The How and Why of Household Reactions to Income Shocks

How to cite

Colarieti, Roberto; Stantcheva, Stefanie; Mei, Pierfrancesco. 2025. "The How and Why of Household Reactions to Income Shocks." AEA RCT Registry. AEARCTR-0015623. https://doi.org/10.1257/rct.15623-1.0

Download: BibTeX · RIS — for reference managers without a browser translator. Zotero and most others pick up this page's citation metadata directly.

Roberto Colarieti* , Stefanie Stantcheva , Pierfrancesco Mei

* Primary investigator

Registry ID
AEARCTR-0015623
DOI
https://doi.org/10.1257/rct.15623-1.0
First registered
Last updated
Status
Completed
Trial dates
2021-05-01 – 2023-01-31
Countries
United States of America ()
JEL codes
D12, D15, E21, E6, G51, H31
Registry record
http://www.socialscienceregistry.org/trials/15623

Abstract

This paper studies how and why households adjust their spending, saving, and borrowing in response to transitory income shocks. We leverage new large-scale survey data to first quantitatively assess households' intertemporal marginal propensities to consume (MPCs) and deleverage (MPDs) (the "how"), and second to dive into the motivations and decision-making processes across households (the "why"). The combination of the quantitative estimation of household response dynamics with a qualitative exploration of the mental models employed during financial decisions provides a more complete view of household behavior. Our findings are as follows. First, we validate the reliability of surveys in predicting actual economic behaviors using a new approach called cross-validation, which compares the responses to hypothetical financial scenarios with observed actions from past studies. Participants' predicted reactions closely align with real-life behaviors. Second, we show that MPCs are significantly higher immediately following an income shock and diminish over time, with cumulative MPCs over a year showing significant variability. However, MPDs play a critical role in household financial adjustments and display significantly more cross-sectional heterogeneity. Neither is easily explained by socioeconomic or financial characteristics alone, and the explanatory power is improved by adding psychological factors, past experiences, and expectations. Third, using specifically-designed survey questions, we find that there is a broad range of motivations behind households' financial decisions and identify four household types using machine learning: Strongly Constrained, Precautionary, Quasi-Smoothers, and Spenders. Similar financial actions stem from diverse reasons, challenging the predictability of financial behavior solely based on socioeconomic and financial characteristics. Finally, we use our findings to address some puzzles in household finance.

Intervention

We run separately two survey waves.
The main survey waves takes place between November 2022 and January 2023. The primary sample comes from this wave.
An additional survey waves takes place between May and October 2021.

Experimental design

For the primary survey wave (November 2022 - January 2023):
(A) We elicit spending and deleveraging propensities to income shocks through hypothetical scenarios. Respondents are asked to allocate hypothetical income shocks to additional spending, debt repayments, and savings over four quarters. We adopt the following randomizations. (i) The shock size (fixed and worth $1000, or 10% of the household’s total annual net income); (ii) The shock sign, either positive (unexpected one-time payment) or negative (unexpected one-time expense); (iii) The timing of the shock: each respondent is presented with two scenarios. In the first scenario, common to all respondents, the income shock occurs right away. In the second scenario, a randomly selected half of the sample is asked to consider an income shock occurring in one quarter, and the other half a shock occurring in two quarters in the future. Treatments (i)-(ii)-(iii) are assigned independently across them.
(B) We also elicit qualitative responses to income shocks. First, we elicit adjustment margins used by the household in response to both positive and negative income shocks of the same size as described in (A). Then, conditional on selecting or not selecting a given adjustment margin (i.e., spending, debt, savings, working hours), respondents are asked a set of questions about why they are using or not using that given margin.

For the first wave of our survey (May - October 2021): we additionally randomize across the source and the horizon of the income shock. In particular, the source of the shock can either be a direct Federal transfer such as a stimulus check, or a generic non-government transfer such as a bonus, gift or win. The horizon over which respondents allocate the income shock is instead either four or eight quarters.

Overall, the goal of our randomizations is to allocate different types of income shocks across respondents.

Design details

Randomization method
Randomization is done automatically by Qualtrics (the program we used to run the survey). The survey is conducted online.
Randomization unit
The randomization is at the individual level. The individuals are U.S. residents who are in the labor force at the time of the interview, and are aged between 25 and 65.
Clusters
We do not have clusters.
Observations
The primary wave (November 2022 - January 2023) has approximately 3000 respondents. The first wave of the survey (May - October 2021) has approximately 1200 respondents.
Arms
For the primary sample (Nov 2022 - Jan 2023), we allocate half of the sample in each treatment arm. Treatments (i)-(ii)-(iii) are assigned independently across them. So: (i) 1500 respondents receive a fixed income shock and 1500 respondents receive a proportional income shock; (ii)1500 respondents receive a positive income shock and 1500 respondents receive a negative income shock; (iii) 1500 respondents receive a shock that occurs in 1 quarter and 1500 respondents receive a shock that occurs in 2 quarters. For the first wave (May - October 2021) we allocate: (a) 600 respondents to the government transfer income source vs 600 respondents to the non government transfer income shocks; (b) 840 respondents are allocated to the 4 quarter horizon vs 360 respondents are allocated to the 8 quarter horizon.
Primary outcomes
The key outcome variables are: (1) spending and deleveraging propensities of surveyed households in response to hypothetical income shocks; (2) classification of households based on self-reported reasons to spend or deleverage.

Cited by

No citation data available for this registration yet.

Keywords