How Social Norms Shape Ambition and Grit: A Vignette Study on Labor Market Entry Inequalities
How to cite
Montinari, Natalia; Barigozzi, Francesca; Righetto, Giovanni. 2025. "How Social Norms Shape Ambition and Grit: A Vignette Study on Labor Market Entry Inequalities." AEA RCT Registry. AEARCTR-0015488. https://doi.org/10.1257/rct.15488-1.0
Download: BibTeX · RIS — for reference managers without a browser translator. Zotero and most others pick up this page's citation metadata directly.
* Primary investigator
Abstract
This study investigates gender inequalities at labor market entry, focusing on the role of social norms and personal values in shaping employment decisions. Although women tend to outperform men in education, gender gaps in employment and wages emerge early in their careers and tend to widen over time. Existing research has primarily focused on factors related to labor demand (e.g., employer discrimination) and labor supply (e.g., gender differences in risk preferences and competitiveness). However, recent studies highlight the importance of contextual factors, such as gender norms and stereotypes, in shaping career trajectories. To explore these issues, we conduct a survey experiment on a representative sample of the Italian population aged 19-29, stratified by gender, education level (high school vs. university graduates), geographic region, and metropolitan status. The core intervention consists of vignette-based experiments, in which we systematically vary the gender of the main character to assess how social norms influence labor market choices. Participants evaluate employment-related scenarios, allowing us to measure the perceived appropriateness of different career decisions.
The vignettes include two key variations: one where the protagonist must decide whether to accept a challenging long-term career opportunity abroad, measuring ambition, and another where they must choose between a high-risk, high-reward path and a more stable but less demanding alternative, capturing grit. The survey also gathers detailed data on education, job status, and early labor market experiences, enabling us to estimate the gender gap at career entry and assess the extent to which it is explained by social norms and personal values. To further explore the impact of social influences, participants in the second wave receive informational feedback based on the responses of their peers, assessing whether exposure to alternative reference points shifts individual beliefs. The data collection is conducted via Computer-Assisted Web Interviews (CAWI), ensuring a high-quality and structured survey administration.
By identifying potential misperceptions of social norms, this study provides insights into how societal expectations contribute to gender disparities in early career choices and how targeted interventions might help mitigate these inequalities.
Intervention
This study investigates gender inequalities at labor market entry, focusing on the role of social norms and personal values in shaping employment decisions. The research will be conducted on a representative sample of the Italian population aged 19-29, stratified by gender, education level (high school graduates vs. university graduates), geographic region, and metropolitan vs. non-metropolitan area.
The intervention consists of vignette-based survey experiments, where we systematically vary the gender of the main character to examine how gender norms influence labor market preferences. Participants evaluate employment-related scenarios, allowing us to assess whether societal expectations and stereotypes shape their decisions.
In addition to the vignette experiment, the survey collects detailed information on participants’ education, job status, and entry into the labor market. This rich dataset enables us to estimate the early gender gap in employment and wages and investigate to what extent these disparities are explained by social norms and personal values.
Participants are assigned to different experimental conditions, where they receive varied informational feedback on perceived social norms and actual decisions made by others. Specifically, participants in the second wave will be exposed to feedback treatments based on responses collected in the first wave, assessing whether information on peers' choices and role models influences personal values and labor market preferences.
The data collection will be carried out through Computer-Assisted Web Interviews (CAWI), administered by a specialized data collection firm. The study aims to identify potential misperceptions of social norms and evaluate their role in reinforcing or reducing gender disparities in early career choices.
Experimental design
The experimental design consists of a two-wave survey experiment conducted on a representative sample of the Italian population aged 19-29, stratified by gender, education level (high school vs. university graduates), geographic region, and metropolitan vs. non-metropolitan area. The study employs vignette-based experiments to analyze how social norms and personal values shape early career decisions and contribute to gender disparities in labor market entry.
Wave 1: Baseline Elicitation of Norms and Beliefs
In the first wave, participants are presented with two vignettes in random order, with the gender of the protagonist randomized as the key experimental variation:
Ambition Vignette – The protagonist must decide whether to accept a prestigious long-term job opportunity abroad with potential for career advancement or opt for a less ambitious but stable local position. This scenario captures perceptions of ambition and career commitment and how these are judged based on gender.
Grit Vignette – The protagonist chooses between a high-risk, high-reward career path and a low-risk, stable career path, allowing us to assess perceived perseverance and resilience in career-related decisions and potential gender biases in these perceptions.
By randomizing the gender of the protagonist, we examine whether social norms and expectations shape how ambition and perseverance are perceived for men and women entering the labor market. The order of vignette presentation is also randomized to control for potential order effects in responses.
For each vignette, we elicit both first-order beliefs (individual perceptions of social appropriateness) and (incentivized) second-order beliefs (expectations about the views of others). Participants evaluate the social appropriateness of different career choices, allowing us to measure perceived norms related to ambition and grit.
While the survey also introduces a variation in the framing of the question (should/would), this is not a primary treatment but is accounted for in the analysis.
At the end of the survey, one of the two vignettes is randomly selected, and 10% of respondents in each wave (500 participants) are chosen for additional incentives. For these participants, incentives are provided based on the accuracy of their estimation of social appropriateness in their second-order beliefs, ensuring engagement and truthful reporting.
Wave 2: Norm Updating and Informational Treatment
The second wave follows the same structure as Wave 1, but with a key difference: participants receive feedback on the responses collected in Wave 1 before making their own evaluations. Specifically, participants are shown:
Feedback on Perceived Social Norms – Aggregate responses from Wave 1 regarding what is considered socially appropriate.
Feedback on Empirical Expectations – Information about the actual choices made by respondents in Wave 1, segmented by gender and education level.
This design allows us to study whether and how exposure to social information influences individual beliefs and stated preferences, as well as whether perceived norms about ambition and grit systematically differ from actual peer decisions.
By comparing responses across the two waves, we can assess the role of informational interventions in shifting personal values and social norm perceptions. The study contributes to understanding how gendered expectations shape labor market preferences and whether targeted information can help mitigate early-career gender disparities.
The data collection is conducted through Computer-Assisted Web Interviews (CAWI), ensuring structured administration and high-quality responses.
Design details
Cited by
No citation data available for this registration yet.