Targeting Payments for Ecosystem Services by Risk in Meghalaya, India
How to cite
Page, Lucy; Pfeiffer, Maike; Pande, Rohini. 2025. "Targeting Payments for Ecosystem Services by Risk in Meghalaya, India." AEA RCT Registry. AEARCTR-0015675. https://doi.org/10.1257/rct.15675-1.0
Download: BibTeX · RIS — for reference managers without a browser translator. Zotero and most others pick up this page's citation metadata directly.
* Primary investigator
Abstract
Protecting ecosystems in low-income countries is crucial to climate-change mitigation and adaptation. Payments for ecosystem services (PES)—which compensate landowners for refraining from ecologically damaging activities—are a promising tool to protect ecosystems while providing income to rural communities. Central to designing effective PES programs is ensuring that they yield “additionality,” or conservation that would not have occurred without payments. Voluntary enrollment, and thus self-selection, into PES programs tends to limit additionality: those who would conserve their land even in the absence of the program have the highest incentive to enroll. Past work suggests that machine-learning models can use basic remote-sensing data to predict deforestation risk at a granular spatial scale. Then, targeting PES enrollment by predicted deforestation risk may be an effective tool to increase additionality. In this randomized control trial, we collaborate with the Government of Meghalaya, India, to embed machine-learning predictions of deforestation risk into a large-scale expansion of an existing PES program. In particular, we will test whether targeting higher-payment PES contracts to landowners on land with higher predicted risk of deforestation can improve program additionality and cost-effectiveness. We will use a combination of satellite, administrative, and primary data to test the impacts of risk-based targeting on PES enrollment, deforestation, program cost-effectiveness, and household welfare.
Intervention
Our primary intervention is targeting PES contracts by predicted risk of deforestation, which we predict at a 30m spatial scale using a convolutional neural network trained on satellite data layers. We classify land into a binary of high- vs. low-risk land, and the government offers higher-payment PES contracts to high-risk land.
Experimental design
We randomize villages between three groups:
Basic PES: PES program staff will approach villages to actively recruit applicants for PES. Government representatives will invite anyone who owns forest land with area over 1ha to enroll in contracts under which they commit to refraining from damaging activities for 30 years, including cutting trees, mining, grazing animals, and raising structures. Enrollees will receive payments at a fixed per-hectare rate for the first 5 years of the contract. These payments will be set at Rs. 10,000 per hectare, with additional payments offered for land where trees are particularly dense or are otherwise of particular ecosystem value because they are e.g. close to a national park or fall in an elephant corridor. Government staff will assess landowners' compliance with PES contracts each year and will reduce enrollees' next-year payments if they have been found in violation.
Risk-targeted PES: In villages enrolled in this arm, the government will offer higher PES payments on land at higher predicted risk of deforestation; otherwise, PES recruitment remains the same as in the base PES program. We predict risk of deforestation at a 30m scale using a convolutional neural network trained on satellite data. In particular, landowners in these villages will be offered payments of Rs. 16,000 per hectare per year for each unit of high-risk land they enroll in Green PES, while being offered Rs. 8,000 per hectare per year for low-risk land. Payments are calibrated such that the average PES payment offered in this arm is equal to that offered in basic PES, as we classify about 25% of land in risk-targeted villages as high-risk.
Control group: No active PES recruitment will occur in control villages. If landowners in control villages learn about Green PES and contact program staff to register, they will be allowed to enroll. However, program staff will not actively visit these villages.
Design details
Cited by
No citation data available for this registration yet.