Preferences for Hazardous Fuel Treatments: Evidence from a Survey of Forest Service Personnel and the General Public
How to cite
Hoban, Danielle. 2025. "Preferences for Hazardous Fuel Treatments: Evidence from a Survey of Forest Service Personnel and the General Public." AEA RCT Registry. AEARCTR-0015770. https://doi.org/10.1257/rct.15770-1.0
Download: BibTeX · RIS — for reference managers without a browser translator. Zotero and most others pick up this page's citation metadata directly.
* Primary investigator
Abstract
In recent decades, the United States has experienced dangerous increases in the prevalence and severity of annual wildfire events. The management of hazardous fuels can mitigate the spread and severity of wildfire events by removing or reorganizing excess woody materials that could otherwise feed fires. However, recent wildfire severity has required a large portion of the United States Forest Service (USFS) budget to be allocated to suppression efforts each year at the expense of other budget categories, such as fuel treatments. This motivates the importance of using available resources in a way that maximizes social welfare, but it is unclear what allocation is considered optimal by relevant stakeholders. This research investigates the preferences of USFS employees and the public for hazardous fuel treatments. The primary objective of this work is to assess how these two groups would prefer a portion of the USFS wildfire management budget be allocated among fuel reduction activities. A secondary objective is to determine how allocation preferences are affected when budgetary changes are presented as a loss or a gain. To address these questions, surveys were administered to a sample of the public residing in Colorado and Utah, and to employees of the USFS. Respondents were asked to complete a budget allocation exercise as the primary mechanism for assessing their preferences. Ultimately, this research will help inform USFS management decisions by improving our understanding of each group’s preferences, as well as characteristics that may influence these preferences.
Intervention
Participants will be asked to complete a budget allocation exercise. An informational treatment will be applied to the allocation exercise. Participants will be asked how they would allocate an additional $100 million between hazardous fuel treatment options or how they would decrease funding among the management options if $100 million were to be cut from the budget.
Experimental design
Two surveys were designed to address the research questions. The surveys follow a 2x2 between-subject design and were designed and will be administered through Qualtrics, an online survey platform. One survey will sample the general public residing in Colorado and Utah. A second survey will sample USFS personnel.Both surveys are comprised of questions that address the participant's experience with wildfire. The survey of USFS personnel focuses more on their professional experience, while the public will be asked about their personal experience. The primary mechanism for analysis in both surveys is a budget allocation exercise and will be the same for USFS personnel and the public. Participants will be asked to allocate a portion of the USFS hazardous fuels treatment budget between prescribed fire and mechanical treatments. Two treatments will be tested through the budget allocation exercise. In the "gain" treatment, participants will be asked how they would allocate an additional \$100 million in the USFS hazardous fuel budget among the management options. In the "loss" treatment, participants are asked how they would decrease funding among the management options if \$100 million were to be cut from the hazardous fuel management budget.
Design details
Cited by
No citation data available for this registration yet.