The effect of paternalistic decisions on children’s self-esteem and long-term decision-making processes: Evidence from rural Thailand
How to cite
Garcia-Couto, Santiago; Sutter, Matthias; Cobo-Reyes, Ramon; Kilenthong, Weerachart. 2025. "The effect of paternalistic decisions on children’s self-esteem and long-term decision-making processes: Evidence from rural Thailand." AEA RCT Registry. AEARCTR-0015122. https://doi.org/10.1257/rct.15122-1.0
Download: BibTeX · RIS — for reference managers without a browser translator. Zotero and most others pick up this page's citation metadata directly.
* Primary investigator
Abstract
Extensive evidence demonstrates that individuals often deviate from rational decision-making due to cognitive biases, framing effects, and limited self-control. These systematic deviations can lead individuals to make choices that are not in their best long-term interests. To address these challenges, paternalistic interventions, such as automatic enrollment in pension plans, taxes on unhealthy foods, and default options, have been widely adopted by both governments and corporations (Mulligan and Philipson, 2000; Mott, 2003; Currie and Gahvari, 2008).
Paternalistic interventions are often found also in the context of families. Having children’s best interest in mind, parents frequently make decisions for their children. These decisions can range from choosing the neighborhood where children grow up, the school they attend, what extracurricular activities they do, or when their children do their homework. All these decisions will affect children in the future since attending schools of higher quality, or having contact with high-performing peers improves children’s chances for better school performance, higher educational attainment, and higher earnings (e.g., Card and Krueger, 1992; Dobbie and Fryer, 2011; Chetty and Hendren, 2018).
Paternalism, by definition, involves interventions that limit or influence individual choices. This restriction of autonomy can have several negative consequences, since autonomy is deeply connected to essential aspects of cognitive and emotional development, such as critical thinking, risk assessment, and self-regulation. By limiting autonomy, paternalistic policies may impair subjects’ development and learning processes, making individuals more susceptible to decision-making errors in situations where external controls are absent (citation). Second, paternalistic interventions may foster a culture of dependency, where individuals become overly reliant on external structures to guide their choices. This can undermine personal responsibility and diminish self-confidence (citation).
Despite the consequences that paternalistic policies might have on subjecs’ future development and decision making, empirical evidence is still scarce. This paper aims to fill that void by studying the effect of paternalistic decisions on children’s long-term decision making process.
Intervention
-
Experimental design
The experiment will consist of three treatments. In the first stage, children will face two different options for completing a real effort task where the payment scheme will be a piece rate.
Before the children begin the task, parents will be asked to choose their child's task under different treatment conditions:
• Baseline: Parents have no decision-making authority. Children select their preferred task and complete it accordingly.
• Parents’ Choice Treatment: Before starting, parents decide the task their child will perform. Children are informed that their parents made this decision at the request of the experimenters.
• Delegation Treatment: Before the task, parents choose either to select the task themselves or to allow their child to choose. Children are informed of their parents' decision-making process and choices.
Before making their decision, all participants will complete a trial round for each activity, with each trial lasting one minute and being paid on a piece rate basis. During this phase, children will not receive any feedback about their performance, and parents will not receive any information regarding the trial rounds. This allows us to classify children according to their skills to perform the tasks and to identify whether the delegation decision depends on these skills.
In the second stage, we aim to measure posterior effects on children decision-making processes. Parents are asked to provide beliefs regarding what their children would choose and what they would prefer their kid to choose. Afterwards, we will collect children's social preferences and they will be asked to participate in a real-effort task and choose the payment scheme they prefer between a non-competitive and a competitive scheme.
Design details
Cited by
No citation data available for this registration yet.