Personalised Step Thresholds and Physical Activity Incentives: A Randomised Controlled Trial
How to cite
Sussman, Kay-leigh; Costa-Font, Joan; Snoyman, Dean; Venter, Stefan; Lagarde, Mylene. 2025. "Personalised Step Thresholds and Physical Activity Incentives: A Randomised Controlled Trial." AEA RCT Registry. AEARCTR-0015589. https://doi.org/10.1257/rct.15589-2.1
Download: BibTeX · RIS — for reference managers without a browser translator. Zotero and most others pick up this page's citation metadata directly.
* Primary investigator
Abstract
This study evaluates whether personalised step-to-points thresholds improve engagement in an insurer-linked physical activity incentive programme in the United Kingdom. The trial was embedded in a digital app platform operating alongside the insurer’s standard rewards programme.
Eligible adult members with low prior recorded physical activity were invited to join the study app. Participants entered a six-week baseline period followed by a six-week intervention period, with rolling enrolment between November 2023 and February 2024. After post-baseline eligibility confirmation, 714 participants were randomised within insurer-defined engagement strata (Unengaged vs Low engaged).
Randomisation was stratified by engagement group and implemented automatically within the study app. In the Low engaged stratum, participants were allocated to control (CL) or personalised thresholds with bonus (TL). In the Unengaged stratum, participants were allocated to control (CU), personalised thresholds with streak bonus (TU), or personalised thresholds without streak bonus (TU no bonus). Control groups remained on the insurer’s standard step-to-points schedule. Personalised groups started on more attainable step thresholds and could progress toward less generous schedules according to pre-specified platform rules. Participants received a £5 weekly Amazon voucher for meeting the weekly goal (>=12 points), and bonus-eligible arms also received a £15 streak bonus for meeting the goal in all six intervention weeks.
The primary outcome was participant-level mean weekly goal achievement during intervention weeks 0 to 5 (observed weeks only). Secondary outcomes included participant-level mean weekly steps and an indicator for achieving the weekly goal at least once. The primary analysis pooled bonus-treatment arms (TU and TL) versus pooled controls (CU and CL), with a secondary comparison within the Unengaged stratum.
In the main pooled comparison, personalised thresholds with a bonus improved weekly goal attainment but did not produce a statistically detectable increase in mean weekly steps over the six-week intervention period. Follow-up observation in platform data was incomplete and differed by arm, so missing-data sensitivity analyses were conducted and reported.
Intervention
This study evaluated personalised step-to-points thresholds in a UK health insurer-linked trial app operating alongside the insurer’s standard rewards programme. Participants were adults with very low or low prior recorded physical activity (insurer-defined “Unengaged” and “Low engaged” groups) who downloaded the study app and consented to data use. After a six-week baseline period in the trial platform (weeks -6 to -1) used for eligibility confirmation, participants were randomised within engagement strata.
The trial platform awarded points for device-recorded activity (steps and workouts), with a weekly goal of at least 12 points. Participants received a £5 Amazon voucher for each intervention week in which they achieved the weekly goal. In bonus-eligible arms, participants also received a £15 Amazon voucher if they achieved the weekly goal in all six intervention weeks (weeks 0 to 5).
The intervention manipulated the step-to-points schedule (levels 0 to 5). Level 5 was the standard schedule used in the insurer’s usual programme. Personalised arms started on a more generous schedule and could move toward less generous schedules over time according to pre-specified platform rules. Progression required (i) achieving the weekly goal in the preceding week and (ii) meeting a rolling six-week average points threshold for the next level. Participants who failed to achieve the weekly goal for two consecutive weeks moved back one level (to a more generous schedule).
Trial arms (stratified by engagement group) were:
Low engaged stratum:
- CL (control, low engaged): standard schedule (level 5 throughout)
- TL (treatment, low engaged): personalised thresholds with streak bonus; started on level 3 and could transition across levels under the platform rule; eligible for the £15 streak bonus
Unengaged stratum:
- CU (control, unengaged): standard schedule (level 5 throughout)
- TU (treatment, unengaged): personalised thresholds with streak bonus; started on level 1 and could transition across levels under the platform rule; eligible for the £15 streak bonus
- TU no bonus (treatment, unengaged): same personalised threshold progression as TU, but not eligible for the £15 streak bonus
No group started on level 0. The intervention period lasted six weeks (weeks 0 to 5), following the six-week baseline period.
Experimental design
This study is a randomised controlled trial embedded in a UK health insurer-linked digital rewards environment. Participants were members with low prior recorded physical activity, identified using insurer engagement classifications (“Unengaged” and “Low engaged”), invited by email, and enrolled in a study app. Participants were enrolled on a rolling basis between November 2023 and February 2024. Study time was indexed to each participant’s intervention start date. The design included a six-week baseline period (weeks -6 to -1) and a six-week intervention period (weeks 0 to 5).
After consent and app download, six weeks of trial-platform baseline data were used to confirm eligibility and exclude participants whose observed baseline activity was inconsistent with the intended low-activity sample. Randomisation was then implemented automatically within the study app after baseline eligibility confirmation. Randomisation was stratified by insurer engagement stratum (Unengaged vs Low engaged). Intended allocation was 1:1 in the Low engaged stratum (CL vs TL) and 1:1:1 in the Unengaged stratum (CU vs TU vs TU no bonus). Allocation was computer-generated and concealed prior to assignment. Outcomes were recorded automatically by the trial platform. Participants could view their own targets and rewards in the app but were not informed of arm labels or other participants’ schedules.
The intervention varied the step-to-points schedule used to earn weekly points. Control groups (CL and CU) remained on the standard schedule (level 5). Personalised groups began on more generous schedules and could progress toward less generous schedules under pre-specified level transition rules. All groups were eligible for a £5 Amazon voucher for achieving the weekly goal (>=12 points) in a given week. TU and TL were additionally eligible for a £15 bonus for achieving the weekly goal in all six intervention weeks; TU no bonus was not bonus-eligible.
The primary endpoint is the participant-level mean weekly goal-achievement indicator over intervention weeks 0 to 5 (observed weeks only). Secondary endpoints are participant-level mean weekly steps over intervention weeks 0 to 5 (observed weeks only) and an indicator for achieving the weekly goal at least once during weeks 0 to 5. The main ITT comparison pools bonus-treatment arms (TU and TL) versus pooled controls (CU and CL). A secondary comparison is conducted within the Unengaged stratum (TU vs TU no bonus vs CU). Analyses are estimated at the participant level using assignment-based (ITT) models; missing platform observation is characterised separately and addressed in sensitivity analyses.
Design details
Cited by
No citation data available for this registration yet.