Nurturing STEM Talent in School

How to cite

Carlana, Michela; Delfino, Alexia; Ashraf, Nava; Rinaldi, Francesca. 2025. "Nurturing STEM Talent in School." AEA RCT Registry. AEARCTR-0015320. https://doi.org/10.1257/rct.15320-1.0

Download: BibTeX · RIS — for reference managers without a browser translator. Zotero and most others pick up this page's citation metadata directly.

Michela Carlana* , Alexia Delfino , Nava Ashraf , Francesca Rinaldi

* Primary investigator

Registry ID
AEARCTR-0015320
DOI
https://doi.org/10.1257/rct.15320-1.0
First registered
Last updated
Status
In development
Trial dates
2025-08-01 – 2027-07-31
Countries
Private
JEL codes
I21, I24, I26, J16, J22, J24
Registry record
http://www.socialscienceregistry.org/trials/15320

Abstract

The persistent under-representation of women in STEM fields contributes to the growing gap between the demand for and supply of STEM skills, with gender disparities emerging as early as adolescence when girls take fewer advanced science courses. While numerous initiatives aim to promote female participation in STEM, their effectiveness remains under-explored. In this project, we address the issue of female under-representation in STEM by focusing on the participation of girls in advanced coding clubs in Italian middle schools. We aim to causally address two main research questions: (1) Does the peer composition of coding clubs (single-sex vs. mixed-gender) affect the performance, choice of science track in high school? Does it affect the perception of stereotypes in the school and society? (2) Does combining negotiation skills with coding reduce the gender gaps in the choice of science track in high school?

We partner with the NGO “Officina Futuro Foundation" that has been implementing coding clubs in Italian schools since 2014. The project is designed to involve two levels of randomization to answer the research questions. First, in the schools implementing at the same time both the single-sex and mixed-gender clubs, we will randomly assign girls at individual level to one of the two activities. Second, we will randomly assign at the club level an additional training on empowering communication and negotiation skills. Using a wide set of administrative and survey data, we will investigate the impact on girls' performance, high-school track choice, perception of stereotypes about gender and science, and self-concept.

Intervention

This study includes two interventions with different aims.
The first component of the intervention focuses on the peer composition of these clubs and involves all students who applied to participate in a coding club. Female students are randomized into mixed-gender (STEM Your Brain) or single-sex (Girls Code It Better) clubs. Male students are randomized into mixed-gender coding club (STEM Your Brain), referred to as treatment group, or out (no coding club), referred to as control group. All students are attending the coding course in the school year 2025-26.
The second intervention is at the club level and concerns all students participating in that club. Half of the club will be assigned to complete a training on empowering communication and negotiation skills. Delivered through workshops and follow-up sessions, this component seeks to mitigate potential negative effects of mixed-gender interactions by fostering confidence, active listening, and collaboration skills among participants.

Experimental design

There are two main RCT experiments. The first one involves the randomization of student to mixed-gender or single-sex clubs in schools that offer both types of clubs. The second concern the impact of an additional workshop to develop soft skills and effective communication among the set of all participating clubs (regardless of the club type).

Design details

Randomization method
The randomization will be done in office by a computer. For the first intervention, a number will be randomly assigned to each applicant and those with the associated smallest number will be selected to attend the mixed-gender club. For the second intervention, a number will be randomly assigned to each club and those with the associated smallest number will be selected.
Randomization unit
We will randomize the first intervention at the individual level within each school and gender: that is, female students within the same school will be randomized at the individual level, and male students within the same school will also be randomized at the individual level. The second intervention will be randomized at the club level.
Clusters
For the first intervention, the treatment is clustered by schools, and we expect a total of 40 schools. For the second intervention, the clusters are the coding clubs, and we expect a total of around 160 clubs in 80 schools.
Observations
For the first intervention, we expect a total of up to 2,000 female students and 2,000 male students. For the second intervention, we expect a total of around 3,200 students. For spillover effects, the population for this study includes up to 15,000 students enrolled in grade 6 to 8 in all 80 schools.
Arms
For the first intervention, female applicants in schools implementing both clubs (40 schools) will be randomly allocated to either single-sex or mixed-gender groups. All female students will be included in the clubs, eventually increasing the number of clubs created in the school if there in case of excessive demand. The mixed-gender clubs will have at least 30% of female students. Among the male applicants, we will randomly select students to fill 70% of the slots in mixed-gender clubs. For the second intervention, we include 50% of coding clubs as treated and 50% as control.
Primary outcomes
Chosen high school track; Questions on stereotypes on gender, science, and soft-skills; Negotiation and communication skills
Secondary outcomes
Network data; educational aspirations; psychological well-being; risk attitudes; students school performance

Cited by

No citation data available for this registration yet.

Keywords