Gender differences in safety perception and labor force participation

How to cite

Mahfouz, Elisa. 2025. "Gender differences in safety perception and labor force participation." AEA RCT Registry. AEARCTR-0015505. https://doi.org/10.1257/rct.15505-1.0

Download: BibTeX · RIS — for reference managers without a browser translator. Zotero and most others pick up this page's citation metadata directly.

Elisa Mahfouz*

* Primary investigator

Registry ID
AEARCTR-0015505
DOI
https://doi.org/10.1257/rct.15505-1.0
First registered
Last updated
Status
Completed
Trial dates
2025-01-16 – 2025-03-10
Countries
Italy ()
Registry record
http://www.socialscienceregistry.org/trials/15505

Abstract

This paper examines how safety perceptions influence commuting preferences and labour market outcomes, with a focus on gender differences. Previous research suggests that women’s commuting decisions are shaped by safety concerns, leading them to prioritize safer commutes over higher-wage opportunities, potentially widening the gender wage gap. Using a two-step approach, the study combines a vignette experiment with a representative survey. In the first step, the vignette experiment elicits respondents’ first- and second- order beliefs to investigate gendered social norms around wage and safety trade-offs. Participants are asked to estimate others' recommendations and provide their own for a fictional protagonist choosing between two job options. The vignette varies the protagonist's gender, wage offers, and commuting safety across 12 versions, with each respondent randomly assigned to one condition to analyse the causal impact of the three factors on mobility-related social norms. Hypotheses include the expectation that safer options are recommended more frequently for female protagonists than for male ones and that higher wage levels will increase the likelihood of advising riskier commutes, with a stronger effect observed for men. In the second step, the survey collects socio-demographic data, job preferences, commuting habits, and safety perceptions from a representative sample of young Italian adults aged 19-29. By linking social norms from the vignette experiment to individual preferences, the study examines how safety concerns affect decisions like accepting riskier commutes or prioritizing safer jobs conditions. Findings are expected to demonstrate the role of safety concerns in shaping gendered commuting preferences and labour market inequalities, contributing to a better understanding of the barriers to women’s workforce participation and emphasizing the need to address safety issues for equitable job access.

Experimental design

The intervention consists of a representative survey combined with a vignette experiment to explore the role of gender, wage, and safety concerns in job acceptance decisions involving commuting risks. We plan to collect data from 5,000 Italian individuals, split equally across two waves (2,500 per wave). Each wave will be independently representative based on gender, age groups (19-24 and 25-29 years), education level (high school graduates vs. university graduates), geographic region, and metropolitan vs. non-metropolitan area to ensure consistency in sample composition across both waves. The survey gathers detailed demographic, socio-economic, and commuting information, and includes questions related to personal safety perceptions examining whether these concerns influence job choices. It focuses on participants’ willingness to accept job, given conditions that impact commuting safety, such as remote work options or shifts within daylight hours. Following the survey, participants are subject to a vignette experiment where they are presented with a fictional scenario involving a protagonist who must choose between two job options. Option 1 offers better career advancement prospects but requires commuting within a broad time range (6:00 am to 11:00 pm). Option 2 provides a daylight-only commute with limited career growth potential and a fixed wage.
The experiment varies according to three dimensions. The first dimension is the gender of the protagonist, with some participants seeing a man and others seeing a woman. The second random variation concerns with the commuting environment described in the scenario: one version of the vignette describes a potentially unsafe environment, in which the protagonist has to walk through some areas of the city that are sparsely populated and poorly illuminated, in order to reach the workplace, located in an isolated neighbourhood. In the other version, the workplace is in the city centre and well connected by public transport, making commuting safe and practical. The third dimension involves three wage levels, and respondents are randomly subject to one of the three variations of the potential wage. More precisely, some respondents see both job options offering the same wage, others see a higher wage in the first option compared to the second, and the third version displays the highest wage level in the first option, while the wage in the second remains fixed. Note that age and level of education of the protagonist are in line with participants’ age and education level, in order to make them identify with the protagonist more easily, and also wage offers are consistent with the level of education (€1200/1500/1800 for high school graduate respondents, €1400/1700/2100 for university graduates).
Participants are randomly assigned to one of the 12 vignette versions with equal probability, ensuring balanced exposure across all conditions. Among these versions, the baseline vignette is the one featuring a male protagonist, a safe commuting environment, and the lowest wage level. This neutral baseline condition serves as a reference point for measuring the causal effects of gender, commuting safety, and wage variations on participants’ responses. Respondents are asked to provide two key responses: their estimation of how many people in their reference group would recommend one of the two options (second-order belief) and their own recommendation about the same option (first-order belief). These measures aim to reveal the causal impact of the protagonist’s gender, commuting conditions, and wage offer on social norms related to job choices. Hypotheses include the expectation that safer options are recommended more frequently for female protagonists than for male ones and that higher wage levels will increase the tendency to advise riskier commutes, with a stronger effect observed for men.
Together, the survey and vignette experiment explore how gendered safety concerns, wage incentives, and social norms interact to shape job and commuting preferences, with a focus on the role of safety perception in job-related decision-making.

Design details

Randomization method
Randomization is done in office by a survey company.
Randomization unit
Individual
Clusters
5000
Observations
5000
Arms
5000
Primary outcomes
First-order beliefs; Second-order beliefs; Respondents’ preferences for specific job characteristics; Current employment status, including wage and contract type; Stated willingness to commute; Trade-offs between wages and job-related benefits, including safer commuting conditions.

Cited by

No citation data available for this registration yet.

Keywords