Neuroeconomics of Competition and Performance Feedback
How to cite
Ertac, Seda; Soyman, Efe. 2025. "Neuroeconomics of Competition and Performance Feedback." AEA RCT Registry. AEARCTR-0015602. https://doi.org/10.1257/rct.15602-1.0
Download: BibTeX · RIS — for reference managers without a browser translator. Zotero and most others pick up this page's citation metadata directly.
* Primary investigator
Abstract
It is well-known that some individuals, particularly women, tend to shy away from competition. This creates significant inefficiency in education and labor market outcomes, as highly able individuals with negative attitudes toward competition are less likely to reach top positions. Part of the negative attitude towards competitive settings can come from the stress/anxiety induced by competition, especially in cases where there is performance feedback. This study will explore 1) the behavioral and neural correlates of the attitudes and response of men and women to competitive environments and performance feedback, 2) the question of whether providing individuals with experience in competitive environments with feedback changes the way they respond to negative and positive performance feedback within such environments. The study will collect both behavioral and neural data, the latter through EEG.
Intervention
A behavioral experience session will be conducted before the EEG session, where a random set of subjects will do tasks with competition and performance feedback (this group will get rewards based on competition outcome), while a control group does the same tasks without feedback and without any incentives related to performance. After this behavioral experience session, participants will participate in the EEG session, where we will collect the main outcome measures.
Experimental design
The study starts with an exploratory survey conducted online. The exploratory survey serves several purposes:
1) Collect measures of competitiveness that will provide a basis for recruiting participants into the neuroeconomics study, that explores the question of whether providing competition experience can change the neural response to positive and negative performance feedback in a competitive environment, 2) Provide baseline data that will allow us to correlate neural responses in the neuroeconomics study with baseline behavioral attitudes towards competitiveness and performance feedback, 3) Do an exploratory analysis of the correlates of the decision to compete in different competitive settings, and their predictive power over achievement. Participants from a range of attitudes towards competition and feedback will then be invited to the study, and upon selection, randomly assigned to treatment (behavioral experience) and control (no experience). These participants will then participate in an EEG session to measure neural activity in competition with a variety of tasks, with feedback.
Invited participants will then be asked to take part in a "behavioral experience session" where a random set of subjects will engage in tasks under competitive incentives and performance feedback, while a control group will see the same tasks without feedback or any performance incentives.
Finally, there will be an EEG session designed to measure the neural correlates of the response to win/loss feedback in a competitive environment.
Design details
Cited by
No citation data available for this registration yet.