Costly Information Revealed by Beliefs: A More Direct Test of Rational Inattention Models

How to cite

Tayawa, Jason; Kim, Suha; Ko, Hyeonggyun. 2025. "Costly Information Revealed by Beliefs: A More Direct Test of Rational Inattention Models." AEA RCT Registry. AEARCTR-0015667. https://doi.org/10.1257/rct.15667-2.0

Download: BibTeX · RIS — for reference managers without a browser translator. Zotero and most others pick up this page's citation metadata directly.

Jason Tayawa* , Suha Kim , Hyeonggyun Ko

* Primary investigator

Registry ID
AEARCTR-0015667
DOI
https://doi.org/10.1257/rct.15667-2.0
First registered
Last updated
Status
On going
Trial dates
2025-04-15 – 2027-05-31
Countries
United States of America ()
JEL codes
C91, D81, D83, D91
Registry record
http://www.socialscienceregistry.org/trials/15667

Abstract

We design an experiment to document the validity of rational inattention models. Our design evaluates these models in direct (choosing intended posteriors) and natural (choosing information structures) frames. The former frame implements a decision variable closest to the model’s primitives, while the latter is more natural for experimental settings. By observing the acquired information in either frame, we can determine which class of rational inattention models aligns with the decision-making processes in the lab. These frames provide insights into the validity of these classes in rational inattention models, which are often tested solely based on choice data without observing the chosen level of informativeness. Assessing the consistency of their behavior between the two frames allows us to know whether it is without loss of generality that experimental designs may adopt an indirect yet natural decision variable and still make use of models that are ultimately defined on random posterior distributions.

Intervention

Experiment 1

The design varies several variables regarding the decision problem of the subject. Each subject is invited to participate in three sessions to do 168 round of a simple guessing task where the guess whether or not the randomly chosen urn for a given round contains a hexagon. Subjects are allowed to gather information about the chosen urn by taking out polygons from the chosen urn. We ask how much information they want to gather, and we vary the frame regarding this question between the three sessions. Within a session, we vary the reward for guessing the chosen urn across the rounds; and we also vary the probability the chosen urn has a hexagon across the rounds. Two rounds are randomly chosen for payment at the end of each session. Please refer to the succeeding research design and study procedures for the details and purpose of variations.

We use different frames and provide more information in succeeding treatments to observe changes in the intended posterior distributions.

Experiment 2

Experiment 2 consists of four parts, following the same decision problem in Experiment 1. Similarly, the design varies several variables regarding the decision problem of the subject. Each subject will do 92 rounds of a simple guessing task where they guess whether or not the randomly chosen urn for a given round contains a hexagon. Subjects are allowed to gather information by taking out polygons from the chosen urn. In all parts, we ask how much information they want to gather, and we vary the frame regarding this question between the first two parts. We vary the reward for guessing the chosen urn across the rounds, and we also vary the probability that the chosen urn has a hexagon across the rounds. In parts 3 and 4, they face similar questions to those in the first half and choose options for levels of information based on their answers in the first two parts. Two rounds are randomly chosen for payment at the end of each session.

Experimental design

Experiment 1

The design varies several variables regarding the decision problem of the subject. Each subject is invited to participate in three sessions to do 168 round of a simple guessing task where the guess whether or not the randomly chosen urn for a given round contains a hexagon. Subjects are allowed to gather information about the chosen urn by taking out polygons from the chosen urn. We ask how much information they want to gather, and we vary the frame regarding this question between the three sessions. Within a session, we vary the reward for guessing the chosen urn across the rounds; and we also vary the probability the chosen urn has a hexagon across the rounds. Two rounds are randomly chosen for payment at the end of each session. Please refer to the succeeding research design and study procedures for the details and purpose of variations.

Experiment 2

Experiment 2 consists of four parts, following the same decision problem in Experiment 1. Similarly, the design varies several variables regarding the decision problem of the subject. Each subject will do 92 rounds of a simple guessing task where they guess whether or not the randomly chosen urn for a given round contains a hexagon. Subjects are allowed to gather information by taking out polygons from the chosen urn. In all parts, we ask how much information they want to gather, and we vary the frame regarding this question between the first two parts. We vary the reward for guessing the chosen urn across the rounds, and we also vary the probability that the chosen urn has a hexagon across the rounds. In parts 3 and 4, they face similar questions to those in the first half and choose options for levels of information based on their answers in the first two parts. Two rounds are randomly chosen for payment at the end of each session.

Design details

Randomization method
randomization done in office by a computer
Randomization unit
Individual level
Clusters
Experiment 1: 100 university students Experiment 2: 100 university students
Observations
Experiment 1: 50400 decisions from 100 university students over three session Experiment 2: 27600 decisions from 100 university students
Arms
Experiment 1: 100 university students invited for three sessions Experiment 2: 100 university students
Primary outcomes
Random Posterior Distribution: the possible set of beliefs and their corresponding probability over the state space. Elicited as the intended probability that their guess would be correct. Information Structure: a collection of conditional probabilities over the signal space given the state. Elicited as the number of polygons to be drawn from the unknown urn. Guess: the subject's guess given their realized signal. Choice of level of information based on previous answers: some questions about desired informativeness (in terms of random posterior distributions or information structures) may involve options based on the participant's previous answers.
Secondary outcomes
Experiment 2 Frame easiness: On a scale of 0-10 (0 extremely difficult to 10 extremely easy), we ask the easiness of answering their desired informativeness given the frame. Frame preference: We ask which frame is preferred over the other, allowing for indifference. Frame distinctiveness: On a scale of 0-10 (0 not being different to 10 extremely different), we ask how much they feel that they treat the two frames differently.

Cited by

No citation data available for this registration yet.

Keywords