On-the-Job Training for Politicians: Evidence from Brazil

How to cite

Canini, Renata; Albuquerque, Amanda de; Finan, Frederico; Fujiwara, Thomas. 2025. "On-the-Job Training for Politicians: Evidence from Brazil." AEA RCT Registry. AEARCTR-0015617. https://doi.org/10.1257/rct.15617-1.0

Download: BibTeX · RIS — for reference managers without a browser translator. Zotero and most others pick up this page's citation metadata directly.

Renata Canini* , Amanda de Albuquerque , Frederico Finan , Thomas Fujiwara

* Primary investigator

Registry ID
AEARCTR-0015617
DOI
https://doi.org/10.1257/rct.15617-1.0
First registered
Last updated
Status
On going
Trial dates
2025-04-21 – 2028-12-31
Countries
Private
JEL codes
C93 ; D72 ; J16 ; H83
Secondary IDs
O15 ; I31 ;
Registry record
http://www.socialscienceregistry.org/trials/15617

Abstract

This randomized controlled trial evaluates the impact of a technical and continuous support program, “Gabinete Compartilhado” (Shared Cabinet), on the performance and career trajectories of first-term women city councilors in Brazil. The program is implemented by an NGO, Rede A Ponte, which provides a combination of individualized legislative assistance, budgetary training, legal support, and peer learning opportunities, with a focus on racial and gender equity. The trial aims to measure effects on legislative output, executive oversight activity, policy influence, political ambition, mental health, and re-election outcomes. The study contributes to the literature on political representation, gender and racial equity in government positions, and the effectiveness of support interventions for the performance of early-career and female politicians at the local level.

Intervention

The intervention provided to treated participants is Gabinete Compartilhado (Shared Cabinet), a continuous technical support program targeting first-term women city councilors in Brazil. The program offers a package of resources which include:
1. Legislative assistance: legal advisory in drafting legislation
2. Budget monitoring tools: courses and a hotline for urgent support on the municipal budget
3. Policy briefs on themes relevant to local legislative activity
4. Ongoing peer learning opportunities in courses and one-to-one meetings
5. On-demand meetings with specialists
Structured workshops and courses on evidence-based policies, political articulation, strategic planning and mental health.
Additionally, participants are encouraged to join Wave of Bills, a project that provides bill proposals based on scientific evidence and previously approved legislation, and reviewed by experts in the field. The bill proposals are focused on a myriad of public policy topics of general interest and relevance to their mandate, such as domestic violence and early childhood care. Finally, the NGO also offers legal support for cases of political violence.

Experimental design

The study employs a randomized controlled trial design involving 83 first-term women city councilors across Brazil. Only one councilor per municipality is included in the study to avoid spillovers and competition, and stratified randomization is conducted based on quotas related to region, political alignment (left vs.center and right), and race (Black or Indigenous vs. other). Candidates are grouped into smaller groups of 3 to 15 individuals based on a PCA score defined by local and individual characteristics. One councilor is randomly selected within each subgroup to receive the treatment, while others are controls. Finally, subgroups are assigned to treatment or waitlist randomly. All estimates are weighted by the propensity score, which is calculated accounting for group-level quotas and stratification weights. Waitlist procedures are used to replace non-takers in a way that preserves the balance of the sample and the group-quota assignment.

Design details

Randomization method
The randomization is conducted in STATA, using cleaned and treated data from the Supreme Electoral Court on candidates of the 2024 plea, excluding those which appear as elected previously to 2024 to focus on first-term mandates. The waitlist is constructed such that we have enough replacements for at least 3 non-takers in each group. Replacement procedures rely on a pre-established waitlist ranked by subgroup scores, ensuring balance is maintained in case of attrition.
Randomization unit
The unit of randomization is the individual councilor. To avoid contamination or spillover effects, only one councilor is selected per municipality to be potentially treated. The first step involved a within-municipality randomization that randomly allocated a rank to each female candidate in that municipality. Then, municipalities are chosen randomly to enter the sample, and the first-ranked legislator represents that municipality in the sample.
Clusters
434 councilwomen, where 83 are treated and the rest are controls.
Observations
434 councilwomen.
Arms
83 councilors treated, and 351 in control.
Primary outcomes
The trial focuses on three main dimensions of impact: technical improvement of legislative activity, soft skills development, and political ability. The key outcomes are: 1) Legislative Output a) self-reported ability to draft and submit bills b) number and type bills proposed, approval rate of bills c) share of policy-related draft bills proposed (instead of “symbolic”ones) 2) Executive Oversight a) self-reported ability to conduct executive oversight activities b) self-reported ability to interfere in the Municipal Budget c) self-reported ability to participate in legislative committees 3) Strategic Planning and Mandate Management a) structure of mandate activities and programmatic prioritization from questionnaire 4) Future in Politics a) self-reported ambition in politics from questionnaire
Secondary outcomes
Secondary outcomes include: 1) Mental Health and Team Management a) questionnaire scoring 2) Occurrence and Vulnerability to Gender and Race-based Political Violence a) questionnaire scoring 3) Political alliances/isolation within and outside of Chamber a) questionnaire scoring 4) Party relationship and position within the party a) questionnaire scoring

Cited by

No citation data available for this registration yet.

Keywords