Impacts of access to book corners and reading diaries on cognitive and non-cognitive outcomes: A field experiment in Nan, Thailand

How to cite

Chankrajang, Thanyaporn; Chimmamee, Montakarn; Kantawang, Pikoon; Khuvasanond, Kirati; Rodkroh, Pornpimon; Sukontamarn, Pataporn; Atichartchayakorn, Thiti. 2025. "Impacts of access to book corners and reading diaries on cognitive and non-cognitive outcomes: A field experiment in Nan, Thailand." AEA RCT Registry. AEARCTR-0015572. https://doi.org/10.1257/rct.15572-1.1

Download: BibTeX · RIS — for reference managers without a browser translator. Zotero and most others pick up this page's citation metadata directly.

Thanyaporn Chankrajang* , Montakarn Chimmamee , Pikoon Kantawang , Kirati Khuvasanond , Pornpimon Rodkroh , Pataporn Sukontamarn , Thiti Atichartchayakorn

* Primary investigator

Registry ID
AEARCTR-0015572
DOI
https://doi.org/10.1257/rct.15572-1.1
First registered
Last updated
Status
Completed
Trial dates
2017-06-19 – 2025-02-11
Countries
Thailand (Southeast Asia)
JEL codes
I20, J13, O15, Z11
Registry record
http://www.socialscienceregistry.org/trials/15572

Abstract

The study aims to evaluate the impacts of access to book corners that are equipped with grade-appropriate children’s books and reading diaries to primary school students on both cognitive and non-cognitive outcomes and in both short and long runs. Whilst previous RCTs that also experiment on providing textbooks and books barely find significant effects mostly due to language barriers, our study exploits the setup in Thailand that students’ mother tongue and the language used in the books are the same. We randomly divide randomly chosen 62 schools with altogether 5,708 students into three groups. The first group of 21 schools each receives a book corner with a set of children’s books that span a variety of topics from popular science to children’s literature, and each individual student gets a grade-tailored reading diary to match the children's books. The second treatment group of 21 schools is also provided with a book corner but the students get no reading diaries. The two treatments help distinguish whether there is a differential impact between reading-for-purpose (Treatment 1) and reading-for-pleasure (Treatment 2) among primary school students. The rest of the 20 schools constitute the control group.

Regarding cognitive outcomes, we test the students on the literacy of Thai language by the Programmes’ own devised Thai reading and writing tests for each grade at End points 1 and 2, after an academic year and a summer holiday. Due to a lack of funding, for longer terms, we first rely on the standardised grade-appropriate reading and writing Thai language tests by the Ministry of Education at End point 3, three years after the commencement of the intervention. Second, we utilise the standardised national test (O-NET) on Thai language, Mathematics, Science and English for students in sixth grade, the last grade for primary education. As such, this End point 4 spans one to five years after the start of the intervention. This test enables us to evaluate the spillover impact of reading proficiency on other subjects.

With reference to non-cognitive outcomes, we based our investigation on our devised questionnaires given to the students at End points 1 and 2. They cover library-using and non-textbook reading behaviours, school-domain attentiveness and empathy, which are characters that are closely related to reading and hence access to book resources. While literature shows that school-domain attentiveness is crucial for individual life outcomes, empathy can additionally improve social outcomes.

Intervention

The study aims to evaluate the impacts of access to book corners that are equipped with grade-appropriate children’s books and reading diaries to primary school students on both cognitive and non-cognitive outcomes and in both short and long runs. We randomly divide randomly chosen 62 schools with altogether 5,708 students from Grades 1 to 6 in Lower Nan Province into three groups. The first group of 21 schools each receives a book corner with a set of 129 children’s books. The books have been evaluated by children’s books experts and academics. They cover children’s literature, popular science, character-building children’s books, and creativity-and-imagination-enhancing children’s books. The book corner consists of an inviting, colourful and visible shelf, sitting mats and a Japanese table. Also, for the first treatment group, each individual student gets a grade-tailored reading diary, designed by the Programme, to match the children's books for each grade. The second treatment group of 21 schools is also provided with a book corner but the students get no reading diaries. The two treatments help distinguish whether there are differential cognitive and non-cognitive impacts between reading-for-purpose (Treatment 1) and reading-for-pleasure (Treatment 2) among primary school students. The rest of the 20 schools constitute the control group. The treatment schools in both groups get to keep the book corners even after the completion of the experiment.

