Bridging the Gap: Evidence from a Large-Scale Cluster-Randomised Trial of English and Life Skills Training for Marginalised Girls in Karnataka, India

How to cite

Blakeslee, David; Bharti, Nitin Kumar; Sharma, Nishtha; Talukdar, Aniruddha; Kayes, Imrul; Joseph, Amalu K. 2025. "Bridging the Gap: Evidence from a Large-Scale Cluster-Randomised Trial of English and Life Skills Training for Marginalised Girls in Karnataka, India." AEA RCT Registry. AEARCTR-0015254. https://doi.org/10.1257/rct.15254-2.0

Download: BibTeX · RIS — for reference managers without a browser translator. Zotero and most others pick up this page's citation metadata directly.

David Blakeslee* , Nitin Kumar Bharti , Nishtha Sharma , Aniruddha Talukdar , Imrul Kayes , Amalu K Joseph

* Primary investigator

Registry ID
AEARCTR-0015254
DOI
https://doi.org/10.1257/rct.15254-2.0
First registered
Last updated
Status
On going
Trial dates
2024-09-01 – 2026-01-31
Countries
India (Karnataka)
JEL codes
I21, I24, I25, I26, J16, O15
Registry record
http://www.socialscienceregistry.org/trials/15254

Abstract

This experiment evaluates an innovative educational intervention for girls from marginalised communities in Kasturba Gandhi Balika Vidyalaya (KGBV) schools in Karnataka, in partnership with the Government of Karnataka and a leading NGO. Out of 205 schools, 69 are randomly assigned to Treatment Arm 1, which delivers a targeted curriculum in English and Critical skills to students of Grades 6 to 9, and 66 to Treatment Arm 2, which combines the same curriculum with additional parental engagement through an Interactive Voice Response (IVR) system. The remaining 70 schools served as the control group. Approximately 13k students are assessed using standardised English, Mathematics, and Critical Skills tests, capturing both cognitive and non-cognitive outcomes. At the same time, 5k parents and all school wardens are surveyed to document socioeconomic context and institutional factors. The results of this trial will provide valuable insights into how targeted educational programs can boost academic performance and foster non-cognitive skills while enhancing parental engagement.

Intervention

This study evaluates the impact of an innovative educational program designed for marginalised adolescent girls from grades 6 through 9 in Kasturba Gandhi Balika Vidyalaya (KGBV) schools in Karnataka, India. Implemented by a non-governmental organisation, the research employs a clustered-randomised controlled trial (RCT) design to measure the effects of activity-based English and Critical skills training (CSAG) on both educational outcomes and personal development. To further enhance the intervention, an Interactive Voice Response System (IVRS) is deployed to promote student–parent engagement and to positively influence schooling outcomes, parental attitudes, and overall involvement.

The intervention comprises two treatment arms:

Treatment Arm 1: School-Level Intervention - In this arm, an activity-based curriculum in English and Critical skills is delivered to students from grades 6 through 9. This component is implemented in 69 of the 205 KGBV schools.

Treatment Arm 2: School-Level plus IVRS Intervention - In addition to the student curriculum provided in Treatment Arm 1, this arm includes an IVRS-based component that educates parents on gender-equitable norms and fosters enhanced parental engagement. This treatment is implemented in 66 schools.

Control Group: 70 schools serve as the control group and receive no intervention.

Experimental design

We conducted a large‐scale randomised controlled trial across Kasturba Gandhi Balika Vidyalaya (KGBV) schools in Karnataka. Spread across four regions (Belgaum, Kalaburagi, Bengaluru, and Mysuru), 205 schools were selected for the study. These schools comprise four distinct institutional types (adhering to the nomenclature established by the Department of School Education, Government of Karnataka) based on their residential and grade configurations:

- Type 1: Residential schools enrolling students in Grades 6–8.
- Type 3: Residential schools enrolling students in Grades 6–12, with our evaluation restricted to Grades 6–9.
- Type 4: Hostel-based schools enrolling students in Grades 9–12, with only Grade 9 students targeted.
- Type 5: Hostel-based schools enrolling students in Grades 6–10, with the evaluation focusing on Grades 6–9.

