Government Scheme Overload: Take-Up and Targeting in a Multi-Scheme Context
How to cite
Mathur, Mitali. 2025. "Government Scheme Overload: Take-Up and Targeting in a Multi-Scheme Context." AEA RCT Registry. AEARCTR-0015640. https://doi.org/10.1257/rct.15640-1.1
Download: BibTeX · RIS — for reference managers without a browser translator. Zotero and most others pick up this page's citation metadata directly.
* Primary investigator
Abstract
Developing countries are often faced with a dilemma: governments offer a variety of social protection schemes to people in need, but take-up rates remain quite low. While researchers have studied interventions meant to improve the take-up and targeting of specific welfare schemes, little is known about how individuals navigate the entire system of welfare schemes and decide how many and which ones to apply to. Therefore, I investigate the following research question: How does the quantity of government welfare schemes offered to individuals affect the take-up and targeting of these benefits? I study this question by implementing a randomized controlled trial in which I experimentally vary the quantity of welfare schemes shared with internal migrants in India.
Intervention
I partner with a Non-Governmental Organization that offers last mile service delivery support to migrants in India. Frontline workers approach migrant communities to disseminate information on scheme eligibility and help register migrants for schemes. After introducing themselves and gaining trust, frontline workers use a mobile application to quickly survey one migrant at a time. This survey includes a variety of demographic questions about the migrant and their family. Upon completing the survey, the mobile application assesses a migrant and their family’s eligibility for different schemes, identified as priority schemes by the NGO.
I classify the schemes migrants are eligible for into two categories:
1. On-the-spot schemes – These are schemes migrants can typically be registered for “on the spot” with minimal documentation. These are primarily composed of schemes for which the migrant can apply to via a government website if they have their Aadhar card (National Identification Card) with them and a phone number linked to it to provide two-factor authentication. Frontline workers explain the scheme to the migrant, scan the migrant’s ID, and register the migrant for the scheme through the government website.
2. Additional schemes – The majority of schemes migrants are eligible for require documentation migrants may not have on their person. These include family ID cards, letters from school, proof of address, ration cards, and birth certificates. In order to apply for these schemes (conditional on eligibility), migrants are instructed to return to the NGO’s office with the relevant documentation, where the frontline worker can either register them on the government website directly or accompany them to a government office where a civil servant will register them.
Migrant workers and their family members are often eligible for both categories of schemes. This study seeks to understand how the quantity of schemes the migrant learns their eligibility about impacts the subsequent take-up of additional schemes via a RCT. The intervention varies both the mode and cadence by which frontline workers share information on schemes to migrant workers. The intervention does not impact the ability for migrants to receive information and apply to “on-the-spot” schemes, but rather, varies how many “additional” schemes they share with each migrant. Additionally, the intervention introduces a “hard-copy” to document what information is shared with the migrant utilizing non-carbon-paper receipt books.
Experimental design
SAMPLE: The study population consists of internal migrants in the Delhi NC Region (Delhi NCR) who had not previously been registered by a frontline worker. Frontline workers recruit migrant workers via their normal practice of entering migrant-dense communities and introducing the NGO’s work. A migrant community in any given day is assumed to be representative of internal migrants in New Delhi.
RANDOMIZATION: The NGO has 15 offices in Delhi NCR, from which the frontline workers base themselves and visit surrounding communities. I randomly assign each of the 15 offices into one of the three treatment arms.
INTERVENTION: Below are the three treatment arms:
1. Control - no change: Frontline workers register migrants using the mobile application and learn which schemes the migrant is eligible for. The frontline worker registers the migrant for the “on-the-spot” schemes they are eligible for and have documentation for. The frontline worker then fills out the receipt document for the migrant, indicating which schemes they registered for and providing an address of the nearest NGO office. The frontline worker uses their own discretion to verbally share additional information with the migrant on “additional schemes” the migrant is eligible for.
2. Treatment 1 - single scheme cadence: Frontline workers follow the same initial procedure from the control group with respect to registering migrants for “on-the-spot” schemes and recording a receipt of those. In addition, the frontline worker asks migrants, “You are eligible for one additional scheme I strongly recommend. Are you interested in learning about it and how to access it?” If migrants are interested in one scheme, the frontline worker can choose an additional scheme the app has identified the migrant being eligible for that the frontline worker recommends. The frontline worker then records this information on the receipt to describe the scheme, its benefits, and next steps the migrant should take to apply for the scheme. The migrant receives a copy of this document. If frontline workers come to an office, they will learn of another scheme.
3. Treatment 2 - multi-scheme cadence: Multiple Schemes: Frontline workers follow the same procedure registering migrants for “on-the-spot” schemes. Next, the frontline worker notes the total number of schemes the migrant and the migrant’s family is eligible for. With this information in mind, the frontline worker asks migrants, “You and your family are eligible for X total schemes. Are you interested in learning about them and how to access them?” If migrants are interested, they explain the schemes the migrant is eligible for and check the appropriate boxes on the large paper so that the migrant has a record of which (on a list) the migrant is eligible for.
The main difference between the two treatment groups are the quantity of information on “additional schemes” shared with migrants. In Treatment 1, migrants learn of one scheme and receive more detailed information about the scheme on a half-page sheet of paper. In Treatment 2, migrants learn of many schemes and receive a full A-4 sheet of paper containing a large list of all potential schemes with the ones they are eligible for clearly indicated.
Design details
Cited by
No citation data available for this registration yet.