Wiseguys or Wise Guys? How do high school equivalency credentials affect third-party appraisals of job applicants' resumes?
How to cite
Heller, Blake; Singla, Henam. 2025. "Wiseguys or Wise Guys? How do high school equivalency credentials affect third-party appraisals of job applicants' resumes?." AEA RCT Registry. AEARCTR-0015269. https://doi.org/10.1257/rct.15269-1.1
Download: BibTeX · RIS — for reference managers without a browser translator. Zotero and most others pick up this page's citation metadata directly.
* Primary investigator
Abstract
This study will measure the influence of reported educational attainment on third-party evaluations of job applicants, focusing the penalties or rewards associated with applicants' reporting having earned a high school equivalency credential. We will recruit roughly 1,000 hiring managers from the five states (CA, FL, GA, NY, and TX) with the largest number of GED testers in 2022 and ask them to evaluate resumes of applicants with randomly assigned characteristics, including implied gender, implied race/ethnicity, work experience, volunteer experience, and educational attainment. We will assess the impact of observing different educational credentials on these hiring managers' appraisals of the resumes, focusing on the relationship between observing a high school equivalency credential and applicant ratings relative to 1) no educational credential reported, 2) a traditional high school diploma (from high- and low-achieving schools), and 3) some college. Additionally, a subset of applicants who report having a high school equivalency credential will also report earning a "GED College Readiness" designation in math or language arts. Finally, we during the survey, will present two different entry-level job descriptions to evaluators, asking them to assess five pairs of resumes for each type of job: a customer service position (with relatively high social skill task content) and a data entry position (with relatively low social skill task content). We will randomize the order in which job descriptions are presented so that some evaluators assess applicants for a customer service position first versus the data entry job (and vice versa), allowing us to test whether the impact of educational credentials is related to the type of job for which applicants are applying.
Intervention
We will recruit roughly 1,000 evaluators with managerial experience from five states (CA, FL, GA, NY, and TX) and ask them to evaluate resumes of applicants with randomly assigned characteristics, including implied gender, implied race/ethnicity, work experience, volunteer experience, and educational attainment. We will also randomly assign the entry-level job description that is presented to evaluators between a customer service position with relatively high social skill task content versus an administrative job with relatively low social skill task content and test whether the impact of educational credentials is related to job characteristics.
Before collecting data from all 1,000 evaluators, we will run a pilot of 50 evaluators to test survey functionality. Once we confirm that they survey works as intended, we will scale up data collection to the remaining 950 evaluators.
We will assess the impact of observing different resume characteristics on these hiring managers' appraisals of the resumes.
Our primary analysis will focus on assessing the relationship between observing a high school equivalency credential and evaluator appraisals relative to applications with 1) no educational credential reported, 2) a traditional high school diploma, and 3) some college.
Our exploratory analyses will assess whether there are differential impacts of listing a high school equivalency credential on evaluator rating for the subset of applicants who report having a high school equivalency credential and also report earning a "GED College Readiness" designation in math or language arts as well as assessing whether the impact of educational credentials varies by job type (customer service vs. data entry). We will also examine whether different resume characteristics moderate the effect of educational credentials on evaluations (e.g., more or less experience; racial or gender differences in impacts (as well as their interaction); type of experience [volunteer vs. paid work; sector of paid work], etc.). We will present our primary analyses pooled across cities, but also publish results separately by state. Additionally, we will assess whether earning a HS diploma from a high-performing vs. low-performing high school moderates any gap in evaluation between HSE equivalency credential holders and traditional HS grads, with and without limiting our sample to evaluators who accurately identify at least 2 of 3 high performing high schools (or 2 of 3 low-performing high schools) in their metro area. Finally, we will assess the mechanisms that explain why hiring managers reward or penalize applicants with HSE by examining whether participants ratings of applicants or preferences for applicants with HSE credentials varies with the factors they report considering as they evaluated candidates as well as the factors they state are "most important" for hiring managers to consider (e.g., social skills, problem solving skills, language skills, alignment of work experience with job, criminal history, etc.).
Experimental design
The experimental design involves recruiting 1,000 hiring managers from five states (CA, FL, GA, NY, TX) to evaluate resumes with randomly assigned characteristics. Each resume will have variations in implied gender, implied race/ethnicity, work experience, volunteer experience, and educational attainment (GED, high school diploma, no education, or some college). Additionally, job descriptions will be randomly assigned to either a customer service role (with high social skill content) or an administrative role (with low social skill content). Hiring managers will rate each resume on various attributes and choose a preferred candidate from pairs of resumes, allowing us to assess the impact of educational credentials on their evaluations. A subset of applicants who report having a high school equivalency credential will also report earning a "GED College Readiness" designation in math or language arts.
Design details
Cited by
No citation data available for this registration yet.