Fostering STEM Retention: The Impact of Mentoring and Community Building
How to cite
Danon, Alice; Grellet, Alexandre; Daviot, Quentin; Kaeppel, Katharina. 2025. "Fostering STEM Retention: The Impact of Mentoring and Community Building." AEA RCT Registry. AEARCTR-0015775. https://doi.org/10.1257/rct.15775-1.0
Download: BibTeX · RIS — for reference managers without a browser translator. Zotero and most others pick up this page's citation metadata directly.
* Primary investigator
Abstract
Despite progress in reducing gender disparities in many fields, the gender gap in science, technology, engineering, and mathematics (STEM) remains significant across OECD countries. Women represent only about a third of STEM graduates and an even smaller share of the workforce, with those from disadvantaged backgrounds being particularly underrepresented. This persistent gap not only contributes to gender wage disparities (Beede et al., 2011) but may also hinder innovation and economic growth (Hsieh et al., 2019). The underrepresentation of women in STEM begins early, with gendered preferences emerging in primary school, and continues throughout the educational and professional pipeline. At the higher education level, not only do fewer women enroll in STEM fields, but they also drop out at higher rates than men.
This project focuses on the critical dropout stage in the early years of higher education, examining the impact of a mentoring and community-building program designed to support female students in STEM. The mentoring component aims to enhance self-efficacy and facilitate access to internships and professional opportunities through mentor networks and career guidance. The community-building component seeks to foster a stronger sense of belonging in a predominantly male-dominated environment. By assessing the effectiveness of these interventions, this study aims to identify strategies to improve the well-being, retention, and long-term persistence of women in STEM fields.
Intervention
This project will evaluate the impact of Article 1’s DEMA1N + STEM project, through a randomized control trial.
Article 1 is an NGO that supports high school and university students from underprivileged backgrounds, ages 16 to 25, by providing them guidance from career orientation through to professional integration with both digital and in-person programs.
In this study, we will focus on a specific project from Article 1 called DEMA1N + STEM. The DEMA1N + STEM project aims to provide young women studying in STEM fields with mentorship support, complemented by a variety of events related to professional integration (STEM Campus, LinkedIn community) as well as social integration tools (student WhatsApp community, beginning of academic year campus, summer campus).
This project targets higher education women from underprivileged backgrounds enrolled in STEM fields, whether it is in universities, private institutions, or vocational schools. Students in this program receive support through mentorship and group activities, including regional and national events, and are part of an online peer community via WhatsApp and LinkedIn groups. For the purpose of this study, we will focus on young women up until Bac +3.
The mentorship program aims to empower women by building their self-confidence and self-efficacy, preventing dropout, and supporting their professional integration through assistance with crafting resumes, writing cover letters, finding internships, and establishing network connections.
Additionally, the online WhatsApp and LinkedIn communities foster a sense of belonging, provide a platform for sharing job opportunities, and offer valuable advice on applications.
Experimental design
The design will be as follows: 1,534 participants will be randomized across treatment and control group, stratifying on:
Week of inscription/Batch
University vs. selective higher education vs. vocational/technical education
Year post-bac (dummy indicating whether they are in the last year of their program)
Grit scale
50% of participants, i.e. 767 participants, will be assigned to the treatment group and receive: mentor, whatsapp group + possibility of attending campuses
50% of participants, i.e. 767 participants, will be assigned to the control group. They will be eligible to receive the treatment 6 months later.
Design details
Cited by
No citation data available for this registration yet.