Behavioral and Economic Impacts of Tariff Innovations in the Brazilian Electricity Market: Evidence from a Randomized Controlled Trial
How to cite
Meloni, Luis Eduardo Negrão; Lucinda, Claudio; Moita, Rodrigo; Oliveira, Lucas Lyrio de; Pereira, Luan Michel Soares. 2025. "Behavioral and Economic Impacts of Tariff Innovations in the Brazilian Electricity Market: Evidence from a Randomized Controlled Trial." AEA RCT Registry. AEARCTR-0015658. https://doi.org/10.1257/rct.15658-1.0
Download: BibTeX · RIS — for reference managers without a browser translator. Zotero and most others pick up this page's citation metadata directly.
* Primary investigator
Abstract
We evaluate the impact of three innovative electricity tariff modalities—Time-of-Use (ToU), Dynamic Tariff, and Prepaid Tariff—on energy consumption behavior, non-technical losses, and default rates in low-voltage consumer segments in Brazil. The interventions are carried out through randomized controlled trials across three regional utility companies of the Energisa Group. In addition to economic incentives, we test behavioral interventions such as opt-in vs. opt-out default settings and different framing strategies in consumer communication. The experiment aims to inform future regulatory changes and improve tariff design using both economic and behavioral insights.
Intervention
This study evaluates the impact of two innovative electricity tariff modalities implemented by the Energisa Group in Brazil: Time-of-Use Tariff (ToU, known as “Tarifa Melhor Hora”) and Dynamic Tariff. These pricing schemes aim to shift electricity consumption away from peak hours, reduce system overload, and promote more efficient energy use.
The intervention covers three utility concession areas: Energisa Sul Sudeste (ESS), Energisa Paraíba (EPB), and Energisa Tocantins (ETO). In each region, eligible low-voltage consumers (residential and small commercial) were randomized into treatment and control groups separately for each tariff type.
• ToU Tariff introduces fixed off-peak and peak prices, communicated in advance to participants.
• Dynamic Tariff uses variable pricing, with day-ahead price signals sent to consumers, incentivizing real-time demand response.
Participants in the treatment group receive the new tariff along with targeted communications from the utility provider explaining how the pricing works and how they can benefit by adjusting their consumption patterns. Communications are tailored by consumption class and region and may include energy-saving tips, example bills, and visual cues.
Control group participants continue under the default tariff, without any changes to pricing or communication.
Smart meters were installed in all selected units prior to the intervention to allow for high-frequency monitoring of consumption. The intervention will last for at least 12 months, with additional monitoring post-intervention.
Randomization was conducted at the unit (UC) level, stratified by class (residential vs commercial) and historical energy usage quintiles.
Experimental design
This study uses a randomized controlled trial (RCT) to evaluate the behavioral and economic impacts of two electricity tariff innovations—Time-of-Use (ToU) and Dynamic Tariff—implemented by the Energisa Group across three utility concession areas: Energisa Sul Sudeste (ESS), Energisa Paraíba (EPB), and Energisa Tocantins (ETO).
Within each concession area and for each tariff type, a set of eligible low-voltage electricity consumers (residential and small commercial) was identified based on consumption history and administrative criteria (e.g., exclusion of consumers with distributed generation, social tariff beneficiaries, excessive disconnections, etc.).
The experimental design involved:
1) Separate randomizations for each tariff and region (6 total experiments: 3 ToU and 3 Dynamic Tariff);
2) Stratification by consumption quintile and customer class;
3) Random assignment of units to treatment or control groups, with a 1.3:1 treatment-to-control ratio;
4) Unit of randomization: electricity consumption unit (UC);
5) Randomization method: performed using R and Python scripts;
6) Sample selection included oversampling: six UCs were selected for each sampling unit to increase the chance of successful installation. One UC was chosen by the utility from each set based on practical considerations (same class, same municipality, same quintile).
Control group consumers continue under the standard tariff. Treatment group consumers receive the new pricing scheme, plus targeted communication encouraging demand response. High-frequency metering data is collected for all units to allow precise estimation of treatment effects.
Design details
Cited by
No citation data available for this registration yet.