Paternalism and Decision-Making under Cognitive Load
How to cite
Holzmann, Matthias; Danzer, Alexander M.. 2025. "Paternalism and Decision-Making under Cognitive Load." AEA RCT Registry. AEARCTR-0015268. https://doi.org/10.1257/rct.15268-2.0
Download: BibTeX · RIS — for reference managers without a browser translator. Zotero and most others pick up this page's citation metadata directly.
* Primary investigator
Abstract
In economic decision-making, individuals often face cognitive load and distractions, which can impair their decision quality and ability to focus on tasks. Therefore, we run a two-wave survey experiment investigating how perceived reductions in decision quality due to cognitive load and distractions influence the willingness to regulate others’ choices. The study, conducted on a representative sample of the German population, assigns participants the role of choice architects (CAs), tasked with constructing payoff sets for decision-makers (DMs) selecting among risky lotteries. In the treatment group, CAs are informed that DMs face cognitive load while choosing their preferred lotteries, which is induced by requiring DMs to simultaneously perform a memorization task. In the control group DMs face no additional cognitive load. The study also examines the beliefs and motives underlying these regulatory behaviors.
Intervention
In a survey experiment, choice architects (CAs) can (in concealed fashion) select lottery choices for potential payoff from a fixed choice set of four lotteries for other survey participants called decision-makers (DMs). CAs are informed that DMs are distracted while choosing their preferred lottery or not.
Experimental design
In this experiment, decision-makers (DMs) will face a decision environment involving uncertainty, where they must choose from several lotteries that determine their payment. Meanwhile, so-called choice architects (CAs) will have the ability to determine (in concealed fashion) for the decision-makers (DMs) the payoff set from a fixed choice set of four lotteries. CAs decide how many and which lotteries to make available to the DMs for potential payoff. In the treatment condition, CAs will be informed that DMs will have to memorize a 7-digit number, thereby inducing cognitive load through diverted attention. This should lead CAs to believe that DMs are unable to sufficiently evaluate the decision problem, prompting CAs to exclude certain lotteries to prevent DMs from making mistakes. By contrast, in the control condition, DMs will not face any cognitive load through remembering a number.
Design details
Cited by
No citation data available for this registration yet.