Long(er)-term Effects of the Targeting the Ultra Poor Program

How to cite

Cai, Rebecca; Duflo, Esther; Banerjee, Abhijit; Sharma, Garima. 2025. "Long(er)-term Effects of the Targeting the Ultra Poor Program." AEA RCT Registry. AEARCTR-0015528. https://doi.org/10.1257/rct.15528-2.0

Download: BibTeX · RIS — for reference managers without a browser translator. Zotero and most others pick up this page's citation metadata directly.

Rebecca Cai* , Esther Duflo , Abhijit Banerjee , Garima Sharma

* Primary investigator

Registry ID
AEARCTR-0015528
DOI
https://doi.org/10.1257/rct.15528-2.0
First registered
Last updated
Status
On going
Trial dates
2007-02-01 – 2025-10-01
Countries
Private
JEL codes
I32, I38, J22, J31, O12, O18
Registry record
http://www.socialscienceregistry.org/trials/15528

Abstract

This study is a follow-up on the long-term impacts of the Targeting the Ultra Poor (TUP) program. The original randomized controlled trial (RCT) was conducted in West Bengal, India, in 2007, to evaluate the effects of a ”big-push” program that provided asset transfers, consumption support, savings, and training to the poorest households. This pre-analysis plan outlines the empirical strategy for examining the longer-term effects, six years after the previous survey wave at year 10 studied in Banerjee, Duflo, and Sharma (2021). We will report treatment effects on the same outcomes as in the 10-year follow-up. We additionally investigate households' experiences during the COVID pandemic and effects on the children and grandchildren of original beneficiaries.

Intervention

Beneficiaries received an asset (e.g., livestock, non-farm microenterprise inventory),
weekly consumption support for 30-40 weeks, savings access, and 18 months of weekly
training visits. No further program contact occurred post-intervention, other than follow-up surveys.

Experimental design

The present study does not involve any intervention or experiment. It conducts an additional follow-up survey on treatment and control groups that received an intervention from 2007-2008.

In the original experiment, the poorest households were identified in two steps. First, residents across 120 village hamlets ranked households into five wealth quintiles. Among households ranked in the bottom quintile, Bandhan then verified eligibility per seven criteria: (i) presence of an able-
bodied female member (to manage the asset), (ii) no credit access, (iii) landholding below 0.2 acres, (iv) no ownership of productive assets, (v) no able-bodied male member, (vi) presence of school-aged children who
were working instead of attending school, and (vii) primary source of income being informal labor or begging. Households had to meet the first two criteria and at least three of the remaining five in order to be eligible for the TUP intervention. In total, 978 households were deemed eligible. Roughly half of these (514) were randomly assigned to receive the intervention, with stratification at the hamlet level. Of these, only 266 accepted treatment. All reported estimates are intent-to-treat estimates.

Households in the treatment group who chose to participate chose a productive asset from a menu of options (two cows, four goats, one cow and two goats, nonfarm microenterprise inventory, etc). About 82 percent chose livestock. In addition to the asset, they received weekly consumption support for 30–
40 weeks,3 access to savings, and weekly visits from Bandhan staff over a span of 18 months. These visits were designed to deliver training on generating income from the chosen asset, lifeskills coaching, and health information. Bandhan had no contact with beneficiary
households starting 18 months after the asset transfer.

To collect information on baseline household characteristics, the research team administered a survey prior to the distribution of assets in 2007–2008, recording household demographics, consumption, food security, asset ownership, income, income sources, financial inclusion, adult time use, and physical and mental well-being. We track economic and health outcomes for treated and control households
through four subsequent survey waves administered at 18 months, 3 years, 7 years,
and 10 years, and now 16 years after the transfer of productive assets.

Design details

Randomization method
Randomization done in office by a computer.
Randomization unit
Randomization at the household level, stratified by hamlet (similar to a village).
Clusters
978 households
Observations
2,300 people
Arms
514 households assigned to treatment, 464 assigned to control
Primary outcomes
The primary outcomes to be analyzed are regarding households’ economic well-being: – Per capita consumption (total, food, non-food, durable goods) – Income and revenue (wages, self-employment earnings, remittances) – Asset ownership (livestock, non-farm assets, durable goods) – Financial inclusion (savings, loans, credit access) – Food security (household meals per day, instances of food shortage) We track TUP program’s effects on adult household members’ physical health, mental health, productive work, and political involvement. • Physical and Mental Health: – Physical health index (self-reported health, workdays missed due to illness, activities of daily living score) – Mental health index (life satisfaction, stress levels, sadness) • Social Outcomes: – Time spent in productive activities – Political engagement (voting behavior, community involvement) – Economic satisfaction (1-10)
Secondary outcomes
Further, we identify channels of persistence with the following outcomes: • Labour Markets and Migration – Occupational shifts (livestock to microbusiness, wage employment, migration) – Wage earnings (local vs. migrant earnings, remittance levels) – Migration patterns (duration, destinations) Adult job loss and job transitions. This will be separated by migrants and nonmigrants. – Experienced earnings loss after the job loss – Switched occupation (from blue-collar to white-collar or vice versa) – Switched job industry – Took up government work programs – Passed away • Migrants’ job loss and travel back to villages. We will report the share of migrants who respond ”yes” to the following binary indicators: – Lost job in migration destination – Traveled back to home village • Share of households that report any business loss, non-farm business closure during COVID lockdowns. • Share of households that report any sale of land or other assets during lockdown. • Social protection services during COVID lockdowns. This will be reported as an index, constructed as the normalized number of transfers that a household received from: – extra food ration – bank deposits as part of existing social welfare schemes – asset or cash transfers from the local government – asset or cash transfers from local non-government bodies • Social protection services in the last 12 months. Takeup will equal 1 if the HH applied for OR received the scheme in the last 12 months. The index is a normalized count summing the following indicators: – work in an employment generating scheme – old age or widow pension – Indira Aawas housing plan – other assets gifted by the Panchayat (village government) – vocational training through the Panchayat – Lakshmir Bhandar monthly bank transfer for women – AAY card – any ration card (BPL or Annapura rationing) – Krishak Bandhu scheme • Healthcare seeking behavior in last month. • Index for extent that household delayed major events due to COVID. This index is a normalized count summing the indicators: – delayed wedding or engagement – delayed funeral – delayed opening new business – delayed taking a large loan – delayed a child starting or progressing in school – delayed migration • Index for household consumption smoothing during lockdown. The index is a normalized count summing the following indicators: – consumed goods that you were planning to sell or consume later – take a loan to buy food or goods that are regularly consumed – increase time spent foraging – increase time spent begging – delayed purchasing essential household items other than food – sought a loan from anyone – conditional on having savings, drew down savings to cover expenses INTERGENERATIONAL OUTCOMES We are interested in outcomes for beneficiaries’ children, who are now adults. Outcomes in this analysis include: • educational attainment • occupation and income • access to credit and financial inclusion • type of job (public sector, private white collar, private blue collar, farm wage employment, business) We will also investigate outcomes for children aged 3 to 16, disaggregated by whether they are children or grandchildren of the beneficiary, where it is possible to distinguish. Child’s outcomes are: • height and weight • age-adjusted middle-upper arm circumference percentile • share that attend school or anganwadi • child age distribution Finally, if sufficient tracking information is available, we will investigate beneficiary mortality. Specifically we will report the share of original beneficiaries who have died since the original intervention in 2007, conditional on age at baseline.

Cited by

No citation data available for this registration yet.

Keywords