Rural Institutional Innovation: Can Village Courts in Bangladesh Accelerate Access to Justice and Improve Socio-Economic Outcomes?
How to cite
Mattsson, Martin; Mobarak, Mushfiq. 2017. "Rural Institutional Innovation: Can Village Courts in Bangladesh Accelerate Access to Justice and Improve Socio-Economic Outcomes?." AEA RCT Registry. AEARCTR-0001563. https://doi.org/10.1257/rct.1563-4.0
Download: BibTeX · RIS — for reference managers without a browser translator. Zotero and most others pick up this page's citation metadata directly.
* Primary investigator
Abstract
Lack of access to the formal justice system is large problem for rural populations in most low and middle income countries. In Bangladesh informal dispute resolution mechanisms are common, but often lack the power to enforce decisions. There is also a perception of bias stemming from local power structures, which may discourage marginalized groups from using such mechanisms.
In 2006 the Government of Bangladesh passed into law a system of Village Courts (VCs) which are given the power to resolve smaller disputes (up to BDT 75,000, or roughly US$ 1,000). The VCs are anchored in the lowest tier of government, the Union Parishad (UP), with the UP Chair acting as the Chair of the court. While this is a great idea in theory to resolve small disputes cheaply with lower administrative complications, qualitative reports indicate that frequency of formation and use of the VCs have thus far been low. To counter this deficit, the Government of Bangladesh has launched a program called Activating Village Courts in Bangladesh (AVCB).
The AVCB program helps UPs to set up VC by educating local government representatives, providing material and human resources, and running awareness campaigns to encourage the local population to seek help from the VC. We will conduct an impact evaluation of the AVCB program using a Randomized Controlled Trial (RCT).
The impact evaluation would compare a treatment group of UPs where the AVCB program is implemented to a “control group” of UPs that do receive the program during the two-year study period. The impact evaluation will answer questions about the causal effect of the AVCB program on a range of outcome variables designed to test each step in our theory of how the VC affects village life. We will examine three broad categories of outcome variables. First, an “Access to justice” component will measure the cost and time it takes to resolve disputes, and the mechanisms households choose to use to resolve any dispute that they are involved in. Second, “quality of the justice process” will measure the nature and duration of continued conflict after the dispute was “resolved”, and self-reported satisfaction measures. Third, we will track longer term downstream effects of improved dispute resolution such as changes in economic activities where cooperation and contract enforcement are valuable, crime rates, trust and communal harmony, as well as political outcomes such as the satisfaction with the UP leaders. The impact evaluation will also be able to assess the spillover effect of the AVCB program on the Bangladeshi local justice system. Does, for example, the VCs decrease the burden on the district courts?
Intervention
Our intervention is the Activating Village Courts Bangladesh (AVCB) program.
The Village Court Act of 2006 requires that a Village Court (VC) be composed of an UP chair (who acts as the Chair of the VC) and four jury members nominated by the plaintiff and the defendant. The plaintiff and the defendant each nominate two jury members, of which two have to be from the twelve-person UP council. These five-person courts take on both criminal and civil cases and have the authority to adjudicate disputes up to BDT 75,000 or approximately USD 1,000. The VCs do not have the ability to adjudicate more serious criminal cases, such as abduction, rape, or murder. VCs can only impose financial punishments and cannot send defendants to prison. In disputes that involve women or children, at least one woman has to be appointed to the court.
The AVCB program was initiated because the VC structure had been implemented by almost no Ups by 2009—three years after the passing of the Village Courts Act. The AVCB program trains relevant local government officials, provides physical infrastructure in the form of court room furnishings and stationary, and provides a Village Court assistant (human capital) who helps with the daily administrative tasks of the VCs. The AVCB program also publicizes the VC system through television commercials, flyers, and even open-air theatre, informing local citizens of their right to seek justice from the VCs.
Experimental design
The experiment is based around the random selection of 187 UPs that will receive the AVCB program from a pool of 276 eligible UPs, 89 UPs are kept as a control group.
Design details
Papers from this trial
- Mattsson, M., & Mobarak, A. M. (2024). Formalizing dispute resolution: Effects of village courts in Bangladesh. Working Paper. https://papers.ssrn.com/sol3/papers.cfm?abstract_id=4740074
Cited by
No citation data available for this registration yet.