 individuals – Unspecified sender (neutral) 650 individuals – No sender displayed (control group)
Primary outcomes
Primary end points: - Change in beliefs (before vs after) - Policy preferences (especially voting intention and support for reforms) - Differential impact by sender
Secondary outcomes
Heterogeneity across trust in political and nonpolitical institutions, ideology, populist attitudes, age, gender, social capital, occupation, contract type, and sector.

Cited by

No citation data available for this registration yet.

Keywords