The Relationship Between Shocks and Higher-Order Risk Attitudes
How to cite
Bejarano, Hernan; Palma, Marco; Cevallos, Samantha. 2025. "The Relationship Between Shocks and Higher-Order Risk Attitudes." AEA RCT Registry. AEARCTR-0015462. https://doi.org/10.1257/rct.15462-5.0
Download: BibTeX · RIS — for reference managers without a browser translator. Zotero and most others pick up this page's citation metadata directly.
* Primary investigator
Abstract
This experiment investigates the causal impact of exogenous income shocks on individuals' risk preferences, specifically focusing on higher-order risk attitudes such as prudence and temperance. Building on the theoretical framework of higher-order risk attitudes and motivated by mixed empirical evidence on the effect of shocks on risk behavior, the study employs a between-subjects design that orthogonally varies initial experimental endowments ($20, $60, or $100) and the occurrence of income shocks. Participants, recruited from a nationally representative online panel (Forthright Access), are randomly assigned to one of seven treatment conditions that systematically isolate income shocks from wealth effects. In Stage I, subjects learn about their endowment source; in Stage II, a risky investment task (adapted from Gneezy and Potters, 1997) elicits risk aversion via investment choices under uncertainty; and in Stage III, lottery selection tasks measure both basic risk preferences (following Eckel and Grossman, 2008) and higher-order attitudes (following Noussair et al., 2014). The experiment aims to test whether shock-induced variations in endowment generate distributions of risk preferences that differ from those arising solely from deterministic changes. Additionally, the study examines the interrelationships among risk aversion, prudence, and temperance across treatment conditions. Outcomes from this research will contribute to a clearer understanding of how exogenous shocks affect decision-making under uncertainty and inform both theoretical models and policy designs to mitigate shocks' economic impacts.
Follow-up experiment: In a subsequent within-subjects design, all participants begin with a $60 endowment and complete four rounds of the Investment Game to establish baseline risk preferences. They are then randomly assigned to one of three treatments: (i) WIN, where there is a 50% chance to gain $40 and reach $100; (ii) LOSS, where there is a 50% chance to lose $40 and end with $20; or (iii) Control-$60, where the endowment remains unchanged. Participants then repeat the Investment Game, allowing us to measure within-person changes in investment behavior before and after experiencing an economic shock. The study concludes with the same set of risk-aversion, prudence, and temperance elicitation tasks as the main experiment, enabling direct comparison between within- and between-subjects findings.
Physiological responses experiment: This experiment mirrors the same structure as the follow-up experiment described above. We will measure physiological responses throughout the experiment using eye-tracking and galvanic skin response (GSR) devices in participants in the treatment arms experiencing an economic shock with a change in income, specifically those in the Negative Shock-$20 and Positive Shock-$100 conditions. These measures allow us to determine the effect of the shock itself, measured through changes in physiological arousal responses.
Intervention
We use a controlled economic experiment to assess the relationship between shocks and higher-order risk attitudes. Particularly, we study if previous apparent discrepancies are generated by the impossibility of field data separating the effects of the income shocks on wealth from those with risk attitudes. To do so, we propose a between-subjects experiment in which we vary the amount of initial experimental endowments (wealth) that subjects receive and the occurrence or non-occurrence of the shock. To capture these relationships from a broader set of subjects than college students, the experiment is implemented via Forthright Access, an online platform with a representative sample of the U.S. population. To capture whether endowment shocks affect our subjects' decision processes, we record decision times and overinvestment attempts. We exogenously isolate shocks from wealth to assess their independent effect on higher-order risk preferences.
We implement an experiment with seven randomly assigned treatments between subjects, as described in Table 1.
Table 1. Treatments
Endowment\Shock Deterministic Shock
$20 Deterministic-$20 Negative Shock-$20 (Negative shock from a 50% chance of a ($20, $60) bundle)
$60 Deterministic-$60 Positive Shock-$60 (Positive shock from a 50% chance of a ($20, $60) bundle)
Negative Shock-$60 (Negative shock from a 50% chance of a ($60, $100) bundle)
$100 Deterministic-$100 Positive Shock-$100 (Positive shock from a 50% chance of a ($60, $100) bundle)
To further investigate within-subject changes in risk attitudes following economic shocks, we will conduct a follow-up experiment with new participants recruited through Forthright Access. In Task 1, all participants will begin with a $60 endowment and complete four rounds of the Investment Game (Gneezy & Potters, 1997) to establish baseline risk preferences. In Task 2, participants will be randomly assigned to one of three treatments that determine their post-shock endowment:
WIN: 50% probability of keeping $60, 50% probability of gaining $40 (final endowment = $100).
LOSS: 50% probability of keeping $60, 50% probability of losing $40 (final endowment = $20).
C$60: Guaranteed $60 endowment (control).
After the shock assignment, participants will complete four additional rounds of the Investment Game, allowing us to measure within-subject changes in the proportion of the endowment invested in the risky asset.
Finally, in Task 3, participants will complete 18 rounds of risk-elicitation tasks (Eckel & Grossman, 2008; Noussair et al., 2012) to measure risk aversion, prudence, and temperance, followed by a brief social preferences questionnaire.
In a third experiment, new participants will be randomly assigned to one of two treatment arm conditions: Negative Shock-$20 or Positive Shock-$100. This experiment mirrors the same structure as the follow-up experiment (Tasks 1–3), with participants completing the Investment Game before and after the shock, followed by the same set of risk-elicitation tasks and social preference questions. The key difference is that this study will be conducted in the lab, where participants will be connected to biometric devices (eye-tracking and galvanic skin response) to record continuous physiological data throughout the experiment.
Experimental design
We use two controlled online economic experiments to assess the relationship between shocks and higher-order risk attitudes. The first is a between-subjects design, varying both the initial endowment ($20, $60, or $100) and the occurrence or non-occurrence of an economic shock. The second is a within-subjects design in which all participants start with the same initial endowment and are then randomly assigned to experience a positive shock, negative shock, or no shock. This allows us to measure within-subject changes in risky investment and compare across treatment arms to assess the effects of shocks on prudence and temperance.
In both experiments, participants have a 10% chance of receiving a payment. After completing all tasks, participants spin a digital roulette to determine if they are selected for payment, with one round randomly chosen to determine their payoff.
Design details
Cited by
No citation data available for this registration yet.