The Explanatory Power of Identity Models in Explaining Moral Balancing

How to cite

Schneeberger, Alexander; Krupka, Erin; Irlenbusch, Bernd. 2025. "The Explanatory Power of Identity Models in Explaining Moral Balancing." AEA RCT Registry. AEARCTR-0015774. https://doi.org/10.1257/rct.15774-1.2

Download: BibTeX · RIS — for reference managers without a browser translator. Zotero and most others pick up this page's citation metadata directly.

Alexander Schneeberger* , Erin Krupka , Bernd Irlenbusch

* Primary investigator

Registry ID
AEARCTR-0015774
DOI
https://doi.org/10.1257/rct.15774-1.2
First registered
Last updated
Status
In development
Trial dates
2025-05-18 – 2025-12-31
Countries
Private
JEL codes
D91, C91
Registry record
http://www.socialscienceregistry.org/trials/15774

Abstract

How should economists model moral balancing behavior? Work in psychology suggests that the behavioral pattern results from individuals’ desires to maintain certain self-images and identities. However, in economics, multiple prominent models try to incorporate identity. This study examines how well the models of Bénabou and Tirole (2011) and of Akerlof and Kranton (2000) explain moral balancing. We examine how well the model of Bénabou and Tirole explains moral balancing by experimentally testing how individuals’ beliefs in being a high moral type affect the likelihood of acting morally and how acting morally, taking no action, and acting immorally changes their beliefs in being a high moral type. We also examine how well the model of Akerlof and Kranton explains moral balancing by experimentally testing how acting morally, taking no action, and acting immorally changes individuals’ norm sensitivities and subsequent social norms.

Intervention

Participants are assigned to one of 12 treatments. In the treatments, we vary two dimensions: 1.) the main outcome measure (4 options) and 2.) the actual or considered past (3 options).

The main outcome measure varies the main variable we want to measure. In the choice treatment (CT) individiuals face a moral choice, in the belief treatment (BT) we measure individuals' belief in being a high moral type, in the norm sensitivity treatment (NST) we measure the individiuals' norm sensitivity, and in the social norms treatment (SNT) we measure the social norms present in the CT.

The actual or considered past varies the task that participants face immediately before the main outcome measure. In the moral past treatment (MPT), individuals face a task that induces them to act morally, in the no past treatment (NPT), individuals receive an endowment without making a choice, and in the immoral past treatment (IPT), individuals face a task that induces them to act immorally.

Experimental design

The research project consists of a survey and two experiments: The pre-screening survey, the main experiment and the receiver experiment. The main experiment consists of two parts, separated by 24-48 hours.

Pre-screening survey:
In the first part, participants answer the questions on the altruism measure from the Global Preference Survey (Falk et al., 2018; Falk, Becker, Dohmen, Huffman, & Sunde, 2022). Based on their responses, we determine their moral type (high or low).

Part one of the main experiment:
In the first stage, participants encounter a belief elicitation (Karni, 2009) in which we measure their initial belief in being a high-moral type. In the second stage, participants encounter a rule-following task (Kimbrough & Vostroknutov, 2018) in which we measure their initial norm sensitivity.

Part two of the main experiment:
The stages encountered in part two of the main experiment differ across treatments. In stage one of the CT-MPT, participants assume the role of the sender in a sender-receiver game (Gneezy, 2005), which has been calibrated to induce truthfulness. In the first phase of the CT-NPT, participants are given a sum of money and cannot act. In the first stage of the CT-IPT, participants assume the role of the sender in a sender-receiver game, which has been calibrated to induce lying. In the second phase of the CTs, participants encounter a binary donation game in which they either donate a certain amount or keep their money. In stage three of the CTs, we elicit the (conditional) social norms of the actions possible in the previous two stages of their respective treatment using the Krupka & Weber method (2013). In the first stage of the BTs, subjects participate in the same tasks as in the CTs. In stage two of the BTs, subjects repeated the belief elicitation from part one. In the first phase of the NSTs, subjects again participated in the same tasks as in the CTs. In the second phase of the NSTs, subjects repeated the rule-following task from part one. In stage three of the NSTs, we elicit the (conditional) social norms of actions possible in the previous two stages of their respective treatment with the Krupka & Weber method. In stage one of the SNTs, we measure the same social norm as in stage three of the CTs. However, this time we use a between-design instead of a within-design.

Receiver Experiment:
In stage one, participants assume the role of the receiver in the sender-receiver game.

Design details

Randomization method
To assign participants to their treatments, we match participants to an entry in a random sequence of treatments based on their order of arrival. To create the random sequence of treatments, we create a sequence of blocks, each containing the treatments at a given frequency. Crucially, the order within each block is randomly shuffled (using the Python module random). As we approach the end of the data collection, we adjust the treatment frequency in each block to achieve our desired goal of usable observations.
Randomization unit
Individual level.
Clusters
We will collect at least 1940 usable observations from participants in the main experiment. An observation from the CT, BT, and NST is usable if the participant behaves morally in the sender game of the MPT, if the participant is assigned to the NPT, and if the participant behaves immorally in the sender game of the IPT. An observation from the SNT is always usable. We will slightly exceed this number since it is impossible to know the attrition between part one and part two of the main experiment in advance.
Observations
We will collect at least 1940 usable observations from participants in the main experiment. An observation from the CT, BT, and NST is usable if the participant behaves morally in the sender game of the MPT, if the participant is assigned to the NPT, and if the participant behaves immorally in the sender game of the IPT. An observation from the SNT is always usable. We will slightly exceed this number since it is impossible to know the attrition between part one and part two of the main experiment in advance.
Arms
We will collect data until we have at least 400 usable observations in the CT-NPT and 140 usable observations in each other treatment of the main experiment. An observation from the CT, BT, and NST is usable if the participant behaves morally in the sender game of the MPT, if the participant is assigned to the NPT, and if the participant behaves immorally in the sender game of the IPT. An observation from the SNT is always usable. We will slightly exceed these numbers since it is impossible to know the attrition between part one and part two of the main experiment in advance.
Primary outcomes
In the CT: Whether or not a person donates in the donation game. In the BT: The belief in being a high moral type according to the belief elicitation. In the NST: The norm sensitivity according to the rule-following task. In the SNT: The social norms of the CT according to the norm elicitation.

Cited by

No citation data available for this registration yet.

Keywords