Reducing the burden of unpaid care work among women farmers in Tanzania: A clustered RCT

How to cite

Pattni, Ravina; Barnhart, Dale; Vasilov, Camelia; Diarz, Ester; Mohanraj, Pranati; Selva, Miriam; Ngusa, Adella. 2025. "Reducing the burden of unpaid care work among women farmers in Tanzania: A clustered RCT." AEA RCT Registry. AEARCTR-0015350. https://doi.org/10.1257/rct.15350-1.1

Download: BibTeX · RIS — for reference managers without a browser translator. Zotero and most others pick up this page's citation metadata directly.

Ravina Pattni* , Dale Barnhart , Camelia Vasilov , Ester Diarz , Pranati Mohanraj , Miriam Selva , Adella Ngusa

* Primary investigator

Registry ID
AEARCTR-0015350
DOI
https://doi.org/10.1257/rct.15350-1.1
First registered
Last updated
Status
On going
Trial dates
2024-08-01 – 2027-08-01
Countries
Tanzania, United Republic of (Iringa)
JEL codes
J16: Economics of Gender; Non-labor Discrimination D31: Household Behavior; Family Economics O13: Agricultural Development; Crops; Horticulture; Agrarian Reform; Rural Development I18: Gender; Education; Health; Welfare; Income; Wealth
Secondary IDs
IDRC grant number for the project: 110363-001
Registry record
http://www.socialscienceregistry.org/trials/15350

Abstract

Background: Globally, women perform 2.6 times more unpaid care work than men. This study examines whether introducing Unpaid Care Work training modules into CARE Tanzania’s existing Farmer Field and Business School (FFBS) program can reduce and redistribute care responsibilities among women farmers. FFBS is a gender-transformative, market-oriented, and nutrition-sensitive extension approach in which groups convene to learn about agricultural best practices on demonstration plots.

Design: In this clustered randomized controlled trial (cRCT) participants are randomly assigned to either the standard FFBS training or FFBS plus the Unpaid Care Work modules. Randomization will occur at the “paraprofessional,” or FFBS facilitator, level.

Sample: We will conduct household surveys among treatment and control households who are participating in the FFBS program at both baseline (August 2024) and endline (August 2026). Of the 1,186 households recruited at baseline, 946 are dual-adult households (where both spouses are interviewed), and 240 are female-headed households (where only the female head is interviewed), for a total of 2,132 targeted respondents.

Outcomes: We will assess changes in time spent on unpaid care work and overall daily workload among men and women using a 24-hour recall adapted from the Pro-WEAI. We will additionally assess secondary outcomes of gender norms and decision-making power surrounding unpaid care work; household investment in labor-saving devices and outsourcing of care work; household income; control over household income; time allocation to paid and educational activities for all other household members; intra-household conflict in dual-adult households; and VSLA investment in labor-saving devices and outsourced care work.

Intervention

The intervention will consist of Unpaid Care Work modules integrated into the existing FFBS curriculum. The Unpaid Care Work modules and activities are currently being designed in response to findings from the baseline data collection. Once the modules are complete, the implementer CARE Tanzania will train frontline staff randomly assigned to the treatment group to deliver these modules to their groups in addition to the standard FFBS curriculum.
Activities
• Monthly dialogue sessions with producer group members, facilitated by frontline staff, focusing on unpaid care work and its impact on household members. Sessions will run year-round, independent of agricultural seasons to ensure continuity.
• Collaboration with a local partner to develop and provide low-cost labor-saving devices to reduce unpaid care work burdens. Since most producer group members are also VSLA members, the project will encourage them to use their savings and loans to purchase these devices.

Compliance, spillover and differential participation and attrition
• No major compliance issues are anticipated, as CARE has successfully used the dialogue-based approach in similar community programs. CARE will use a monitoring tool to track the outcomes of the dialogue sessions relating to shifting care work norms and practices.
• Spillover effects are expected to be minimal, as activities will be delivered within group settings by frontline staff assigned to either treatment or control, reducing cross-group exposure.
• Since the Unpaid Care Work Modules build on the existing FFBS infrastructure, treatment and control groups will face similar participation dynamics. Endline survey participation is also not expected to differ significantly between treatment and control households, given the shared FFBS framework.

Experimental design

Our study utilizes a cluster randomized controlled trial (cRCT) to evaluate the impact of adding Care Work Modules to the existing FFBS curriculum. Paraprofessionals trained to lead FFBS groups are randomly assigned to either the intervention arm, which receives the additional Care Work Modules, or the control arm, which continues with the standard curriculum.
Randomization was conducted at the level of the group facilitator (called ‘paraprofessional’) rather than by FFBS group. This approach was selected to prevent contamination since a single paraprofessional can train multiple FFBS groups, and mixing intervention and control groups under one facilitator could bias results.

Design details

Randomization method
Using the statistical software Stata, we executed 1,000 rounds of randomization and group selection to enhance study power and ensure comparability between the treatment and control arms. We then selected the iteration that yielded the fewest average groups per paraprofessional and the greatest equilibrium across wards.
Randomization unit
The unit of randomization is the paraprofessional. After assigning all 60 paraprofessionals to treatment or control, we randomly selected FFBS groups led by each for inclusion in the study. As noted above, we executed 1,000 rounds of randomization and group selection to enhance study power and ensure comparability between the treatment and control arms. We initially sampled 60 first-choice groups per arm, plus 20 backups per arm, anticipating potential list inaccuracies. Within each selected FFBS group, we then randomly sampled 10 households per group, plus replacement households. If groups were large, up to 25 replacement households were sampled to address potential field issues. To avoid double-sampling spouses—since household composition was not in the sampling frame—we exclusively sampled women respondents, determining in the field whether each household was dual-adult or female-headed.
Clusters
60 paraprofessionals
Observations
Our target sample was initially 1200 households (960 dual-adult households and 240 female-headed households). Because we sought to recruit both men and women from dual-adult households, this would reflect a total of 2,160 individual survey respondents. At baseline, we recruited 1,186 households (946 dual-adult households and 240 female-headed households), reflecting a total of 2,132 individual respondents.
Arms
Our target sample was 600 treatment households and 600 control households. At baseline, we recruited 586 control and 600 treatment households.
Primary outcomes
The primary experimental outcomes of the RCT are a. Total hours unpaid care work time performed by women b. Daily workload of women c. Gender gap in time allocation to unpaid care work among men and women in dual-adult households d. Gender gap in daily workload among men and women in dual-adult households
Secondary outcomes
The secondary outcomes are: ● Gender norms and decision-making power surrounding unpaid care work ● Household investment in labor-saving devices and outsourcing of care work ● Household income ● Control over household income ● Time allocation to paid and educational activities for all household members ● Intra-household conflict in dual-adult households ● VSLA investment in labor-saving devices and outsourced care work ● Gender gap in unpaid care for FFBS groups whose VSLA funded childcare systems
Sponsors
Name: The International Development Research Centre (IDRC) Location: Ottawa, Canada Url: https://www.idrc-crdi.ca/en
Partners
Name: CARE Partner_type: ngo Url: https://www.care.org/

Cited by

No citation data available for this registration yet.

Keywords