To ensure the proportional representation of all KGBV types, we employed a stratified random sampling approach based on school type and administrative region. Because there were only seven Type-3 schools statewide, we merged them with Type-1 schools since both are residential and serve the same grades. Schools were then stratified by type (merged Type-1/3, Type 4, and Type 5) and administrative region (Belgaum, Kalaburagi, Bengaluru, and Mysuru). This produced 12 strata. Within each stratum, an equal number of schools were randomly assigned to one of the three arms:

⁃ 69 schools in Treatment Arm 1
⁃ 66 schools in Treatment Arm 2
⁃ 70 schools in the Control Group

We administered surveys across three target groups: students, parents, and wardens. Within each selected school, for each targeted grade (Grades 6–9), all students in the baseline survey were included. This procedure resulted in a final student sample of approximately 13k. For the parental intervention, we randomly selected 10 students per grade (or included all students if a grade had 10 or fewer students) and tracked their primary caregivers for the parental survey. This selection yielded a final parent sample of approximately 5k households. Additionally, each school’s warden was surveyed, resulting in a sample of 205 wardens.

Our evaluation employs an extensive suite of assessments across students, parents, and wardens. Students are administered standardised tests measuring both cognitive domains (English, Mathematics, and Critical Skills) and non-cognitive skills—including self-efficacy, growth mindset, grit, and locus of control—using validated instruments. Parents are surveyed using multi-module questionnaires that capture household socioeconomic status, educational aspirations, gender norms, and engagement practices. Wardens completed a detailed survey that assesses institutional infrastructure, managerial competencies, and perceptions of student performance. The warden survey instrument also includes experimental modules—such as economic games and preference elicitation tasks—to measure risk attitudes and other economic preferences. Together, these assessments enable us to evaluate rigorously the impact of our interventions on educational outcomes and the broader ecosystem.

Design details

Randomization method
Randomisation was conducted in the office by the Principal Investigator using STATA software on a computer.
Randomization unit
Randomisation is conducted at the school (cluster) level. Schools were then stratified by type (merged Type-1/3, Type 4, and Type 5) and administrative region (Belgaum, Kalaburagi, Bengaluru, and Mysuru). This produced 12 strata. Within each stratum, an equal number of schools were randomly assigned to one of the three arms: Treatment 1, Treatment 2, and Control.
Clusters
205 Clusters (Schools) in 12 Strata
Observations
Planned observations include approximately 13k students from 205 KGBV schools (clusters), 5k parent observations, and 205 warden observations.
Arms
The sample size by treatment arms was 69 schools in Treatment Arm 1, 66 schools in Treatment Arm 2, and 70 schools in the Control Group.
Primary outcomes
Student-Level Outcomes - Schooling Outcomes (e.g., attendance, foundational literacy—including reading, writing, comprehension, and school exam scores) - Cognitive Skills (e.g., critical thinking, verbal reasoning, logical reasoning, numerical aptitude) - Non-Cognitive Skills (e.g., goals/aspirations, self-efficacy, self-perceived barriers to education) Parental-Level Outcomes - Parental Aspirations and Expectations - Parental Engagement
Secondary outcomes
Student-Level Outcomes - Other Cognitive Engagement Measures (e.g., engagement in deep or meaningful activities such as reading newspapers or books) - Affective Engagement (e.g., liking for learning and for school) - Behavioural Engagement (e.g., effort in learning and involvement in school activities) - Higher-order cognitive Skills (e.g., self-confidence, curiosity) - Socio-Emotional Skills - Gender Attitudes and Beliefs - Communication Skills - Time Use Parental-Level Outcomes - Parental Beliefs and Attitudes Warden-Level Outcomes - Warden’s Beliefs and Attitudes - Warden Motivation - Level of Effort
Partners
Name: Samagra Shikshana Karnataka (SSK), Government of Karnataka Partner_type: government Url: https://sdcedn.karnataka.gov.in Name: Swataleem Foundation Partner_type: ngo Url: https://www.swataleem.org

Cited by

No citation data available for this registration yet.

Keywords