Training Experiment in the Latin American Quick-Service Restaurant Industry. Enhancing Managerial Skills and Workforce Development.

How to cite

Nyshadham, Anant. 2025. "Training Experiment in the Latin American Quick-Service Restaurant Industry. Enhancing Managerial Skills and Workforce Development.." AEA RCT Registry. AEARCTR-0015298. https://doi.org/10.1257/rct.15298-1.0

Download: BibTeX · RIS — for reference managers without a browser translator. Zotero and most others pick up this page's citation metadata directly.

Anant Nyshadham*

* Primary investigator

Registry ID
AEARCTR-0015298
DOI
https://doi.org/10.1257/rct.15298-1.0
First registered
Last updated
Status
On going
Trial dates
2025-01-20 – 2025-12-31
Countries
Private
JEL codes
L2, M50, J24, L66
Registry record
http://www.socialscienceregistry.org/trials/15298

Abstract

This study intends to explore the managerial practices of the quick service restaurant industry in Colombia, in order to explore how their autonomous decisions affect performance in equilibrium times and in times when they face a disruption (natural disasters, pandemic, political unrest).

We intend to implement and evaluate a training curriculum for managers consisting of several training sessions based on a previous study’s survey answers, with the purpose of improving managers’ soft skills. There will be 2 curricula, one for men and one for women, each based on the survey’s answers for managers of each gender, and the relationship between managers’ answers and their productivity. Our intention is to evaluate whether soft skills training aimed at the specific characteristics of male or female managers can improve managers productivity and modify managerial practices.
Our intention is to answer the following questions:

How do managers in the QSR industry make decisions?
How do such managerial practices affect performance in general (in equilibrium times)
How do managers handle decisions in unprecedented times (times of crisis including Hurricane María, Guayanilla earthquake, power outages following the earthquake in Puerto Rico, as well as times of political unrest and outstanding events in Colombia).
How did the introduction of the Leadership technology affect Arcos Dorados’ restaurant level managerial practices and productivity?
How does the introduction of on demand delivery services affect managerial practices and productivity?
How does a training intervention for managerial practices impact store performance and changes in managerial practices.

Experimental design

All managers at the store level were selected as training participants, with a total of 460 managers in 74 restaurants. Multiple managers can work at the same time in the same store, and managers are divided into shift managers, area managers or restaurant managers. Randomization was thus done at the store level, and stratified on three variables. The first is store location, grouping all stores in the capital city, Bogotá, and all stores in other cities. Out of the 74 stores, 34 are located in Bogotá and 40 in other cities. The second variable used for the stratification is the gender balance of the store.Following Adhvaryu et al. (2023a), we construct a measure of Manager-Worker gender balance. The measure identifies "imbalanced" stores as stores where the share of managers of a certain gender exceeds the share of workers of the same gender by at least 15% (stores where the share of female managers exceeds the share of female workers by at least 15% are denoted as Female-heavy Management or FHM, and stores where the share of male managers exceeds the share of male workers by at least 15% are denoted as Male-heavy Management or MHM). We also classify "balanced" stores into Male-balanced or Female-balanced, with stores where the share of male managers exceeds the share of male workers by less than 15% and where the share of female managers exceeds the share of female workers by less than 15% respectively. We do not observe stores where the share of male or female managers is exactly equal to the share of male or female managers. The third variable is a binary variable that outlines stores that are in the process of closing down. While implementing the deployment of our intervention, our firm partner made us aware of the plans to close down 3 stores sometime between the planned start of our intervention and the end of the year. As such, we stratify for this stores so that after they are closed, no group ends up with a larger number of stores. By stratifying our sample this way, we can also expect to to identify differential treatment effects according to the gender composition of the store managers are at.

Design details

Randomization method
We randomize into 3 treatment arms, one for each curriculum and control, and all stores from our firm partner are selected into one of the three arms. As such, stores are randomized into 3 possible groups. While the control group has no access to any curriculum, the managers at these stores were given access to the hosting platform but were only able to see and fill out the pre-post testing survey for each module of the curriculum, and were told that the survey is intended for a managerial characteristics study. Additionally, since managers in the control only had to fill the 4 pre-post surveys, we expected that they would be able to complete this in around 15-20 minutes, and were likely to not return to the platform to fill the surveys again later. As such, control managers were only asked to fill the survey once rather than twice. In order to make the three intervention arms as similar as possible and improve balance, we run a re-randomization exercise. Following Banerjee et al. (2020), we first run 5000 iterations of the randomization, followed by performing balance tests between groups for several relevant measures: store sales, both monthly and quarterly, employee hiring and turnover, and manager indexes, using the indexes described in section 3. After we have run these balance tests, we select 5% of the randomization that performed better, and randomly select one of these to be our final randomization. This ensures that our randomly assigned groups are balanced and are as comparable as possible while still being assigned randomly.
Randomization unit
Restaurant/store
Clusters
71
Observations
700 workers 400 managers
Arms
C=23 T1=24 T2=24
Primary outcomes
Performance (sales, units sold, and tickets) Personnel variables (hiring, turnover, absenteeism, scheduling, training) Manager report indices (control, personality, experience & education, soft & hard skills, metrics, broad skilling, preemptive planning, rapport, pyramid organization, autonomy, and kaizen) Worker report indices (rapport, psychological safety, harassment, and satisfaction)

Cited by

No citation data available for this registration yet.

Keywords