Selective Memory of Goals as Reference Points

How to cite

Wang, Ao; Mueller, Maximilian; Bessagnet, Lony. 2025. "Selective Memory of Goals as Reference Points." AEA RCT Registry. AEARCTR-0015551. https://doi.org/10.1257/rct.15551-1.1

Download: BibTeX · RIS — for reference managers without a browser translator. Zotero and most others pick up this page's citation metadata directly.

Ao Wang* , Maximilian Mueller , Lony Bessagnet

* Primary investigator

Registry ID
AEARCTR-0015551
DOI
https://doi.org/10.1257/rct.15551-1.1
First registered
Last updated
Status
In development
Trial dates
2025-03-07 – 2027-12-25
Countries
Private
Registry record
http://www.socialscienceregistry.org/trials/15551

Abstract

The objective of this study is to understand the role of memory on the formation of educational goals regarding key metrics of academic performance, such as high school grade average. As the most important educational goals are often set for long-term purposes, their impact on educational effort or motivation depends on its persistence. On the other hand, however, goals have been recognized as a plausible candidate for reference points that bring sensation of gains and losses, and such sensation may induce students to manipulate them for the sake of wellbeing. This mechanism implies that long-term goals may be moderated by imperfect, and potentially biased recall of the original goals that one sets in the past. Armed with experimental variation, we seek to answer the following questions: (I) Whether recall of past goal is imperfect or biased, and how such imperfection or bias varies with one's current academic performance relative to one's original goal; (II) Whether incentives to enhance recall accuracy, and whether one's current relative academic performance moderates such effect; (III) Whether pre-announced incentives to remember the original goal enhances recall accuracy and educational performance.

Intervention

As elaborated in the "Experimental Design" section, students are randomized into seven groups (Groups A through G) over the course of three surveys. Group G serves as the control group: while students in this group are asked in Surveys 2 and 3 to recall the goal they stated in Survey 1, these recall questions are not incentivized, and no advance notice is given in Survey 1.

In contrast, for the treatment groups (Groups A–F), the goal recall questions in Surveys 2 and/or 3 are incentivized. Additionally, some of these groups receive advance notice in Survey 1 about the upcoming recall questions.

Experimental design

We plan to recruit 750 students who are about to take the Abitur. The final exams account for one third of their Abitur average, and they also function as the college entrance exams. These students would take three surveys. The key questions in the survey include the stated goal for the Abitur average, recollection of their stated goal and the recall accuracy, wellbeing as a function of academic performance, response time to key questions, as well as subject-specific performance, attitudes, and reported effort.

The experimental variations are implemented in the surveys. There are two major forms of variations to incentivize recalling the original goal. Ex-ante incentive refers to the kind of intervention where we inform students after they stated their goal of performance (Survey 1) that we will ask them about their original goal in specified waves in the future. Ex-post incentive refers to the kind of intervention where students are not given heads-up about the memory question in a specific wave, but questions that incentivize them to remember pop up unexpectedly in Survey 2 and 3. These two conditions are compared to None (No Incentives), which means that the question about goal recall is asked but not incentivized. In terms of these variations, we split the sample into seven groups (A, B, C, D, E, F, G)

Group A, B, C, D includes information in Survey 1 that informs students that the recall questions about their original goal will be asked in either Survey 2 or Survey 3. They will get an extra 5 euro if their answer is correct in the corresponding survey. The specific survey where the questions appear are listed below:
(A) (125 students) - Ex-ante for Survey 2, None for Survey 3,
(B) (125 students) - Ex-ante for Survey 2, Ex-post for Survey 3,
(C) (100 students) - None in Survey 2, Ex-ante for Survey 3,
(D) (100 students) - Ex-Post in Survey 2, Ex-ante for Survey 3,

In Group A and B, students are informed in Survey 1 that we will ask their original goal in an incentivized manner in Survey 2. In Group C and D, we will ask about their original goal in an incentivized manner in Survey 3. Note that for Ex-Post we would not inform students beforehand, although the incentivized goal recall question and its incentive will appear in the same form in the survey. None means that the question that ask students to recall also appear but would not be incentivized.

In Group E, F, G, students are not informed in Survey 1 that they might be questions that ask them recall their goal.
(E) (100 students) - Ex-post in Survey 2 + None in Survey 3
(F) (100 students) - None for Survey 2 + Ex-post for Survey 3
(G) (100 students) - None for Survey 2 + none for Survey 3

Note that not informing students in Survey 1 does not mean that the questions that ask students to recall does not appear. As we explained above, all Ex-post intervention includes the incentivized recall questions, so in Group E, the recall question in Survey 2 will actually be incentivized and the recall question in Survey 3 will not be incentivized, despite the plan that students will not be told about them in Survey 1.

In terms of the exact timing, Survey 1 is scheduled to take place right before Abitur exams take place. Survey 2 is scheduled to take place 4~6 months after the exams. Survey 3 is scheduled to take place 12~18 months after the exams.

Design details

Randomization method
Randomization by Qualtrics
Randomization unit
Individual
Clusters
About 90-100 schools
Observations
700 - 750 students (possibly in 2 waves). For later waves of surveys (Survey 2 and 3), we expect attrition of 10%.
Arms
750 students. Group A: 125 students Group B: 125 students Group C: 100 students Group D: 100 students Group E: 100 students Group F: 100 students Group G: 100 students
Primary outcomes
recalled goal, (relative) academic performance, stated wellbeing, stated wellbeing as a function of counterfactual academic performance [note: we plan to restrict our analysis of stated wellbeing questions to those who answer the wellbeing questions before the recall questions]
Secondary outcomes
recall accuracy for the overall performance, response time for recall question, goal by subjects and their recall accuracy, perceived importance by subjects; recall accuracy of placebo questions (Stress during Exam Preparation and Attention Check)

Cited by

No citation data available for this registration yet.

Keywords