Underrepresented Groups, Job Search, and Fear of Failure
How to cite
Opanasets, Alexandra; Jiang, Michelle. 2025. "Underrepresented Groups, Job Search, and Fear of Failure." AEA RCT Registry. AEARCTR-0015394. https://doi.org/10.1257/rct.15394-2.2
Download: BibTeX · RIS — for reference managers without a browser translator. Zotero and most others pick up this page's citation metadata directly.
* Primary investigator
Abstract
When workers from underrepresented groups opt out of “higher risk, higher reward” jobs, income gaps arise. Workers may rationally avoid applying to jobs where they’d be disproportionately punished for failure, and employer bias informs how employers interpret negative productivity signals from workers of different identities. Socialized group differences in traits such as risk aversion or other-regarding preferences also influence job choice. Our proposed research aims to answer: Do workers from underrepresented groups take disproportionate action to avoid failure on the job? If so, what proportion of any resultant gaps in job choice are due to anticipated discrimination versus socialized differences in behavioral traits? We propose running an experiment in which we randomly vary the potential consequences for failure on the job, and observe how this affects job choices for workers from different demographic groups.
Experimental design
Our treatment changes the descriptions of the jobs workers are considering, thus changing the stakes and consequences of failure. We have two cross-randomized dimensions of treatment:
1) Demographic Reveal: Under Demographic Reveal, the worker’s demographic information (gender and race) is revealed to employer subjects along with their score and their Prolific work history. Under No Demographic Reveal, only the worker’s anonymized quantitative attributes are revealed.
2) Separation Risk: Under Separation Risk, the worker might get “fired” (i.e. not be invited back to complete the second round of puzzles). Under No Separation Risk, the worker will always be invited back to complete the second round and their performance will be used to train employers in a “practice round” of evaluation.
Our final design consists of four treatment cells.
Design details
Cited by
No citation data available for this registration yet.