Gendered Job-Role Framing Effects
How to cite
Sandvik, Jason. 2025. "Gendered Job-Role Framing Effects." AEA RCT Registry. AEARCTR-0015311. https://doi.org/10.1257/rct.15311-1.0
Download: BibTeX · RIS — for reference managers without a browser translator. Zotero and most others pick up this page's citation metadata directly.
* Primary investigator
Abstract
We study whether prospective employees' assessments of their gender-based goodness-of-fit for a particular job role can be influenced by visual depictions of the gender make-up of the workforce. We do this specifically within the context of recruitment for detention center officers. Historically, detention center officer positions, like other law enforcement job roles, have been held predominately by men. However, there is increasing evidence that suggests women can succeed in these roles as well. We look to see whether a person's perceptions of whether women are a good fit for jobs as detention center officers changes when they see visual depictions of women in those roles.
Intervention
We will administer a survey-based experiment via Qualtrics to a nationally representative sample of working age adults, with oversampling of individuals in Arizona. We are using the survey sampling services of Cint for this. Participants will respond to questions about their demographic traits, interest in working as a detention center officer, and views on specific topics/issues within the survey. Randomization will occur via the Qualtrics block-randomization tool, and this is how participants will be randomly exposed to the treatment stimulus of the control conditions (described below). Participants will be paid for their participation by Cint.
Experimental design
After consenting to participate and passing the attention check question. All participants will be provided with some basic information about the duties and responsibilities of detention center officers. A third of the participants will see only this information, with no graphics. Another third of the participants will see this information, along with three images of detention center officers (of which all are male). Another third of the participants will see this information, along with three images of detention center officers (of which two are female and one is male). Then they will engage in the double-list exercise, where they will each be shown four lists of 4-5 statements, and they will be asked to state how many of the statements in each list are true for them. Two of the lists will each contain a key statement, one that has to do with their perceptions of women's suitability for being detention center officers relative to men and one that has to do with their willingness to switch jobs if their ideological leanings differed from that of their supervisors. The placement of the key statements will vary randomly across and within lists. This variation is not a key aspect of the design other than it helps to resolve concerns about order effects.
After completing the double-list exercise, they will respond to a series of questions about their demographic traits and their work experience. They will also be explicitly asked about their perceptions of women's suitability for being detention center officers relative to men and about their willingness to switch jobs if their ideological leanings differed from that of their supervisors
Design details
Cited by
No citation data available for this registration yet.