Nudging Freshmen to Persist: Evidence from Two Large Private Colleges in Brazil
How to cite
Arango, Sergio; Bettinger, Eric; Lichand, Guilherme. 2025. "Nudging Freshmen to Persist: Evidence from Two Large Private Colleges in Brazil." AEA RCT Registry. AEARCTR-0015680. https://doi.org/10.1257/rct.15680-1.0
Download: BibTeX · RIS — for reference managers without a browser translator. Zotero and most others pick up this page's citation metadata directly.
* Primary investigator
Abstract
This study evaluates the impact of behavioral "nudge" interventions, delivered via text messages, on college persistence among undergraduate students enrolled at private higher education institutions in Brazil. We conduct two randomized controlled trials (RCTs) across two academic semesters in 2024, reaching over 120,000 students. The intervention consists of low-cost, periodic digital messages—delivered via SMS, WhatsApp, and push notifications—designed to promote academic engagement, support goal setting, and provide timely information about institutional resources and deadlines.
Although SMS-based outreach has become a common tool for supporting student success in higher education, rigorous evidence on its effectiveness remains scarce in middle-income country contexts. Most existing studies are concentrated in high-income settings, and little is known about whether such behavioral interventions are effective at scale in countries like Brazil, where structural barriers to persistence are different, and digital communication channels may have broader reach.
Additionally, this study takes place within the context of Brazil’s private higher education sector, which differs significantly from the for-profit college landscape in the United States. In the U.S., for-profit institutions are often associated with low academic quality, low value-added, and poor labor market outcomes—including lower earnings and higher unemployment rates relative to public or nonprofit institutions (Cellini & Chaudhary, 2012; Deming, Goldin, & Katz, 2012). These patterns raise legitimate concerns about whether increasing persistence in such settings is socially beneficial. By contrast, Brazil’s private higher education sector serves a much broader population, tuition costs are substantially lower, and the average returns to higher education remain high. These differences suggest that, in the Brazilian context, promoting persistence is more likely to lead to socially and economically desirable outcomes.
Intervention
The intervention is a student success initiative developed by Movva, an ed-tech company that applies behavioral science and artificial intelligence to improve retention in higher education. Movva identifies students at risk of dropping out and sends them personalized, behaviorally-informed messages through digital channels such as SMS, WhatsApp, and push notifications. These communications are designed to support motivation, promote academic engagement, and encourage course completion.
The initiative was implemented in partnership with Vitru Educação, a major private higher education provider in Brazil, beginning in the first semester of 2024. It targeted approximately 60,000 first-semester undergraduate students per semester, across a broad set of programs and campuses ("polos") nationwide. The intervention was designed to be both personalized and scalable, adapting messages to student profiles while reaching a large and geographically diverse population.
Experimental design
In the first semester of 2024, a randomized intervention was implemented to evaluate the effectiveness of different communication channels in promoting student success among freshmen college students. The selection strategy prioritized courses with the largest student enrollments, and within each course, students were assigned to treatment or control groups based on their campus location. The intervention targeted approximately 60,000 students, divided across three experimental arms. One control group received no messages, while two treatment groups were exposed to different communication strategies: one group received eight SMS messages per month (two per week), and the other received a combination of six SMS and two WhatsApp messages per month.
In the second semester of 2024, the intervention design was refined based on findings from the earlier semester, with a stronger focus on cost-effective and scalable communication strategies. Given budget constraints, the most successful strategy from 2024-1—combining SMS and WhatsApp—was prioritized for a treatment group of 13,443 students. These students were drawn from eight courses that had shown the most promising results previously. A corresponding control group of 9,701 students from the same courses did not receive any messages, allowing for a clean comparison. In addition, two new experimental groups were introduced to test the effectiveness of push notifications, a low-cost communication channel. The first push group included 4,590 students and was designed to assess the impact of push messages alone. A second, broader push notification group included 17,823 additional students who had not been part of the original sample, allowing researchers to explore the channel’s scalability and performance across a more diverse student population. This multi-arm design aimed to balance rigor with practical considerations and expand the evaluation of digital messaging in higher education.
In the second semester of 2024, two distinct randomized experiments were conducted to evaluate the effectiveness of digital communication strategies in promoting the success of freshmen college students. Experiment 1 focused on two treatment arms and a control group, drawing on evidence from the most promising courses in the previous semester. A total of 27,734 students were included in this experiment. The first treatment group, comprising 13,443 students, received eight messages per month—six via SMS and two via WhatsApp. The second treatment group included 4,590 students who received messages exclusively through push notifications, a no-cost communication channel. A control group of 9,701 students received no messages. This design allowed for a direct comparison between two delivery strategies (SMS+WhatsApp vs. push notifications) and a control condition, all within a high-priority student population.
Experiment 2 aimed to expand the evaluation of push notifications to a broader and more diverse population of freshmen college students, leveraging the low cost of this communication channel. This experiment included a total of 36,916 students, randomly assigned to one of two groups. The treatment group consisted of 17,823 students who received messages exclusively via push notifications. The control group, comprising 19,093 students, received no messages. Unlike Experiment 1, which focused on a smaller set of high-priority courses, Experiment 2 included a wider range of academic programs and campuses. This design enabled the research team to assess the scalability and generalizability of push notifications as a tool for improving student outcomes in varied institutional contexts.
Design details
Cited by
No citation data available for this registration yet.