Experimental design

The trial is designed to test the significance of access to children’s books’ resources or resource constraint hypothesis. As such, we have the treatment groups that are provided with book corners. To further illustrate the mechanism inside the children’s reading process, we have two distinct treatment groups; one with reading dairies designed particularly for each grade’s books and distributed to individual students, and one without. This helps us distinguish whether there is a differential impact between reading-for-purpose and reading-for-pleasure. The trial is conducted upon the 62 randomly chosen state primary schools with altogether 5,708 students in Lower Nan Province, which represents primary schools in Thailand. We obtain the names of the schools in the Regional Education Area One of Nan Province which is in Lower Nan and then randomise to select schools into the sample and then randomise again to assign the schools into three groups. Then we contact the schools to see whether they would like to participate in the experiment. All of them agree. We do not target any group of children but all children in primary schools that participate in the Programme.

Design details

Randomization method
Randomisation was done in the office by a computer over all state primary schools in Lower Nan Regional Education Area.
Randomization unit
School
Clusters
Number of schools: 62 schools in total Treatment 1: 21 schools Treatment 2: 21 schools Control: 20 Schools
Observations
Number of students across all treatment arms: 5,708 students altogether from Grades 1 to 6.
Arms
Treatment 1: 21 schools and 2,319 students The schools in Treatment 1 receive a book corner with a set of 129 children’s books. They cover children’s literature, popular science, character-building children’s books, and creativity-and-imagination-enhancing children’s books. The book corner consists of an inviting, colourful and visible shelf, sitting mats and a Japanese table. Also, for the first treatment group, each individual student gets a grade-tailored reading diary, designed by the Programme, to match the children's books assigned for that grade. Treatment 2: 21 schools and 1,617 students The second treatment group of 21 schools is also provided with a book corner but the students get no reading diaries. Control: 20 schools and 1,772 students The control schools receive nothing.
Primary outcomes
End point 1: Short-run impacts after an academic year (i) Library-using and non-textbook reading behaviours (ii) Cognitive outcomes in terms of literacy of Thai language tested by the Programmes’ own devised Thai reading and writing tests for each grade (iii) Non-cognitive outcomes that can be related to reading – attentiveness (iv) Non-cognitive outcomes that can be related to reading -- empathy End point 2: Medium-run impacts after a summer holiday and before the students learn new literacy material of the new academic year according to their curriculum (i) Cognitive outcomes in terms of literacy of Thai language tested by the Programmes’ own devised Thai reading and writing tests for each grade (ii) Non-cognitive outcomes that can be related to reading – attentiveness (iii) Non-cognitive outcomes that can be related to reading -- empathy End point 3: Long-run cognitive outcomes after three years from the start of the intervention. Using the reading and writing Thai language tests for each grade, based on the nationalised tests by the Ministry of Education. End point 4: Long-run cognitive outcomes when students from each grade reach grade 6. Using the nationalised O-NET exam on Thai language, Mathematics, Science, and English to test the long-term effects whether reading can have a spillover impact on the proficiency of other subjects that are also based on the ability to read, understand and analyse, and concentrate. Note that the O-NET, which stands for "Ordinary National Educational Test," is a standardised, nationwide exam in Thailand that assesses the knowledge and abilities of students in grades 6, 9, and 12, primarily used to evaluate the quality of education at a national level and inform teaching practices within schools; it is administered by the National Institute of Educational Testing Service (NIETS) and is based on the Basic Education Core Curriculum of Thailand.

Cited by

No citation data available for this registration yet.

Keywords