Lies, Truths, and Perceptions

How to cite

Ho, Benjamin; Shurchkov, Olga; Deryugina, Tatyana. 2025. "Lies, Truths, and Perceptions." AEA RCT Registry. AEARCTR-0015324. https://doi.org/10.1257/rct.15324-1.0

Download: BibTeX · RIS — for reference managers without a browser translator. Zotero and most others pick up this page's citation metadata directly.

Benjamin Ho* , Olga Shurchkov , Tatyana Deryugina

* Primary investigator

Registry ID
AEARCTR-0015324
DOI
https://doi.org/10.1257/rct.15324-1.0
First registered
Last updated
Status
In development
Trial dates
2025-02-05 – 2026-02-25
Countries
United States of America ()
JEL codes
C91, D91, D72
Secondary IDs
https://osf.io/bj3d9
Registry record
http://www.socialscienceregistry.org/trials/15324

Abstract

Disinformation is a growing concern in today's digital environment, influencing public opinion on social media, political discourse, and everyday decision-making. This study investigates individuals’ ability to discern the truthfulness of self-reports made by anonymous participants, focusing on how the extremeness of a claim affects perceived credibility. Using an online experiment, participants will assess reports generated by others in controlled settings, with some exposed to incentives for being believed and others provided with gender information about the sender. We test whether people behave as Bayesians when assessing potential deception and whether incentives, gender, and belief priors systematically influence their evaluations. Our findings contribute to the understanding of truth perception, the strategic modification of statements based on audience incentives, and the mechanisms underlying the spread of misinformation.

Intervention

The study involves an online experiment conducted via Qualtrics and Prolific, where participants evaluate the truthfulness of reports made by others. The experiment consists of three main parts:

Truthful Self-Reporting Task (Part 1): Participants (senders) complete a task (either a random number task or a matrix task) and report their performance.
Lie Detection Task (Part 2): Other participants (receivers) assess the accuracy of reports from Part 1, sometimes with additional information such as gender cues. Receivers also express their confidence and wager potential earnings on their assessments.
Survey and Beliefs (Part 3): Participants provide demographic information and respond to incentivized questions about general misreporting patterns.
The intervention includes:

Two experimental tasks (Numbers Task and Matrix Task)
Four treatment conditions per task:
No Incentive to Persuade (NIT) & No Gender Information (NGT)
Incentive to Persuade (IT) & No Gender Information (NGT)
No Incentive to Persuade (NIT) & Gender Information (GT)
Incentive to Persuade (IT) & Gender Information (GT)

Experimental design

Within-subjects variation: Each receiver evaluates multiple reports of varying extremeness.
Between-subjects variation: Participants are randomized into one of four treatment conditions (incentive vs. no incentive, gender information vs. no gender information).
Attention Checks: To ensure data quality, an explicit attention check will be implemented, and subjects failing it will be removed.

(see attachment)

Design details

Randomization method
qualtrics survey
Randomization unit
individual
Clusters
2000 online subjects
Observations
2000
Arms
1000 in the effort task, 1000 in the random number task. also within each task, we randomized information provided about gender, and incentives so 250 for each arm of the 2x2 treatment design.
Primary outcomes
Primary Endpoints: Truth Perception Accuracy: The probability that receivers correctly assess whether a report is true or false. Earnings Maximization: Whether receivers make truth assessments in a way that maximizes their expected earnings. Effect of Report Extremeness on Credibility: Whether more extreme claims (e.g., reporting a maximum value) are perceived as less truthful. Effect of Incentives on Lying: Whether senders report more truthfully when their payment depends on being believed.
Secondary outcomes
Confidence and Betting Behavior: How much participants stake on their evaluations and whether they adjust this behavior under different treatments. Gender Effects on Believability: Whether gender cues influence the perceived credibility of reports. Receiver’s Own Lying Behavior: Whether a participant’s own tendency to lie affects their likelihood of doubting others. Cognitive Processing and Lie Detection: The relationship between contemplation time and lying behavior. Social and Risk Preferences: How demographic and preference-based factors correlate with lying behavior and lie detection accuracy. Altruism in Lie Detection: Whether receivers avoid marking reports as false in cases where doing so reduces the sender’s earnings.

Cited by

No citation data available for this registration yet.

Keywords