Multidimensional Temptation: Field Evidence

How to cite

Suchy, Rafael; Merone, Stefania; Toussaert, Séverine. 2025. "Multidimensional Temptation: Field Evidence." AEA RCT Registry. AEARCTR-0015314. https://doi.org/10.1257/rct.15314-1.3

Download: BibTeX · RIS — for reference managers without a browser translator. Zotero and most others pick up this page's citation metadata directly.

Rafael Suchy* , Stefania Merone , Séverine Toussaert

* Primary investigator

Registry ID
AEARCTR-0015314
DOI
https://doi.org/10.1257/rct.15314-1.3
First registered
Last updated
Status
On going
Trial dates
2025-02-03 – 2025-02-21
Countries
Private
JEL codes
C93, D01, D90, D91
Registry record
http://www.socialscienceregistry.org/trials/15314

Abstract

The current empirical work on temptation and self-control costs is limited to settings in laboratory settings and predominantly focused on existence claims. To bring decision theory in the field, we design customized food ordering platforms on which we invite participants for a challenge - following a carb- and meat-controlled diet for three consecutive days. Our dataset allows us to take an agnostic and comprehensive approach to measure temptation: we allow for any degree of commitment, from commitment to a single meal category to complete flexibility. Using information on the entire ordering over seven menus, we develop measures to study the source, strength and structure of temptation. More specifically, our design allows us to test for cumulative and stochastic temptation. We use detailed survey data on participants’ food perceptions and self-reported consumption to test whether the elicited behavioral measures align with participants’ assessments of what foods are tempting and unhealthy. We validate our quantitative measures against real-world behavior.

Intervention

Respondents in the study complete a survey in which they submit preferences over seven meal platforms (which differ in the number of meals offered). After completing the survey, all respondents will be invited to a second stage. In the second stage, participants receive a link to one of the seven food ordering platforms. The specific food ordering platforms are partly determined by the survey responses (e.g., orderings that participants submitted) and partly determined by chance. We will further track the number of meals respondents collect in colleges.

Experimental design

We aim to recruit 400 students across 6 colleges, targeting roughly 12% of the student body within each college. The study consists of 4 main parts.

(i) Main survey (20-25 mins): Collection of socio-demographics background variables, meal habits, and introduction to the meal challenge and food ordering platform. Elicitation of preferences for the menu shown on the platform via iterative ranking and monetary valuations. Administered the week of 03/02/2025.
(ii) Meal ordering: Order of 5 meals on the platform that was randomly assigned to the respondents. The orders need to be submitted in the morning of 10/02/2025.
(iii) Meal pickup: Consumption on site of the meals ordered between 10/02/2025 and 14/02/2025 (each day, Monday to Friday during college hall lunchtime hours).
(iv) Follow-up survey (10-15 mins): Feedback survey on experiences. Sent at the end of the challenge (from 14/02/2025).

Design details

Randomization method
There are two sources of randomization: (1) Randomization of menu assigned on the platform: This randomization will be performed in R after the main survey took place. We will perform the randomization at the college level. (2) Information treatment: In the main survey, we will randomize a message at the college level. The control message will simply remind participants of the two dimensions of performance in the challenge (choice of plant-based options and hall attendance). The treatment message will say that an AI model expressed uncertainty about their performance in the challenge (accounting for both dimensions). We will assess the impact of the message on (i) their self-reported motivation (primary); (ii) their menu preferences (primary); (iii) their expected meal category choice (secondary); (iv) their expected number of meal pickups (secondary); (v) their chosen meal category if they got the unrestricted platform (primary); (vi) their actual number of meal pickups (primary); (vii) whether they picked up all 5 meals (secondary). Randomization was performed via survey software (Qualtrics) and statistical software by computer (Python and R).
Randomization unit
Individual
Clusters
Target: 400 participants (selected partly for logistical reasons)
Observations
Target: 400 participants (selected partly for logistical reasons)
Arms
Target: 200 participants per treatment arm (selected partly for logistical reasons)
Primary outcomes
(i) Indicator=1 if the participant put the unrestricted platform (showing all 3 meal categories) at the top of their ranking (alone) and =0 otherwise; (ii) Indicator=1 if the participant put the restricted platform with Daily Harvest only at the top of their ranking (alone) and =0 otherwise; (iii) Indicator=1 if the participant actually chose Daily Harvest when facing the unrestricted platform and =0 otherwise; (iv) Number of meals collected (between 0 and 5).
Secondary outcomes
(i) Indicator=1 if the participant submitted an order on the platform and =0 otherwise; (ii) Indicator=1 if the participant collected all 5 meals and =0 otherwise; (iii) Indicator=1 if the participant collected at least one meal and =0 otherwise.

Cited by

No citation data available for this registration yet.

Keywords