In this study we aim to estimate the consumer demand curve for off-net (“interoperable”) payments, by randomizing the price that consumers face for off-net payments, within an FSP's digital payments apps, with users of the Philippines' instant retail payment switch, InstaPay. An experimentally-generated estimate of demand would be informative for a number of purposes, including for FSPs’ own pricing decisions, and for pricing regulation decisions by policymakers. The demand curve can also be inverted to generate an aggregate estimate of consumer welfare from access to off-net payments, identified with experimental variation in a real-stakes, field setting. We will also study spillovers of instant payments usage on other financial inclusion behaviors, including other payments channels, and use of financial services. We aim to implement the study with a sample that can be re-weighted to be nationally-representative, so we can make statements about the welfare accrued from access to instant payments from financially included individuals in the Philippines.
Intervention
Variation in the fee that users pay for instant payment switch, InstaPay.
Experimental design
The study will randomly vary the price that users pay for instant payment switch.
Design details
Randomization method
Randomization done in office by a computer.
Randomization unit
Individual (bank client).
Clusters
NA
Observations
Up to 7130 in Diskartech sample, including 5679 in intervention sample, 500 in consented control, and up to 1000 in pure control. In practice, the pure control sample was erroneously contaminated, so includes under 1000 subjects (951).
Up to 10,000 in Pulz sample, including 8000 in intervention sample, 1000 in consented control, and 1000 in pure control.
Arms
1420 per treatment arm (4 pricing treatment arms), in Diskartech sample.
2000 per treatment arm (4 pricing treatment arms), in Pulz sample.
Primary outcomes
Use of InstaPay, measured by number and volume of daily, weekly and monthly transactions.
In line with a demand curve, we hypothesize that:
Hypothesis 1. Lower InstaPay fees will cause increased use of InstaPay in terms of number of transactions.
Hypothesis 2. Lower InstaPay fees will cause higher total volumes (i.e., the sum of transaction sizes over the time period) on InstaPay on longer time horizons (week-to-month), through overall increased use of InstaPay as a payment instrument.
We hypothesize that lower InstaPay prices will cause smaller individual transaction sizes, primarily through the mechanism of reducing bundling (bundling is the tendency for a user to bundle multiple transactions together, to avoid the cost of a higher transaction fee, an incentive which is reduced under lower fees).
Hypothesis 3. Lower InstaPay fees will cause (i) lower average transaction sizes, and (ii) lower transaction volumes, over shorter time horizons (day-to-week).
Secondary outcomes
Our secondary outcomes will be taken from administrative and survey data. These include:
1. Use of other payment instruments (e.g., PesoNet, ATM, bank transfers, etc).
2. Use of other financial products and services.
3. Other subjective measures and beliefs about InstaPay and digital financial services, such as:
i. Understanding and perceptions of digital financial services.
ii. Satisfaction with digital financial services.
Hypothesis 4. The effect of lower InstaPay fees on increased InstaPay use (hypotheses 1-3) has an ambiguous effect on the use of other payments services, as InstaPay may crowd out other payment channels, but on the other hand it may induce greater use of digital payments overall (all channels).
Hypothesis 5. The effect of lower InstaPay prices on increased InstaPay use (hypotheses 1-3) will be to cause an increase in the use of other financial products and services.
Hypothesis 6. The effect of lower InstaPay prices and increased InstaPay use will cause increased subjective awareness of satisfaction with digital financial services.
Cited by
No citation data available for this registration yet.