The Impact of the Menstrual Cycle on Bargaining Behavior

How to cite

Lozano, Lina; Riedl, Arno; Rott, Christina. 2025. "The Impact of the Menstrual Cycle on Bargaining Behavior." AEA RCT Registry. AEARCTR-0015476. https://doi.org/10.1257/rct.15476-2.0

Download: BibTeX · RIS — for reference managers without a browser translator. Zotero and most others pick up this page's citation metadata directly.

Lina Lozano* , Arno Riedl , Christina Rott

* Primary investigator

Registry ID
AEARCTR-0015476
DOI
https://doi.org/10.1257/rct.15476-2.0
First registered
Last updated
Status
In development
Trial dates
2025-03-24 – 2025-07-25
Countries
Private
Registry record
http://www.socialscienceregistry.org/trials/15476

Abstract

We investigate experimentally how the menstrual cycle affects bargaining behavior and bargaining outcomes of women. Female participants negotiate in an unstructured bilateral bargaining game with asymmetric information about the allocation of a surplus ('pie size'). Our study provides first evidence that biological factors affect bargaining. The study is approved by the Ethical Review Committee of Psychology and Neuroscience (ERCIC\_651\_24\_01\_2025) at Maastricht University.

Intervention

The study consists of two phases. The first phase involves tracking participants’ menstrual cycles over a three-month period. Participants are recruited three months before the online bargaining session, during which they report the start date of their last menstruation. Using this information, along with their average cycle length over the tracking period, we estimate the start of their next menstrual cycle. A three-month tracking period is necessary, as medical literature suggests this is the minimum duration required for accurate cycle measurements.

In the second phase, participants take part in an online bargaining experiment. They are randomly assigned to anonymous pairs and engage in a bargaining game over ten rounds. Each participant is given a unique anonymous ID (i.e., their Prolific ID) to ensure confidentiality throughout the study.

Experimental design

The study consists of two phases. The first phase involves tracking participants’ menstrual cycles over a three-month period. Participants are recruited three months before the online bargaining session, during which they report the start date of their last menstruation. Using this information, along with their average cycle length over the tracking period, we estimate the start of their next menstrual cycle. A three-month tracking period is necessary, as medical literature suggests this is the minimum duration required for accurate cycle measurements.

In the second phase, participants take part in an online bargaining experiment. They are randomly assigned to anonymous pairs and engage in a bargaining game over ten rounds. Each participant is given a unique anonymous ID to ensure confidentiality throughout the study.

Design details

Randomization method
Participants are randomly assigned to the roles of informed and uninformed players in the bargaining game and maintain the same role throughout the 10 bargaining periods. In addition, they are grouped into matching groups of eight players (depending on session attendance) and are re-randomized into new pairs at the start of each bargaining period. In each period, they are matched to a new other participant with the opposite role. Participants may be matched with the same other participant in multiple rounds, but they will never be matched with the same participant in consecutive rounds and they are informed about it.
Randomization unit
Participants will be matched into groups of 8 (4 informed, 4 uninformed) for the bargaining task. This group size balances statistical power, session feasibility, and real-time matching constraints.
Clusters
120 groups of 8 participants (N = 960), we expect to obtain 160 informed and 160 uninformed participants per phase.
Observations
960 (480 informed players and 480 uninformed players)
Arms
120 groups of 8 participants (N = 960), we expect to obtain 160 informed and 160 uninformed participants per phase. Menstrual Phase Assignment: Participants are pre-assigned to matching groups based on three menstrual phase categories—Ovulation, Pre-menstrual, and a combined Menstrual/Post-menstrual category—estimated using self-reported cycle data collected across prior survey waves. The matching logic prioritizes two objectives: (1) maximizing the inclusion of participants in the ovulation phase, given its short temporal window, and (2) maintaining approximate balance across phase categories and roles (informed/uninformed) within each 8-person group. Assignment to sessions is based on the participants who are connected at the time of the session, and dynamic group formation is handled automatically by oTree. The platform allows for flexible, real-time allocation of participants into matching groups while preserving the intended balance in phase and role distributions whenever possible. Although over 1,200 participants have been tracked, we conservatively plan for a final sample size of N = 960 to account for attrition and potential no-shows. This oversampling strategy increases the likelihood of forming complete, well-balanced groups during live sessions. All participants who attend a scheduled session will be matched following the same stratified randomization protocol, with priority given to maintaining the desired balance across menstrual phases and player roles.
Primary outcomes
Measures of the bargaining process and outcomes: For the bargaining process, we analyze informed players' initial offers, uninformed players' initial demands, and both players' concessions during bargaining. Initial offers and demands capture an individual's bargaining attitudes before they are affected by the negotiation partner's behavior. To investigate the interactive nature of bargaining, we look at concessions during the simultaneous bargaining stage. Bargaining outcomes are measures of negotiation success. We analyze negotiators' final payoffs, deal rates, and payoffs conditional on reaching an agreement.
Secondary outcomes
We collect data on (i) demographics (e.g., age, education, and work status) and (ii) risk and social preferences. These variables will be used as controls to assess the robustness of our analysis. As a robustness check, we will also adjust the window frame for ovulation. This approach will help assess the sensitivity of our findings and further reinforce the robustness of our study's conclusions. Furthermore, to ensure the reliability and validity of our findings, we will incorporate a self-reported measure of bargaining to complement the results obtained from the behavioral measure. Finally, as an additional robustness check, we will perform the entire analysis separately for informed and uninformed players, using bootstrapped cluster-robust standard errors with 1,000 repetitions.

Cited by

No citation data available for this registration yet.

Keywords