Technology and Audit Interventions to Combat Theft in Pakistan's Power Sector
How to cite
Naeem, Muhammad Usman; Dobermann, Tim; Burgess, Robin; Greenstone, Michael; Hayat, Faraz. 2026. "Technology and Audit Interventions to Combat Theft in Pakistan's Power Sector." AEA RCT Registry. AEARCTR-0015084. https://doi.org/10.1257/rct.15084-1.0
Download: BibTeX · RIS — for reference managers without a browser translator. Zotero and most others pick up this page's citation metadata directly.
* Primary investigator
Abstract
Pakistan's power sector faces a severe fiscal crisis, with high rates of electricity theft and non-payment contributing to a circular debt at approximately 2.1% of GDP, that threatens the country's economic stability. This situation underscores the urgent need for scalable solutions to reduce losses and improve revenue recovery. Conducted in partnership with the Lahore Electric Supply Company (LESCO) and the Ministry of Energy, this study evaluates the comparative effectiveness of technological versus enforcement-based interventions in high-loss areas of Lahore.
Transformers are randomly allocated into three experimental groups to evaluate distinct anti-theft strategies. The first group (T1) receives the technological intervention of Aerial Bundled Cables (ABCs), a theft-resistant infrastructure designed to physically prevent unauthorized hook connections. The second group (T2) is subject to an enforcement intervention termed "enhanced combing," involving an increased frequency of audits where utility personnel actively identify theft, disconnect illegal users, and issue penalties. Finally, the control group serves as a baseline, maintaining status-quo operations to allow for comparative analysis of intervention effectiveness.
The primary objective is to measure both the short-term and sustained impacts of these interventions on electricity theft (losses), bill payment rates, and consumer regularization. By leveraging high-frequency administrative data from smart metering, the study tracks whether these strategies lead to lasting behavioral change. Key outcomes assessed include the rate of electricity theft (calculated as the difference between electricity supplied and billed), the non-payment rate, and shifts in consumer numbers and behaviors. Additional secondary outcomes, such as accumulated arrears, will also be examined using detailed administrative data provided by LESCO.
The findings from this evaluation will directly inform decisions by the Ministry of Energy and LESCO regarding the most cost-effective strategies for combating electricity theft and enhancing fiscal stability.
Intervention
(i) Technological Intervention (ABC): This arm involves the replacement of existing bare low-voltage distribution lines with insulated Aerial Bundled Cables (ABC). This infrastructure is designed to physically prevent the attachment of illegal hook connections (kundas) by shielding the live conductor, thereby increasing the cost and difficulty of electricity theft.
(ii) Enforcement Intervention (Combing): This arm implements enhanced combing, a rigorous enforcement regime characterized by high-frequency audits. Dedicated utility teams inspect the transformer perimeter to identify theft, dismantle illegal connections , and issue detection bills to offenders. This intervention tests the efficacy of administrative enforcement without infrastructure upgrades.
(iii) Control: A passive control group where transformers receive no new infrastructure or special audit teams, continuing with LESCO's standard operating procedures.
Experimental design
This study employs a cluster-randomized controlled trial (RCT) design to evaluate strategies for reducing electricity theft. The unit of randomization is the distribution transformer, representing a distinct neighborhood network. The study sample consists of 120 high-loss transformers selected from the Lahore Electric Supply Company (LESCO) service area .
To ensure balance, transformers were stratified by administrative circle (Eastern and Southern) and randomly assigned into three experimental arms (N=40 per arm):
(i) Technological Intervention: Replacement of bare wires with theft-resistant Aerial Bundled Cables (ABC).
(ii) Enforcement Intervention: Implementation of "enhanced combing," a high-frequency audit and disconnection drive.
(iii) Control: Continuation of status-quo utility operations.
High-frequency outcome data is collected via Advanced Metering Infrastructure (AMI) installed at the transformer level, complemented by monthly administrative billing and collection records. Evaluation relies exclusively on confidential administrative data already generated by LESCO. We assemble (i) a monthly transformer‑level panel tracking units supplied, units billed, and technical losses from the date each transformer was metered, and (ii) matched household‑level records of billing, payments, arrears, and consumption for every customer connected to study transformers. These data will continue to flow for at least 18 months after installation, allowing us to trace short‑ and medium‑run effects.
Design details
Cited by
No citation data available for this registration yet.