Interventions to Promote Equity in Selection (IPES)

How to cite

Munoz, Manuel. 2025. "Interventions to Promote Equity in Selection (IPES)." AEA RCT Registry. AEARCTR-0015473. https://doi.org/10.1257/rct.15473-1.1

Download: BibTeX · RIS — for reference managers without a browser translator. Zotero and most others pick up this page's citation metadata directly.

Manuel Munoz*

* Primary investigator

Registry ID
AEARCTR-0015473
DOI
https://doi.org/10.1257/rct.15473-1.1
First registered
Last updated
Status
In development
Trial dates
2025-03-03 – 2025-04-30
Countries
Private
Registry record
http://www.socialscienceregistry.org/trials/15473

Abstract

I investigates whether simple, behaviorally informed prompts can reduce biases in faculty nominations for the “Student Excellence Award” at a university in Colombia. I randomly assign faculty members to one of four conditions (one control group and three treatment prompts) delivered immediately prior to nominating a student. These prompts focus on inclusion, unconscious bias, and explicit commitment to equity. The primary outcome is whether faculty nominate students from historically underrepresented socioeconomic backgrounds at higher rates, as well as changes in the diversity of nominees.

Intervention

This RCT tests four versions of a brief message shown to faculty immediately before they nominate a student for an Excellence Award:
1. Control (Standard Nomination): A simple request to nominate a student on the basis of academic performance.
2. Inclusion Prompt: Reminds faculty to consider students from all socioeconomic backgrounds and to ensure no deserving student is overlooked.
3. Equity Commitment Prompt: Emphasizes organizational commitment to equity, encouraging nominators to reinforce diversity and inclusion goals.
4. Unconscious Bias Prompt: Highlights the possibility of overlooking less-privileged students due to unconscious biases and invites faculty to reflect on such biases when choosing a student.

Experimental design

I will invite all eligible faculty at UNAB to participate in a short online nomination survey.
Before nominating a student, faculty are randomly assigned to see one of four prompts (three treatment conditions plus one control).
1. Control (Standard Nomination): A simple request to nominate a student on the basis of academic performance.
2. Inclusion Prompt: Reminds faculty to consider students from all socioeconomic backgrounds and to ensure no deserving student is
overlooked.
3. Equity Commitment Prompt: Emphasizes organizational commitment to equity, encouraging nominators to reinforce diversity and
inclusion goals.
4. Unconscious Bias Prompt: Highlights the possibility of overlooking less-privileged students due to unconscious biases and invites
faculty to reflect on such biases when choosing a student.
By comparing nomination patterns, I seek to identify which channels (type of message) best encourage nomination of students from underrepresented backgrounds.

Design details

Randomization method
Randomization is done using computer. I randomize in blocks to balance the following variables: gender (male-female), tenure (yes-no), nominated someone in a previous related event (yes-no)
Randomization unit
Individual faculty member
Clusters
- Planned Number of Observations: Approximately 670 faculty members are expected to be invited. - Sample Size by Treatment Arms: Expected ~167 faculty in each of the four arms (Control, Inclusion Prompt, Equity Commitment Prompt, Unconscious Bias Prompt).
Observations
- Planned Number of Observations: Approximately 670 faculty members are expected to be invited.
Arms
N/A
Primary outcomes
I will test differences between control and treatments both by pooling all treatment conditions into one (binary comparison), as well as by comparing control and each treatment conditions (to evaluate the effect of the different messages). 1. Nomination rate: share of faculty that makes a nomination 2. Diversity of nominations: share of low class or female students nominated 3. Quality of nominations: average GPA; also willingness to accept nomination
Secondary outcomes
1. Beliefs on exposure: reported share of students from different social groups that faculty have encountered 2. Perceptions of Excellence: Textual answers about what characteristics define an “excellent” student 3. Strategies for success: Textual answers about what strategies could help underperforming students become excellent

Cited by

No citation data available for this registration yet.

Keywords