How does information affect decision-making?

How to cite

Melo, Grace. 2025. "How does information affect decision-making?." AEA RCT Registry. AEARCTR-0015126. https://doi.org/10.1257/rct.15126-1.3

Download: BibTeX · RIS — for reference managers without a browser translator. Zotero and most others pick up this page's citation metadata directly.

Grace Melo*

* Primary investigator

Registry ID
AEARCTR-0015126
DOI
https://doi.org/10.1257/rct.15126-1.3
First registered
Last updated
Status
Completed
Trial dates
2025-02-03 – 2025-04-07
Countries
United States of America ()
JEL codes
D12; C90; D80
Registry record
http://www.socialscienceregistry.org/trials/15126

Abstract

This paper quantifies individuals’ value for objective information and investigates whether this information changes their beliefs and food preferences. The overall hypothesis is that information frictions (i.e., access to scientific, timely research findings) can help explain failures in learning and informed decision-making. We use two studies to test this hypothesis and measure the demand for research findings on as well as their behavioral response to learning. In Study 1, we will quantify individuals' value for information about synthetic biology in food (i.e., lab-grown meat) and determine whether they update their beliefs when informed of its health and environmental effects. In study 1, we expect that individuals find peer-reviewed information and numeric evidence more valuable, while nonpeer review and descriptive evidence are less informative. Based on findings from Study 1, we will develop a behaviorally informed intervention for Study 2, in which we will test whether informing consumers about the health impacts of “artificial” food additives in “natural” foods changes food preferences. In sum, this article will provide direct evidence regarding people’s preferences for information and whether providing objective information to consumers can lead to behavior change.

Intervention

Participants will be invited to take part in an experiment on “economic decision-making.” The study will begin with an introduction to lab-grown meat, followed by elicitation of participants' prior beliefs regarding its environmental and health impacts, as well as their willingness to pay (WTP) to learn findings from related impact research. Next, we will disclose the results of the incentivized elicitation approach and subsequently measured participants' stated WTP for lab-grown meat. Finally, we will elicit their posterior beliefs to evaluate how the provided information influenced their perceptions.

The information intervention is the information on the evidence brief given to those participants who purchase evidence brief based on the BDM approach.

Experimental design

In this section, we describe the first experiment to measure (a) individuals' demand for simple, concise research information and (b) how receiving information affects their beliefs and stated behavior. The context this experiment focused on was synthetic biology in food (i.e., lab-grown meat), a controversial topic in food policy discussions. Our primary hypothesis is that individuals value information about the health and environmental impact of lab-grown meat, update their beliefs and change their preferences, especially when information is perceived as trustworthy and provided in a visual manner (Figure 1).
Experimental setting and sample
We conducted Study 1 with a sample of 500 U.S. consumers in February 2024, using Forthright Access panelists to gather geographically dispersed estimates of consumer willingness to pay (WTP) for information across the United States. Forthright Access, a marketing firm, recruits respondents through a variety of online and offline advertising channels to create a nationally representative panel of US residents aged 18 and older.
We also conducted Study 1 with a sample of 500 communication experts (i.e., journalists ) recruited through Prolific. Prolific is an online research platform that connects researchers with high-quality participants, ensuring diverse and reliable samples for academic studies. WTP for information from communication experts can gauge how much value they place on having credible, research-backed information in their messaging.

Design details

Randomization method
BDM price will be drawn from a distribution with a mass of zeros. Participants wil
Randomization unit
The experimental currency in which we elicited WTP consisted of lottery tickets, which also incentivized participation. We initially endowed each participant with 100 such lottery tickets, each with a chance of winning a one of 20 $2580 e-gift card. Participants could save their lottery tickets for the lucky draw or use some, or all of them, to learn the estimated effect size of the study. Following a Becker-DeGroot-Marschak elicitation procedure (BDM), we measured the participant’s maximum WTP [0 to 100] to find out the results of the relevant study. We then drew a randomized price for the study. If the price was below the participant’s WTP, we revealed the findings and deducted the price from the participant’s stock of lottery tickets. To ensure that we observed belief updating for most participants, while maintaining incentive compatibility in the BDM procedure, the price was drawn from a distribution with high mass at zer o.
Clusters
Na
Observations
About 500 US consumers, including those who usually lack access to research (e.g., low literacy), participated in this experiment conducted online.
Arms
Total 500 US Consumers
Primary outcomes
WTP for information on the evidence brief (research evidence)
Secondary outcomes
prior and posterior beliefs

Cited by

No citation data available for this registration yet.

Keywords