Unveiling Bias in Judicial Decisions: How Law School Shapes Perspectives
How to cite
Schlosser, Maike; Goldemann, Lennart.
2025. "Unveiling Bias in Judicial Decisions: How Law School Shapes Perspectives." AEA RCT Registry. AEARCTR-0015465.
https://doi.org/10.1257/rct.15465-1.0
Download:
BibTeX
·
RIS— for reference managers without a browser
translator. Zotero and most
others pick up this page's citation metadata directly.
The objective of this study is to better understand the origins of discrimination in the judicial system. While a large body of literature documents the existence of biases in judicial decision making, we do not know where these biases originate from. To gain a better understanding of the role of legal training, we conduct a survey experiment with German law students. Thereby, we aim to answer two main questions: First, do law students evaluate criminal cases differently if we vary certain characteristics of the perpetrator? Second, how does the answering behavior change over the course of law school?
Experimental design
We use a survey experiment to examine if certain characteristics of a perpatrator influence law students' judicial decision-making in criminal case evaluations. We collaborated with legal experts to design short criminal cases resembling those used in law school training. The survey is distributed at universities in law school courses and among law students through cooperation partners. Additionally, we conduct it at select universities ourselves. To encourage participation, students have the chance to win vouchers through a raffle.
Design details
Randomization method
The survey experiment is conducted through the online survey provider LimeSurvey. Overall, we have five treatments (five cases). For each individual it is random which version of each case she receives. The randomization method is implemented in Lime Survey.
Randomization unit
For each case we randomly allocate the Treatment or Control Version to an individual. The randomization unit is the individual-case.
Clusters
We contact professors and staff of 40 universities. We do not know at this point how many of them will share our survey experiment among the law students at their respective univerisities.
Observations
We contact professors and staff of 40 universities. We do not know at this point how many of them will share our survey experiment among the law students at their respective univerisities.
Arms
We randomize on the individual level. Hence, each version of each case should be answered by approximately 50% of the total sample.
An exception is the case with three versions, here we expect accordingly 1/3 of the sample to have awnsered each version.
Primary outcomes
Case evaluations: Students have to decide whether they follow a stricter assessment of the case or not on a 4-point Likert Scale (yes, rather yes, rather no, no). Additionally, we construct a binary variable indicating approval ( = 1 if yes of rather yes).
Secondary outcomes
Degree of penalty: Depending on their case evaluation students have to determine the severity of the penalty (length of incarceration or monetary punishment). The length of incarceration will be evaluated on a continuous scale. If the decision is between incarceration or monetary punishment, we construct a dummy variable coded as 1 if the student chooses incarceration.
Degree of (Un)certainty: After each case evaluation, we ask the students about their degree of certainty in assessing the respective case. For this, we use a slider where students can rate their certainty on a scale from 1 (extremly uncertain) to 5 (extremly certain).
Cited by
No citation data available for this registration yet.