Exploring teacher’s repetition biases with a survey experiment

How to cite

Campos, Ignacio Garijo; Alfonso, Antonio; Jorrat, Diego; Sánchez, Ángel; Branas, Pablo. 2025. "Exploring teacher’s repetition biases with a survey experiment." AEA RCT Registry. AEARCTR-0015120. https://doi.org/10.1257/rct.15120-1.0

Download: BibTeX · RIS — for reference managers without a browser translator. Zotero and most others pick up this page's citation metadata directly.

Ignacio Garijo Campos* , Antonio Alfonso , Diego Jorrat , Ángel Sánchez , Pablo Branas

* Primary investigator

Registry ID
AEARCTR-0015120
DOI
https://doi.org/10.1257/rct.15120-1.0
First registered
Last updated
Status
In development
Trial dates
2025-03-17 – 2025-04-04
Countries
Spain ()
JEL codes
I21
Registry record
http://www.socialscienceregistry.org/trials/15120

Abstract

Grade repetition has been widely debated due to its potential negative effects on students' self-esteem and long-term academic performance. While most research has focused on student outcomes, this study shifts the perspective to teachers' decision-making in grade repetition cases. We conduct a survey experiment in Spain, where the repetition rate is significantly higher than the OECD average. Teachers evaluate hypothetical student profiles with varying characteristics and decide whether each student should repeat a grade. Our design allows us to analyze the impact of policy exposure, preference alignment, and cognitive biases on teachers' decisions. Additionally, we explore sociodemographic and behavioral factors associated with harsher repetition tendencies, including burnout levels, teaching experience, and institutional characteristics.

Intervention

We encourage the reader to go directly to the pdf attached to this registration ("Experimental description and analysis plan.pdf") where everything is laid out clearly and with detail.

This is a one stage experiment, meaning that teachers are only contacted once. The intervention requires access through a link compatible for both mobile and desktop that will be sent by email to all teachers by the regional government.
It is worth noting that the teachers will be asked to answer two surveys, one before the experiment and one after its completion. The total estimated time of completion is of 18 minutes.

Teachers can close the survey and open it again after days and their answers will be saved. Once they are done, they cannot answer again from the same device and browser.

Experimental design

We encourage the reader to go directly to the pdf attached to this registration ("Experimental description and analysis plan.pdf") where everything is laid out clearly and with detail.

Teachers will be asked to answer two surveys, one before the experiment and one after its completion. The total estimated time of completion is of 18 minutes.

The first survey asks sociodemographical questions as well as questions about the school the teacher works for (questions shown in the pdf document). The second survey asks behavioral questions that allow us to explore things like self-perceived empathy levels or confidence in meritocracy or the educational system.

The experiment works as following:
Teachers are presented with different student profiles (according to 6 binary characteristics) and asked if the student should repeat grade or not. They repeat the task 8 times (8 students). We name this device as the repetition task or ‘cards game’, and it allows us to estimate the
harshness level of the teacher by comparing their decisions with those of the rest of the sample. This simple setting is presented for the control group.
In the treatment groups, teachers are randomly assigned to education systems (1 of 3 policies) before or after making the repetition task. They are also asked to rank the policies as favorite, neither-favorite-nor-least-favorite and least favorite (hereafter F/∼/LF).
Therefore, there are 3 elements to this experiment: The repetition task, the 2 educational policy (3 scenarios) and the ranking over policies (F/∼/LF).

There are 4 groups. The control group and 3 different treatments.

Group I: Control Group. Teachers fill the repetition task and then select their preferences over the policies.

Group II: Policy treatment. Teachers are randomly assigned to one of the 3 policies. Then, they are asked to complete the repetition task. Finally, they choose their preferences over the policies

Group III: Revelation Treatment. Teachers are asked to fill their preferences first, and then they are randomly assigned to a policy. Finally, they fill the cards with the repetition task.

Group IV: Awareness Treatment. This treatment is identical to the revelation one with an additional (randomly assigned) priming sentence: ‘this is your F/∼/LF policy’.

Design details

Randomization method
Randomization by qualtrics
Randomization unit
There are no clusters of randomization.
Clusters
We have no estimates for the number of schools, but we will cluster at the school level.
Observations
Between 2500-7800 teachers
Arms
We consider 10 treatment arms with equal probabilities, thus we expect around 250 to 780 teachers in each arm
Primary outcomes
Teacher's hardness level contextualized by peers' decisions.

Cited by

No citation data available for this registration yet.

Keywords