What motives increase prosocial behavior? An experiment on blood donation
How to cite
Ballicu, Gabriele; Pelligra, Vittorio. 2025. "What motives increase prosocial behavior? An experiment on blood donation." AEA RCT Registry. AEARCTR-0015541. https://doi.org/10.1257/rct.15541-1.0
Download: BibTeX · RIS — for reference managers without a browser translator. Zotero and most others pick up this page's citation metadata directly.
* Primary investigator
Abstract
Although numerous surveys have explored why people donate blood, no research has compared the strength of these motivations with actual donation rates. To fill this gap, we conducted a field experiment with 24,839 college students, sending them messages targeting different motivations (social norms, empathy, guilt, and self-interest motives). We tracked both their willingness to donate and their actual donations, and found a consistent gap between intention and action. In addition, responses varied significantly depending on the messages received. These findings have important policy implications, informing targeted advertising campaigns and helping to identify the right audiences for blood donation initiatives.
Intervention
We have five treatments of the online questionnaire (run between subjects), each with a standard structure of questions (regarding demographic and blood information, as well as questions about attitudes and beliefs on blood donation). Afterward, we ask the subjects if they want to donate blood during the blood drive (this serves as the proxy for intention to donate). This last message differs across groups:
A simple message (T0) that asks participants to be contacted by a voluntary blood donation association.
A norm-framed message (T1) that incorporates the effect of social, descriptive, and moral norms, combined with reciprocity.
A burden-to-not-donate framed message (T2) that combines reluctant altruism with guilty-regret emotion and inequality aversion.
An empathy-framed message (T3) that uses the identifying victim effect, with a story of two people (a male and a female) needing blood donations.
A hedonistic-framed message (T4) with self-interested motives (such as a free day from work, scholarships, free medical check-ups, and health benefits).
Experimental design
Subjects receive an email explaining the importance of gathering information and opinions about blood donation, especially to improve blood donation organizations in the region. Another email follows with a survey that offers a potential financial reward upon completion. We explain that they can participate in a survey, which takes about five minutes, conducted in collaboration with AVIS (the largest blood bank organization in Italy), to analyze public opinions on blood donation. We also remind them about the possibility of winning a monetary prize and that they can book a day to donate blood.
We make it clear that it is essential to remember the unique code generated after completing the survey. However, we emphasize that the probability of winning the prize is entirely independent of the decision to donate blood, as participants will be randomly assigned to receive the prize. The only requirement to win the prize is completing the questionnaire, which is crucial to prevent biasing people's behavior by motivating them to donate due to a "lottery incentive."
To encourage participation, we incentivize completion to increase the sample size. We award 20 prizes of 100 euros ten days after the blood drives, selecting twenty randomly from those who complete the survey. To prevent people from filling out the questionnaire multiple times to increase their chances of winning or obtaining more codes, they must log in with their institutional email to enter the lottery. Personal and questionnaire data are collected on separate sites and stored in distinct datasets to protect participants' privacy and anonymity and to avoid any potential experimental demand effects.
Design details
Cited by
No citation data available for this registration yet.