Enslaving Memory. Re-framing the episodes of national shame and modern-day racial attitudes in the UK.

How to cite

Lipinski, Robert. 2025. "Enslaving Memory. Re-framing the episodes of national shame and modern-day racial attitudes in the UK.." AEA RCT Registry. AEARCTR-0015477. https://doi.org/10.1257/rct.15477-1.0

Download: BibTeX · RIS — for reference managers without a browser translator. Zotero and most others pick up this page's citation metadata directly.

Robert Lipinski*

* Primary investigator

Registry ID
AEARCTR-0015477
DOI
https://doi.org/10.1257/rct.15477-1.0
First registered
Last updated
Status
In development
Trial dates
2025-03-07 – 2025-03-14
Countries
United Kingdom of Great Britain and Northern Ireland ()
Registry record
http://www.socialscienceregistry.org/trials/15477

Abstract

Competing political actors often choose to emphasize different aspects of the same events from national history to make them fit their broader worldview and thus advance their agenda. However, the extent to which such re-framing can affect public attitudes towards modern-day policy issues has only recently started to be evaluated. This project seeks to better understand that question by investigating whether shifting the emphasis between positive and negative framing of the British slave-trading history affects people’s self-declared views on race-related issues. It randomly assigns survey respondents to positive framing, underscoring Britain's abolitionist efforts, versus negative framing, highlighting the scale of suffering induced by the slave trade, and a control group. All groups are then asked a series of questions about i) shame vs pride in the British role in the slave trade ii) support for restitutions; iii) national pride; iv) racial relations; v) racial attitudes; vi) opinion on race-related policy measures in modern Britain. By evaluating how the responses to those questions compare to each other and to the control group not exposed to any priming information, this study aims to measure the extent to which re-framing shameful episodes from national history - a tactic used by many political actors - can move public attitudes on relevant policy issues.

Intervention

The intervention consists of a dedicated survey experiment, administered as a part of the YouGov's political omnibus.

The survey will target c.1600 adult respondents living in the United Kingdom. The data will be sampled and weighted to ensure it’s nationally representative based on gender, age, education level, social class, region, voting history, and political interest.

The experiment itself will consist of 7 survey blocks. The first block will be shown to the respondents in a randomised manner. Depending on their condition, a respondent will either read one of the two framings of the British slave trading history or will see no text prior to answering the questions, as outlined below:

The following six blocks with contain between 1-3 survey items pertaining to: i) shame vs pride in the British role in the slave trade ii) support for restitutions; iii) national pride; iv) racial relations; v) racial attitudes; vi) opinion on race-related policy measures in modern Britain. The exact phrasing is described in the attached questionnaire. Where possible, the wording of the question follows past surveys to allow for (qualitative) comparisons of the results.

The respondents will be evaluated relative to the control group using both OLS and ordered logistic regression models, controlling for the socio demographic variables listed below.

Socio-demographic controls included: age, gender, region, social class, education level, household income, ethnicity, religion, marital status, work status, political interest, and a dummy for the Brexit referendum and national parliamentary elections in 2019 and 2024. The significance levels will be corrected for multiple hypothesis testing using the Bonferroni correction.

Experimental design

The c. 1,600 respondents targeted by the survey will be randomised into 3 treatment arms, resulting in ~533 respondents in each arm.

Depending on their condition, a respondent will either first read one of the two framings of the British slave trading history or will see no text prior to answering the questions, as outlined below:

The respondents in the treatment arms will be shown their respective texts and be asked to read before proceeding with the other questions. Control group will see the questions right way.

Design details

Randomization method
Randomization done by YouGov in their surveying system.
Randomization unit
Individual respondents
Clusters
1,600 British adults (18+)
Observations
1,600 British adults (18+)
Arms
1,600 British adults (18+)
Primary outcomes
> Attitudes towards British history of slave trading Measured with a single survey item Generally speaking, are you more ashamed of Britain’s historic involvement in the slave trade or more proud that Britain was one of the first countries to abolish it, or do you think these things happened so long ago that you feel neither proud nor ashamed? Response Options: (1) Both proud and ashamed (2) Both proud and ashamed (3) More proud of abolishing the slave trade (4) Too long ago to be proud or ashamed (98) None of these / Don’t know > Restitutions to the affected nations Measured with three survey items Question prompt: How much do you agree or disagree with each of those statements… 1. United Kingdom owes a debt to the nations whose ancestors experienced slavery 2. United Kingdom should formally apologise to the nations whose ancestor experiences slavery 3. United Kingdom should pay compensation to the nations whose ancestors experienced slavery Response Options: (1) Strongly disagree (2) Disagree (3) Neither agree not disagree (4) Agree (5) Strongly agree (98) Don’t Know > National pride Measured with three survey items Question prompt: How ashamed or proud are you… 1. being British 2. British history 3. present-day role of Britian in the world Response Options: (1) Very ashamed (2) Somewhat ashamed (3) Neither ashamed not proud (4) Somewhat proud (5) Very proud (98) Don’t Know (99) Not applicable > Racial relations Measured with three survey items Question prompt: Thinking specifically about race in the UK, do you think people from ethnic minority backgrounds in the UK face more or less discrimination than white people in the following areas of life, or do you think it makes no difference… 1. In interactions between strangers, e.g.. in a shop or on the street 2. Access to good schooling 3. Access to citizenship and/or visas Response Options: (1) More (2) No difference (3) Less (98) Don’t know > Racial attitudes Measured with three survey items Question prompt: How uncomfortable or comfortable would you feel with having the following as your neighbour … 1. a Black person 2. a Hindu person 3. a Polish person Response Options: (1) Very uncomfortable (2) Somewhat uncomfortable (3) Neither uncomfortable nor comfortable (4) Somewhat comfortable (5) Very comfortable (98) Don’t know > Race-related policies Measured with three survey items Question prompt: For each of the following policies, please indicate how much you support or oppose it 1. Positive discrimination to make sure ethnic minorities are equally represented across all levels of companies and institutions 2. Removing statues and other commemorations (e.g. plaques, street names) of people responsible for slavery and slave trade from public spaces 3. Having historical injustice, colonialism and the role of the British Empire taught as part of the national curriculum Response Options: (1) Strongly oppose (2) Oppose (3) Neither support nor oppose (4) Support (5) Strongly support (98) Don’t know

Cited by

No citation data available for this registration yet.

Keywords