Household Responses to Fiscal News Shocks: Vignette Experiment
How to cite
Blossey, Nils; Schröder, Adrian. 2025. "Household Responses to Fiscal News Shocks: Vignette Experiment." AEA RCT Registry. AEARCTR-0015317. https://doi.org/10.1257/rct.15317-1.0
Download: BibTeX · RIS — for reference managers without a browser translator. Zotero and most others pick up this page's citation metadata directly.
* Primary investigator
Abstract
We use a factorial vignette experiment to analyze how U.S. households respond to expansionary government spending shocks. A nationally representative sample of 1,600 respondents is presented with two scenarios—a baseline and a shock scenario—in which prospective government spending is randomized along three key dimensions: size, duration, and composition. We then examine how expectations about fiscal policy affect household forecasts for key macroeconomic variables, including inflation, GDP growth, unemployment, and average income tax rates. To explore the mental models underpinning the transmission mechanisms of fiscal policy, we elicit open-ended explanations and allow respondents to state their agreement with established theoretical mechanisms linking fiscal shocks to macroeconomic outcomes. This allows us to determine whether households’ mental models align more with Keynesian or Ricardian models of fiscal policy.
Intervention
We first inform respondents about the typical growth rate of federal government spending in the United States and ask them to provide their expectations for four key macroeconomic outcomes—inflation, unemployment, GDP growth, and the average income tax rate—over the next 12 months. Each respondent is then presented with a vignette describing a hypothetical fiscal expansion, which is randomized along three dimensions: the size of the expansion, its duration (temporary or permanent), and its composition (general spending, military spending, or infrastructure).
Experimental design
Our experimental design is structured as follows: First, respondents receive information about the usual real growth rate of federal government spending. They are then asked to provide their expectations for four key macroeconomic outcomes—inflation, GDP growth, the unemployment rate, and the average income tax rate—over a twelve-month horizon under this baseline scenario. Next, each respondent is assigned to a shock scenario, which consists of a randomized combination of the size, timing, and composition of a fiscal expansion. Finally, based on this shock scenario, respondents once again predict the evolution of each macroeconomic outcome.
Design details
Cited by
No citation data available for this registration yet.