Eliciting Social Norms: A Survey Experiment on Descriptive and Normative Beliefs
How to cite
Montinari, Natalia; Barigozzi, Francesca; Righetto, Giovanni. 2025. "Eliciting Social Norms: A Survey Experiment on Descriptive and Normative Beliefs." AEA RCT Registry. AEARCTR-0015517. https://doi.org/10.1257/rct.15517-1.0
Download: BibTeX · RIS — for reference managers without a browser translator. Zotero and most others pick up this page's citation metadata directly.
* Primary investigator
Abstract
Social norms play a fundamental role in shaping beliefs and behaviors, yet their measurement remains a methodological challenge. This study focuses on the elicitation of social norms in the context of gendered expectations regarding grit and ambition in the labor market. Specifically, we measure two distinct but related concepts: 1) Normative expectations (social norms) – what people believe ought to be done; 2) Empirical expectations (non-normative social beliefs) – what people believe others typically do or think. Using a vignette-based experimental approach, we systematically vary the framing of belief elicitation to test: i) Whether social norms (normative expectations) and empirical expectations differ systematically in the context of gender norms related to grit and ambition; ii) Whether misperceptions—defined as the difference between second-order beliefs (perceived beliefs of others) and the actual distribution of first-order beliefs (self-reported beliefs of others) as in Cortés et al. (2022)—are similar or different depending on whether empirical expectations or social norms are elicited. iii) How these differences in elicitation contribute to understanding the gender gap in career ambition and perseverance, particularly in how men and women perceive and internalize workplace expectations.
Our study builds on the existing literature on measuring social norms (e.g., Bicchieri, 2017; Gërges & Nosenzo, 2021; Cortés et al., 2022) and contributes to the methodological understanding of how elicitation techniques influence the measurement of perceived gender norms in professional settings. By analyzing how empirical and normative expectations differ across genders, we aim to provide insights into how these perceptions shape behavioral outcomes and contribute to persistent gender disparities in labor market participation and career advancement.
Intervention
This study employs a vignette-based survey experiment to examine the measurement of social norms related to grit and ambition in the labor market. The core objective is to compare the elicitation of normative expectations (what ought to be done) with empirical expectations (what is commonly done or believed) and assess how these differences influence perceptions of gender norms.
The intervention consists of randomly assigning participants to different framing conditions when eliciting their beliefs about social norms:
Normative frame – Participants report what they believe ought to be done in a given scenario.
Empirical frame – Participants report what they believe others commonly do or think in a given scenario.
Participants are presented with hypothetical workplace scenarios involving a central character whose gender is randomly varied. They are asked to evaluate the character’s career-related choices, allowing us to test: i)Whether normative expectations and empirical expectations systematically differ in the context of gender norms related to grit and ambition; ii)Whether misperceptions of social norms (i.e., the difference between second-order beliefs and actual first-order beliefs) vary depending on whether normative or empirical expectations are elicited. iii)How these differences contribute to gender gaps in career ambition and perseverance, particularly in how men and women perceive and internalize workplace expectations.
In the second wave of the study, participants will be exposed to informational feedback based on the responses collected in the first wave. This feedback will highlight either the actual normative expectations or empirical expectations reported by their peers, allowing us to examine whether social norm misperceptions can be corrected and whether this correction works differently for normative and empirical expctetations
The survey will be administered through Computer-Assisted Web Interviews (CAWI), ensuring a randomized and controlled exposure to different elicitation frames.
Experimental design
This study employs a two-wave vignette-based survey experiment on a representative sample of the Italian population aged 19-29, stratified by gender, education level (high school vs. university graduates), geographic region, and metropolitan vs. non-metropolitan area. The experiment is designed to analyze how social norms and personal values shape early career decisions, focusing on the distinction between normative expectations (what ought to be done) and empirical expectations (what is commonly done or believed).
Wave 1: Baseline Elicitation of Norms and Beliefs
In the first wave, participants are presented with two career decision vignettes, with the gender of the protagonist randomized as the key experimental variation:
Ambition Vignette – The protagonist must choose between a prestigious long-term job opportunity abroad (potential for career advancement) and a less ambitious but stable local position. This scenario captures perceptions of ambition and career commitment and examines how these judgments differ by gender.
Grit Vignette – The protagonist chooses between a high-risk, high-reward career path and a low-risk, stable career path, allowing us to assess perceptions of perseverance and resilience in career decisions and potential gender biases in these perceptions.
The primary treatment variation in this study is the framing of belief elicitation, which systematically varies between:
Normative Frame ("Should") – Participants are asked what ought to be done in the given scenario (normative expectations).
Empirical Frame ("Would") – Participants are asked what they believe others would do in the given scenario (empirical expectations).
For each vignette, we elicit:
First-Order Beliefs – Participants' own views about what ought to be done (normative) or what they believe others would do (empirical).
Second-Order Beliefs – Participants' perceptions of what others believe ought to be done (normative) or what others commonly do (empirical).
By randomizing both the gender of the protagonist and the framing of belief elicitation (should vs. would), we can test:
Whether normative expectations and empirical expectations systematically differ.
Whether gendered perceptions of ambition and grit influence these differences.
The extent to which individuals misperceive social norms based on how beliefs are elicited.
At the end of the survey, one of the two vignettes is randomly selected, and 10% of respondents receive an incentive based on the accuracy of their second-order beliefs, encouraging engagement and truthful reporting.
Wave 2: Norm Updating and Informational Treatment
The second wave follows the same structure as Wave 1, but introduces an informational feedback intervention before participants respond to the vignettes again. Specifically, participants are shown:
Feedback on Normative Expectations – Aggregate responses from Wave 1 about what participants believe ought to be done in the given scenarios.
Feedback on Empirical Expectations – Aggregate responses from Wave 1 about what people actually reported doing or believing in the given scenarios.
This allows us to test:
Whether exposure to social information shifts beliefs, and whether the shift differs between normative and empirical expectations.
Whether perceptions of gendered career norms can be altered through informational interventions.
Whether individuals update their beliefs differently depending on whether they initially responded to a normative ("should") or empirical ("would") framing.
By comparing responses across the two waves, we can assess the role of informational interventions in correcting norm misperceptions and examine whether social norms systematically reinforce or mitigate gender gaps in ambition and perseverance.
Design details
Cited by
No citation data available for this registration yet.