We study how to equalize students’ educational opportunities in a tracked high school system. We will use a randomized control trial in nearly 370 Italian middle schools to test two conceptually different ways to close gender gaps in high school track recommendations. To help teachers predict future performance, our first treatment provides teachers with a simple algorithmic recommendation that indicates whether students are likely to excel in the more rigorous scientific high school tracks. To address behavioral biases and awareness issues, our second treatment provides teachers with real-time feedback on the diversity of their track recommendations compared to an algorithmic benchmark, which they can then adjust before communicating their recommendations to students. We hypothesize that the first intervention will lead to fairer track recommendations if teacher biases are driven by inaccurate mental models of how individual students will perform in high school. Meanwhile, the second intervention will lead to fairer recommendations if teachers are best able to correct behavioral biases when considering the aggregate diversity of their track recommendations.
Experimental design
Information intervention with teachers
Design details
Randomization method
Randomization was done in an office by a computer.
Randomization unit
The unit of randomization is the school. When teachers report teaching in multiple participating middle school buildings, these buildings were treated as a single school to prevent exposure to multiple treatments. Schools were then randomly assigned to the control group or to one of three treatment groups, with equal probability (25% each).
Clusters
Around 368 schools
Observations
Our estimation sample consists of 8th-grade students in treatment-eligible classes within the 368 randomized schools. We expect approximately 39,600 8th-grade students to be in treatment-eligible classes. Furthermore, we will assess spillover effects by comparing the gender gaps in track recommendation and track choice using administrative outcomes of 8th-grade students in ineligible classes in treated and control schools. We expect approximately 19,000 8th-grade students to be in ineligible classes in treated or control schools.
Arms
The schools will be randomized into the control group or one of three treatment groups, with 25% probability each.
Primary outcomes
The primary outcome will include:
(1) Administrative outcomes on the gender gap in the teachers' scientific track recommendations, for baseline high-achievers.
Secondary outcomes
The secondary outcomes will include:
(1) Administrative outcomes on the gender gap in the students' track enrollment decisions, for baseline high-achievers.
(2) Administrative outcomes on the gender gaps in the teachers' scientific track recommendations and students' track enrollment decisions, for the general population of eighth graders.
(3) Administrative outcomes on the proportion of baseline high-achievers recommended to and enrolled in the scientific track, compared to baseline low-achievers, both in aggregate and by gender.
(4) Administrative outcomes on students' academic performance in high school, conditional on scientific track enrollment, both in aggregate and by gender.
(5) Data collected from a teacher questionnaire on teachers' beliefs about the gender gaps in their own track recommendations and their students' track enrollment decisions.
(6) Data collected from a teacher questionnaire on scientific track recommendations for hypothetical students' profiles with randomized genders.
Cited by
No citation data available for this registration yet.