A Crucial Moment in Defense: An RCT of Counsel at First Appearance

How to cite

Naufal, Georges; Patterson, Bethany; Danser, Renee; Greiner, D. James. 2025. "A Crucial Moment in Defense: An RCT of Counsel at First Appearance." AEA RCT Registry. AEARCTR-0015291. https://doi.org/10.1257/rct.15291-1.0

Download: BibTeX · RIS — for reference managers without a browser translator. Zotero and most others pick up this page's citation metadata directly.

Georges Naufal* , Bethany Patterson , Renee Danser , D. James Greiner

* Primary investigator

Registry ID
AEARCTR-0015291
DOI
https://doi.org/10.1257/rct.15291-1.0
First registered
Last updated
Status
Completed
Trial dates
2020-07-06 – 2021-09-21
Countries
United States of America (Texas)
JEL codes
C93, J08, K4, K14
Registry record
http://www.socialscienceregistry.org/trials/15291

Abstract

Upon arrest and booking, a defendant is presented in front of a judge in a hearing referred to as first appearance also known as magistration. At first appearance, magistrate judges decide whether a person will be released while awaiting trial or held in jail. Currently, there are no counsel present at magistration in almost all counties around the state of Texas. Out of 254 counties, only 5 (Bexar, Cameron, Fort Bend, Harris, and Potter Counties) offer counsel at first appearance. Nationally, and as of 2009, only fourteen states guarantee legal representation at first appearance. There has never been a systematic evaluation of the effects of counsel at first appearance on different outcomes. This study examines the causal impact of a defense counsel on primary outcomes including bail type, bail amount, release decisions, release conditions, and secondary outcomes such as recidivism, failure to appear, and disposition.

Intervention

Upon arrest and booking, a defendant is presented in front of a judge in a hearing referred to as first appearance also known as magistration. At first appearance, magistrate judges decide whether a person will be released while awaiting trial or held in jail. Currently, there are no counsel present at magistration in almost all counties around the state of Texas. Out of 254 counties, only 5 (Bexar, Cameron, Fort Bend, Harris, and Potter Counties) offer counsel at first appearance. Nationally, and as of 2009, only fourteen states guarantee legal representation at first appearance. There has never been a systematic evaluation of the effects of counsel at first appearance on different outcomes. This study examines the causal impact of a defense counsel on primary outcomes including bail type, bail amount, release decisions, release conditions, and secondary outcomes such as recidivism, failure to appear, and disposition.

Experimental design

This study takes advantage of the magistration process occurring once a day in two counties to randomize days on which defense counsel is present at magistration. The research team created a randomization schedule for a full year plus a few pilot days. In Hays County, the RCT study started on July 6, 2020, and ended on July 11, 2021. In Potter County, the RCT study started on September 16, 2020, and ended on September 21, 2021. The randomization schedule is balanced for day of the week and month to account for seasonality in criminal activity and maintaining a 50% randomization rate. The schedule was set up at the day level allowing for attorneys to be present at magistration on the treatment days for the full duration of all hearings. Attorneys met with all defendants who are scheduled for magistration for about 10 minutes each before the hearing started. Attorneys advocated on behalf of each defendant in front of the judge.

Design details

Randomization method
Randomization was done using the randomize command in Stata.
Randomization unit
Days
Clusters
About 365 days for each county.
Observations
About 5000 individuals in Hays County and 3000 individuals in Potter County.
Arms
About 2500 individuals in the control and 2500 in the treatment in Hays County About 1500 individuals in the control and 1500 in the treatment in Potter County
Primary outcomes
Bail type, bail amount, release conditions, days in jail
Secondary outcomes
Recidivism, failure to appear, disposition, sentencing, cost

Cited by

No citation data available for this registration yet.

Keywords